Jump to content

Do stops lead to fewer profitable trades?


Recommended Posts

Hi all,

I realise stops are there to allow you to set a risk/reward ratio but my question is whether your trade is much more likely to succeed if you don't have a stop or you use stops like an emergency stop i.e. the risk to reward is massive for any particular trade.  I've had many trades where i've set a stop and its been closed out because the market has turned but only just enough to hit my stop.  If i'd set the stop lower, with more time it would have been successful.  Perhaps its more about knowing where to set the stop based on the chart rather than being so concerned about the ratio itself?  So i'm not anti-stops by any means i realise they're essential especially if you can't monitor your positions constantly but having a higher risk-bigger stop or better positioning of it could increase chance of success?  Any opinions anyone on this? 

Also is there such a thing as having a probability of success on a trade?  I.e. if you have a low limit is the probability of success higher than a high limit e.g. 0.5 vs 20, time is also a factor on all of this.  Or do people just see the market as black and white up or down i.e. if its going up half a point its going to go up 10 points so whats the point of very low limits. Of course market conditions may also influence the probability, so i assume successful traders although they can't put a % probability on success they can read the market well enough that they can roughly say that there is likely a greater than 50% chance that any trade may be successful?  Sorry just rambling really.  I haven't invested hours and hours of reading so presumably there are answers to all of this and I need to read more.

Thanks for any comments in advance

 

Link to comment

Larry Connors did a study on this in the 90's (using stops or not)

I use stops - I just add a point or 2 to cover spreads etc

The markets are mathematical points of force, the laws of probability and probabilistic returns apply to trading - most people never get in sync with that hence the high failure rate

Dr. Van Tharps book "Trade your way to financial freedom" details probability, statistical returns, win distribution and risk brilliantly.

Hope it helps and good luck on your trading journey

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
13 minutes ago, THT said:

Larry Connors did a study on this in the 90's (using stops or not)

I use stops - I just add a point or 2 to cover spreads etc

The markets are mathematical points of force, the laws of probability and probabilistic returns apply to trading - most people never get in sync with that hence the high failure rate

Dr. Van Tharps book "Trade your way to financial freedom" details probability, statistical returns, win distribution and risk brilliantly.

Hope it helps and good luck on your trading journey

 

SSH!  Don't tell him, else he might STEAL it 🤣

Link to comment
6 hours ago, Acidtrip said:

The main job of a stop loss is to ensure you don't experience a monumental loss and wipe out your entire account. 

Yeah this is the conclusion I have come to, it doesn't mean there aren't big risks.

Link to comment
20 hours ago, u0362565 said:

I realise stops are there to allow you to set a risk/reward ratio but my question is whether your trade is much more likely to succeed if you don't have a stop

most people can get direction right but mess up the execution and so stops end many trades that would have come right but without stops and even with very large stops your whole account is at risk.

Many algos take a different path, they see direction and a likely entry point but instead of a stop put in a hedge if price turns against them and just wait, so the equal trade in the opposite direction keeps the PnL static until price turns in their favour once again or just abandon the trade.

However you choose to do it you must do something to cover bad execution.

20 hours ago, u0362565 said:

Also is there such a thing as having a probability of success on a trade? 

no, all trades have a probability of 50/50 which is why you need a repeatable process,  a strategy which you can test and prove positive expectancy over a number of trades (see thread 'Trade Planning and Testing').

 

Edited by Caseynotes
  • Great! 1
Link to comment
5 hours ago, Caseynotes said:

most people can get direction right but mess up the execution and so stops end many trades that would have come right but without stops and even with very large stops your whole account is at risk.

Many algos take a different path, they see direction and a likely entry point but instead of a stop put in a hedge if price turns against them and just wait, so the equal trade in the opposite direction keeps the PnL static until price turns in their favour once again or just abandon the trade.

However you choose to do it you must do something to cover bad execution.

no, all trades have a probability of 50/50 which is why you need a repeatable process,  a strategy which you can test and prove positive expectancy over a number of trades (see thread 'Trade Planning and Testing').

 

I'm sure you're right on the 50/50 but to someone not in the know if the conditions look favourable i.e. there is a trend in one direction and you go in that direction how does it not swing to be greater than 50/50.  Anyway sorry i will go read some more.  Also getting annoyed by not being able to close because of price movements in the market it says that can be the difference between profit and loss i have found out.  Whats the probability of success if the **** platform worked seamlessly i wonder.. 

  • Thought provoking 1
Link to comment
43 minutes ago, u0362565 said:

I'm sure you're right on the 50/50 but to someone not in the know if the conditions look favourable i.e. there is a trend in one direction and you go in that direction how does it not swing to be greater than 50/50.  Anyway sorry i will go read some more.  Also getting annoyed by not being able to close because of price movements in the market it says that can be the difference between profit and loss i have found out.  Whats the probability of success if the **** platform worked seamlessly i wonder.. 

The problem is that people think they are trading with IG but they're not, they're trading in a market via IG. This is not a computer game where if you push the A button there is an automatic result, when you shout out a bid at an auction you might get a fill or you might just get a round of laughter instead. So the platform is not always the problem. It's not up to IG to fill your orders, it's up to IG to try to get your orders filled by other market participants, if the market has stopped then the market has stopped and everyone has to wait for it to start up again.

There is also the problem of getting run over by the big boys who are able to step in and take out multiple levels with just a nod and suddenly the next best price is a very long way from your order.

