Jump to content

DAX


Recommended Posts

41 minutes ago, HMB said:

No, I'm not.  And for that I have plenty of evidence.

 

I recommend using TradingView's 'replay' function to do 100 trades on past data.  I think it's free for daily replays, unfortunately you have to pay for intraday replays but you can get a free 30 day trial.

Link to post
  • 2 weeks later...
  • Replies 198
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

good luck though that's a pretty strong run back up to the pivot, wouldn't be willing to bet against it myself. certainly if the Dow heads lower dax likely to follow.

Look at how the Fibs line up with monthly Pivots here 🤓  

mate, your weakness is you've got a gambling addiction, the only way out is a rules based system that you can stick with because testing proves it works or just giving up and seeking professional help

Posted Images

  • 2 weeks later...

1389416678_Germany30_20201028_01_31.thumb.png.8e5db02ffc902e457ad4b99b80c7e1a1.png

 

...11% or so below post-outbreak high...  support around 12300-12350 couldn't stop the SAP move...  then high below that...

however complete undoing of overnight move to 12050 (or even 12200) and it would still be well in a pretty fast down-trend...  some signs of bottoming at current levels...

expecting slight rebound around the open, if that happens, and no more significant up move then, will likely close the trade at wherever it stabilizes in the very short term... 

 

also maybe useful to keep the composition in mind from time to time...:

 

image.png.7bd30461627e00fda5d1da7224c86950.png

 

 

Edited by HMB
Link to post
11 minutes ago, HMB said:

mean...  drop just below the overnight low on bar closing news...  stop hit, re-opened, as move seemed to halt..:786369572_Germany30_20201028_02_55.thumb.png.c0b80c94d23addabe9df55ee15bad111.png

stop hit again of course.  guess one to let play out for now.

Link to post
1 minute ago, HMB said:

ok, last try - using my own post above as counter indicator...:

need to be careful around 'news' events. sudden drop last hour caused by Merkel proposing a new 2 week circuit breaker lockdown for Germany.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Just now, Caseynotes said:

need to be careful around 'news' events. sudden drop last hour caused by Merkel proposing a new 2 week circuit breaker lockdown for Germany.

ok - thanks

Link to post

stop hit again...  the strategy with betting on short-term pre-market rebounds with tight stops at weak support levels just doesn't work.  likely it's gonna rebound on some point, but if that's from -2% or -2.8% I definitely don't know

 

another lesson (which I'll again try to learn...)  ...it's really about avoiding bad habits, isn't it.  amazing how unable to do that I seem to be

Link to post
2 minutes ago, HMB said:

stop hit again...  the strategy with betting on short-term pre-market rebounds with tight stops at weak support levels just doesn't work.  likely it's gonna rebound on some point, but if that's from -2% or -2.8% I definitely don't know

 

another lesson (which I'll again try to learn...)  ...it's really about avoiding bad habits, isn't it.  amazing how unable to do that I seem to be

trialing different strategies on demo and finding it doesn't work on a reasonable sample size no harm done. 

imho continuations are easier to play than trying to pick reversals.

  • Like 1
Link to post
12 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

trialing different strategies on demo and finding it doesn't work on a reasonable sample size no harm done. 

imho continuations are easier to play than trying to pick reversals.

I'm back to live trading, but with small sizes.  I need to learn to deal with emotions better, which doesn't work that well in demo (it does a bit though).  But now facing having my loss limit almost reached and then having to be able to stop trading for a month, although I think there might be nice opportunities, is an experience I didn't get in demo.

Think you are very right regarding continuations vs. reversals, in particular if the short-term trend is down and we are at medium term important levels (or through them) like DAX 12000...

Similarly useful assessment I heard, is some prefer trading the middle of the trend, not the beginning or end.

need to deeply, emotionally redefine what I perceive as opportunity.  I am too contrarian in the short term.  Very often too early.  But I guess this kind of "behavior re-modelling" will require receiving a few more punches - target for now is to keep them smaller, no matter what.

Maybe I move to ETFs for now - wider spreads, but a bit smaller minimum opening sizes.

Edited by HMB
Link to post
3 minutes ago, HMB said:

I'm back to live trading, but with small sizes.  I need to learn to deal with emotions better, which doesn't work that well in demo (it does a bit though).  But now facing having my loss limit almost reached and then having to be able to stop trading for a month, although I think there might be nice opportunities, is an experience I didn't get in demo.

Think you are very right regarding continuations vs. reversals, in particular if the short-term trend is down and we are at medium term important levels (or through them) like DAX 12000...

Similarly useful assessment I heard, is some prefer trading the middle of the trend, not the beginning or end.

need to deeply, emotionally redefine what I perceive as opportunity.  I am too contrarian in the short term.  Very often too early.  But I guess this kind of "behavior re-modelling" will require receiving a few more punches - target for now is to keep them smaller, no matter what.

Maybe I move to ETFs for now - wider spreads, but a bit smaller minimum opening sizes.

fine but the point is your system/strategy should be so well honed/defined that you only need to follow the process when the chart triggers it. If you are stuck trying to make decisions on the fly you are totally reliant on some inner skill/insight that you presumably don't have yet.

picking reversals can work but not usually by newbies hence 75% retail traders net short at any one time on the US indices in spite of multi year bull runs and not coincidental 75% retail traders lose money.

 

Link to post
1 minute ago, Caseynotes said:

fine but the point is your system/strategy should be so well honed/defined that you only need to follow the process when the chart triggers it. If you are stuck trying to make decisions on the fly you are totally reliant on some inner skill/insight that you presumably don't have yet.

picking reversals can work but not usually by newbies hence 75% retail traders net short at any one time on the US indices in spite of multi year bull runs and not coincidental 75% retail traders lose money.

