Jump to content

Book cost - why it's changing?


Recommended Posts

Hi,

It seems that my book cost fluctuates. In order to calculate running P/L of the portfolio, the book cost should be fixed in the account native currency on time of purchase?

Why is it changing? Is it because at the time when I bough US shares the GBP/USD was different?

Also what does it mean when the book cost goes down in that scenario? Is it because NOW the GBP/USD is higher in value?

I guess book cost going down than what I actually aid for it, it means that I'm losing on the exchange rate  since I bought the shares respectively 

I bought US shares with my GBP account.

 

Many Thanks,

George

Edited by Georgi
Link to post

Will someone from the IG community answers the question why the book cost is not fixed in native currency at the state of the world = the time of purchase of foreign shears (the exchange rate at the time of purchase)?  This is the right thing to do, otherwise the running P/L is wrong.. 

Link to post
  • 5 months later...

I had the same question and after an unhelpful online chat, I sent email to the helpdesk.

Their reply after 3 days is as follows: Please be informed that the booking cost is fixed.
However, as you hold shares bought in a different currency than GBP, the conversion of that booking cost to GBP is fluctuation, therefore the the overall booking cost to GBP is also changing

I still fail to see how this can be the the case, given that when I bought the shares I was charged in GBP at the exchange rate at the time, and therefore the GBP book cost should not change.

I will go back and challenge their response, but I'm not holding out much hope  of geting a different response.


 

Link to post
  • 2 months later...

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      15,389
    • Total Posts
      73,866
    • Total Members
      62,267
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    endoftimer
    Joined 13/06/21 11:39
  • Posts

    • Fraud, corruption, censorship and the Covidian Cult.   ''The Wuhan/Covid fraud and corruption goes to the very top of the mainstream media establishment. Just in case that wasn't already obvious.''  zerohedge @zerohedge 'The @pulitzercenter is covering up its ties to @PeterDaszak and @EcoHealthNYC! They have removed him from the page of the 2016 conference on future pandemics, where Daszak revealed how his Chinese friends are building killer viruses.'   YouTube censorship ...   The rules are for Thee not for We.   And the 'We' are all in this together.   .
    • 10 years old and still just as relevant.  
    • Oh, so underlying conditions are significant now we have the vaccines, ''98% of ALL COVID-19 deaths in English hospitals were people with underlying conditions. The evening standard is trying to defend the vaccine by saying that the people who died with two doses had underlying health issues. See the problem?'' datatosee.com  @dontbetyet     MEANWHILE, - What? ''WHOA!! 73% *HIGHER* death rate in this vaccinated UK cohort compared to the unvaccinated (19/9344 vs 23/19573, p=0.07). Pause. We need more transparency on this data, not more politics with people ... misrepresenting the data.''  Dr Ah Kahn Syed @arkmedic   Also meanwhile, ''Pandemrix was pulled for causing narcolepsy in 20 in a million doses. The crude reporting rate for myocarditis is 35 per million doses for 16-17 year olds [covid vaccines] ''  Dr Clare Craig @ClareCraigPath  (Chart taken from FDA video below).        .
×
×
  • Create New...