Some might remember I wrote this awhile ago in response when someone asked 'is spread betting for fools?'

'I didn't realise I was competing in a two way auction, I thought I was just gambling like I do in Vegas where if the action is really hot and the big guys are throwing lots of money around and the spread is getting bigger and bigger then that is exactly the right time to jump in, boy was I suckered.'

Link to comment
54 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

of course, but perhaps you know different, you only trade with the trend so presumably your win rate is a lot higher than 50%? 🧐

Yes, the odds of being right are significantly less than 50% :D 

Link to comment
45 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

The problem is that people think they are trading with IG but they're not, they're trading in a market via IG. This is not a computer game where if you push the A button there is an automatic result, when you shout out a bid at an auction you might get a fill or you might just get a round of laughter instead. So the platform is not always the problem. It's not up to IG to fill your orders, it's up to IG to try to get your orders filled by other market participants, if the market has stopped then the market has stopped and everyone has to wait for it to start up again.

There is also the problem of getting run over by the big boys who are able to step in and take out multiple levels with just a nod and suddenly the next best price is a very long way from your order.

Some might remember I wrote this awhile ago in response when someone asked 'is spread betting for fools?'

'I didn't realise I was competing in a two way auction, I thought I was just gambling like I do in Vegas where if the action is really hot and the big guys are throwing lots of money around and the spread is getting bigger and bigger then that is exactly the right time to jump in, boy was I suckered.'

Yeah I'd completely disconnected from what's really happening. You're right its not a computer game!

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      21,599
    • Total Posts
      91,797
    • Total Members
      41,859
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Yabbie
    Joined 20/03/23 23:48
  • Posts

    • Elliott Wave Analysis TradingLounge Daily Chart, 21 March 23,   Ethereum/U.S.dollar(ETHUSD) ETHUSD Elliott Wave Technical Analysis  Function: Follow trend Mode: Motive Structure: Impulse Position: Wave III Direction Next higher Degrees: wave (I) of Motive Details: Wave 3 equals 1.618 multiplied Length of wave 1 at 2943.53 Wave Cancel invalid level: 1073.42 Ethereum/U.S.dollar(ETHUSD)Trading Strategy: Ethereum resumes its upward trend in wave III with a chance to reach the 161.8 level of wave I at 2943.53. Also, the price has risen above the MA200 line, giving the view to a continued upward trend in wave III. Ethereum/U.S.dollar(ETHUSD)Technical Indicators: The price is above the MA200 indicating an UpTrend. The wave oscillators above Zero-Line momentum are bullish. TradingLounge Analyst: Kittiampon Somboonsod, CEWA     Elliott Wave Analysis TradingLounge 4H Chart, 21 March 23,   Ethereum/U.S.dollar(ETHUSD) Elliott Wave Technical Analysis Function: Follow trend Mode: Motive Structure: Impulse Position: Wave (3) Direction Next higher Degrees: wave ((3)) of Motive Details: Wave 3 equals 1.618 multiplied Length of wave 1 at 2290 Wave Cancel invalid level: 1369 Ethereum/U.S.dollar(ETHUSD)Trading Strategy: Ethereum resumes its upward trend in wave (3) with a chance to reach the 161.8 level of wave (1) at 2290. Also, the price has risen above the MA200 line, giving the view to a continued upward trend in wave (3). Ethereum/U.S.dollar(ETHUSD)Technical Indicators: The price is above the MA200 indicating an UpTrend. The wave oscillators above Zero-Line momentum are bullish.
    • Content Bitcoin BTC/USD Summary 28,000, 30,000 and 33,000 are the resistance levels that fit in the Elliott Wave count. The current move up is in line with the bear market rally Elliott wave count I have for the NASDAQ that is also looking for a top around the 13,000. I suggest trading to these levels and exit and wait for the next set up either long or short. Elliott Wave I don't know if we are in a bullish market or a bear market rally Strategy: Trade to 30,000 and exit long trade Analyst Peter Mathers TradingLounge™   
    • Stock Market Daily Report: SP500, AAPL, TSLA, AMZN, NVDA, MSFT, META, NFLX, GOOGL, BAC Stock Market Content: SP500, Apple (AAPL),Tesla (TSLA), Amazon (AMZN), Nvidia (NVDA), Microsoft MSFT, Berkshire Hathaway (BRK/B), Block, Inc (SQ), Meta Platforms, Netflix (NFLX), Enphase (ENPH), Alphabet GOOGL and Bank of America BAC. Stock Market Summary: Day Traders stay long and Positions traders - we will be looking for the short trade set ups later in the week once I can confirm the top Elliott Wave Analysis: Waves fours and fives to top around Wed when the FOMC  Feds Funds Rate Trading Strategies: Day traders can continue to  trade higher Video Chapters 00:00 SP500 / NASDAQ 100 10:19 Apple (AAPL) 15:17 Amazon (AMZN) 19:23 NVIDIA (NVDA) 25:29 Meta Platforms (META) 30:46 Netflix (NFLX)  31:48 Enphase (ENPH) 36:30 Alphabet (GOOGL)  38:01 Microsoft (MSFT) 39:03 Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B) 42:12 Tesla (TSLA) 44:18 Block Inc. (SQ)  46:48 Bank of America BAC 52:16 Thanks for supporting Analyst Peter Mathers TradingLounge™     
×
×
  • Create New...