 

sure, you are right, maybe I should consider trading only demo for years to come.  Or just let it be and live with the (colossal) failure.  Been thinking about that, and will keep doing so - and trading with small size for a while might actually convince me to stop.

I see value in using trading to develop self-control and other more general skills, though, which may be worth a regular small loss. But there may of course be better ways, or I'm wrong with this completely - haven't made up my mind about that, either, yet.

Regarding systems - I think I'm just too far away from that - be it personality, skills or  interests.  I have a hard time to imagine that I could come up with a set of so clearly defined rules when to enter trades that leave any judgment out of the equation, and then still be profitable.  I think if something like that existed, it would have been found by others already and should stop working soon - in particular nowadays with kinda unlimited computing power and AI.  And I don't have the skills to compete in that area.

For now I'm trying to just avoid mistakes (in particular stick to loss limits) and also be more conscious about what I'm doing (e.g. formulate reasons for entry and targets) - for any system development I guess these would also be very early steps.

Monthly loss limit just got hit - back with a new trade in four weeks..!

Link to post
2 minutes ago, HMB said:

sure, you are right, maybe I should consider trading only demo for years to come.  Or just let it be and live with the (colossal) failure.  Been thinking about that, and will keep doing so - and trading with small size for a while might actually convince me to stop.

I see value in using trading to develop self-control and other more general skills, though, which may be worth a regular small loss. But there may of course be better ways, or I'm wrong with this completely - haven't made up my mind about that, either, yet.

Regarding systems - I think I'm just too far away from that - be it personality, skills or  interests.  I have a hard time to imagine that I could come up with a set of so clearly defined rules when to enter trades that leave any judgment out of the equation, and then still be profitable.  I think if something like that existed, it would have been found by others already and should stop working soon - in particular nowadays with kinda unlimited computing power and AI.  And I don't have the skills to compete in that area.

For now I'm trying to just avoid mistakes (in particular stick to loss limits) and also be more conscious about what I'm doing (e.g. formulate reasons for entry and targets) - for any system development I guess these would also be very early steps.

Monthly loss limit just got hit - back with a new trade in four weeks..!

not too many people are successful just trying to second guess the market all the time, they tend to be successful because they have developed a system that they can operate without thinking and has a positive expectancy proved by ongoing testing.

Part of that testing is the demo stage and will prove many ideas wrong, finding something that survives demo may well take time but if does then move onto the live testing at minimal size.

That's the stage when you learn many lessons in actual trading that can never be learnt on demo but if you don't have any system at all then it resorts to just guessing and hoping and you will break yourself on it. 

Devise a system that can survive demo first and it might have a chance live. 

Link to post
13 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

not too many people are successful just trying to second guess the market all the time, they tend to be successful because they have developed a system that they can operate without thinking and has a positive expectancy proved by ongoing testing.

Part of that testing is the demo stage and will prove many ideas wrong, finding something that survives demo may well take time but if does then move onto the live testing at minimal size.

That's the stage when you learn many lessons in actual trading that can never be learnt on demo but if you don't have any system at all then it resorts to just guessing and hoping and you will break yourself on it. 

Devise a system that can survive demo first and it might have a chance live. 

You mean a system of precisely defined conditions based on observable, quantitative data (for example a purely technical trading system)?

Did you not just earlier (rightly) point out that one needs to be careful around news events?  And does this not involve a subjective component (judgment) that involves thinking and can only be tested within limits? 

 

Link to post
1 minute ago, HMB said:

You mean a system of precisely defined conditions based on observable, quantitative data (for example a purely technical trading system)?

Did you not just earlier (rightly) point out that one needs to be careful around news events?  And does this not involve a subjective component (judgment) that involves thinking and can only be tested within limits? 

 

if your system has a contingency for news or market open periods of high volatility fine.

What I meant by be careful was just put your hands in the air and step away from the key board!

  • Like 2
Link to post
Just now, Caseynotes said:

if your system has a contingency for news or market open periods of high volatility fine.

What I meant by be careful was just put your hands in the air and step away from the key board!

ok

Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      14,393
    • Total Posts
      70,976
    • Total Members
      59,486
    • Most Online
      5,137
      14/01/21 09:51

    Newest Member
    Couldbeanyone
    Joined 04/03/21 22:17
  • Posts

    • @Toppie_Australia If you want to trade crypto use a crypto broker such as FTX and Binance their quite reputable and their margins are hugely smaller than IG. Personally I don't like the Binance platform it's just too confusing to navigate around and their id verification is a nightmare (just don't even go there).  I prefer using the 3commas platform and use the API interface to connect my brokerage accounts.   
    • I think most professional traders have that methodology and mindset its what sets us apart from the rest I don't look at the VIX, as with cycles for you, the VIX isn't of interest to me, done perfectly well without the need for it so far and that won't change going forward  
    • Ultimately what ever happens regarding " cycles" will be of no help to me . I am my own trader    Re volatility , its my niche , My models pick up most swings high and low .  My methods are recactive not so much predictive .   Its doesnt matter where it goes as long as it goes  .  1 year predictions are just a little fun with no weight in my profitability . Most years are up so just on that you should be bullish year on year and you will be right more times than not  .  I dont care if i am right or wrong . I left my ego behind a while back  .  Vix hasnt been around long enough to have a handle on its efficacy but i have done studies on realised volatility back multi decades and i put some credence in my conclusion  , but once again it will have zero influence on my returns unlike most  . We know there are no absolutes in this game , just probabilities and possibilities , define the former and manage the latter and it takes care of itself   ..  rock on   Wise words 
×
×
  • Create New...