Jump to content
  • 0

IG and TradingView Charts Different


Lydia285

Question

Hi,

It seems that the charts on IG Web Platform vs. TradingView are quite different. 
See photo. Both taken at the same time.

- For charting on Tradingview, what should I use to be as accurate as possible? Example: FXCM / Forex.com / Oanda charts?
- Which candlestick countdown timer does IG platform follow?

@CharlotteIG

IG Chart 4H.JPG

TradingView Chart 4H.JPG

Link to comment

3 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 1
2 hours ago, Lydia285 said:

It seems that the charts on IG Web Platform vs. TradingView are quite different. 
See photo. Both taken at the same time.

- For charting on Tradingview, what should I use to be as accurate as possible? Example: FXCM / Forex.com / Oanda charts?
- Which candlestick countdown timer does IG platform follow?

Hi, there are a number of differences that will cause charts to look different.

The accurate chart to use is the broker's chart you are trading with, those are the prices on offer to you, no 2 brokers will offer the exact same prices at any one moment, they all track the underlying market but none can offer you the exact exchange price, all brokers source their prices from an array of different liquidity providers. 

The platform itself will handle data differently and will not look exactly the same as the broker's chart for the broker's data  Tradingview is displaying.

The time zones also cause the charts to look different, the other 3 brokers are US based while IG UK uses GMT (+1 in summer) while IG Australia uses Australian EST and I think IG US uses US Chicago. The time zones are stamped by the broker and can't be changed except through a third party platform like Tradingview or Prorealtime.

Different brokers also have different weekly opening, IG opens on Sunday evening so IG markets have 1, 2 or 3 hourly candles on a Sunday which creates an extra day and so both the price and indicator data will project differently onto a chart.

Hope this helps.

Link to comment
  • 0
7 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

Hi, there are a number of differences that will cause charts to look different.

The accurate chart to use is the broker's chart you are trading with, those are the prices on offer to you, no 2 brokers will offer the exact same prices at any one moment, they all track the underlying market but none can offer you the exact exchange price, all brokers source their prices from an array of different liquidity providers. 

The platform itself will handle data differently and will not look exactly the same as the broker's chart for the broker's data  Tradingview is displaying.

The time zones also cause the charts to look different, the other 3 brokers are US based while IG UK uses GMT (+1 in summer) while IG Australia uses Australian EST and I think IG US uses US Chicago. The time zones are stamped by the broker and can't be changed except through a third party platform like Tradingview or Prorealtime.

Different brokers also have different weekly opening, IG opens on Sunday evening so IG markets have 1, 2 or 3 hourly candles on a Sunday which creates an extra day and so both the price and indicator data will project differently onto a chart.

Hope this helps.

 

You're on a roll today, bonnie loon! 🤓

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      16,624
    • Total Posts
      79,343
    • Total Members
      65,118
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    SMogul
    Joined 01/12/21 23:58
  • Posts

    • Hello @SillyMilly I think you are referring to purchasing crypto for holding, like people who buy gold or silver as a store of value, while @MongiIG and @ArvinIG are referring to the activity of "trading" since IG is a trading platform, i.e. for those who want to buy and sell assets as a mean to make a profit. In that sense they are right in pointing out that the FCA (the Financial Conduct Authority (UK)) which is the main governing body for the financial sector (I believe) has ruled against the activity of trading cryptocurrencies for non-professionals. I think perhaps due to the very risky nature of trading in crypto, which are prone to extreme volatility. Having said all that, you can purchase crypto through an exchange. I am not sure if there are any legal restrictions in the UK, but I doubt it. I suggest you do a Google search for "Crypto Exchanges UK". Good luck
    • Hi I would like to buy a few gold sovereign coins to keep for a couple of years or so then sell on later in the hope of beating hyper inflation I was told not to buy them online or mail order because the postage is very expencive and I was told to buy them in person I live in Manchester, UK. Surgestions please on where to look if considering buying. Buying somewhere that is safe so I know I am getting real gold and somewhere that dose not charge an extortion on broker fees? I was also told to avoid jewelers has there transaction fees where extortion   Thanks
×
×
  • Create New...