Jump to content
  • 0

Discrepancy of profits quoted on IG pre sale and after?


Gold_Coast

Question

Hey All - new here, hope you are well. I was hoping someone could help with a question I have please..

I am from the UK and only traded US stocks on IG. I noticed that the actual profits I get from selling my shares are 50%+ less than what IG quotes just prior selling underneath all my positions. I managed to screenshot everything when I sold out all my positions on 30 Nov.

I understand there are currency charges and trade commissions, and of course trade depends on the exchange rate. However, I just can't get my head around how this is happening. Would appreciate if people could share their views and expertise please.

 
 
(1) Profit information quoted PRIOR to selling the shares on 30 Nov on IG - £1,094.96
WhatsApp Image 2020-12-05 at 17.00.34.jpeg
 
(2) Based on the screenshot info above, decision was made to sell whole portfolio BUT total profits received post sale were only - £635, ALMOST 60% less
 
WhatsApp Image 2020-12-05 at 17.00.34 (1).jpeg
 
WhatsApp Image 2020-12-05 at 17.00.34 (3).jpeg
 
WhatsApp Image 2020-12-05 at 17.00.34 (2).jpeg
 
I would like to point out as well that the sale prices I got were mostly higher than on the first screenshot, yet profits received were still so much smaller.
 
 
Even JUST using Lululemon as an example here, this is just ridiculous - pre-sale profit was $288.90 USD on first screenshot (say £200 being generous with the exchange rate), and I just cannot fathom how it ended up being only £58.80 post sale, surely the currency rate, fees and commissions don't amount to the £100+ void here?
 
Thank you for your help in advance.
Link to comment

3 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
On 05/12/2020 at 18:14, Gold_Coast said:

Hey All - new here, hope you are well. I was hoping someone could help with a question I have please..

I am from the UK and only traded US stocks on IG. I noticed that the actual profits I get from selling my shares are 50%+ less than what IG quotes just prior selling underneath all my positions. I managed to screenshot everything when I sold out all my positions on 30 Nov.

I understand there are currency charges and trade commissions, and of course trade depends on the exchange rate. However, I just can't get my head around how this is happening. Would appreciate if people could share their views and expertise please.

 
 
(1) Profit information quoted PRIOR to selling the shares on 30 Nov on IG - £1,094.96
WhatsApp Image 2020-12-05 at 17.00.34.jpeg
 
(2) Based on the screenshot info above, decision was made to sell whole portfolio BUT total profits received post sale were only - £635, ALMOST 60% less
 
WhatsApp Image 2020-12-05 at 17.00.34 (1).jpeg
 
WhatsApp Image 2020-12-05 at 17.00.34 (3).jpeg
 
WhatsApp Image 2020-12-05 at 17.00.34 (2).jpeg
 
I would like to point out as well that the sale prices I got were mostly higher than on the first screenshot, yet profits received were still so much smaller.
 
 
Even JUST using Lululemon as an example here, this is just ridiculous - pre-sale profit was $288.90 USD on first screenshot (say £200 being generous with the exchange rate), and I just cannot fathom how it ended up being only £58.80 post sale, surely the currency rate, fees and commissions don't amount to the £100+ void here?
 
Thank you for your help in advance.

Hey, 

With US shares if you're on our manual conversion your commission should be £10 on the open and close for this share. So £20 needs to be taken into consideration for the commission. 

With the exchange rates you can find them on your order history so you can see the rate you were converted at. 

Unfortunately I can't post data that's personal to your account. If you're struggling to work out what happened with your position you can email us asking for a breakdown and we will be able to go step by step and break down all charges relating to a line of stock you purchased and sold. 

Sorry I couldn't help more with this. 

All the best 

 

Link to comment
  • 0

Thanks @CharlotteIG for your response.

I am fully aware of the commission as well as the exchange rate as posted in the screenshots above. I have gone through my statements and understand the breakdown.

My question is why my overall profits are so inflated / overstated on the IG screen? This is very mis-leading and causes clients to sell thinking they would get X amount of profit but actually they end up with only 40% of that. What is the reason behind the huge discrepancy?

I did e-mail so am waiting for a full response hopefully too.

Link to comment
  • 0
On 09/12/2020 at 09:55, Gold_Coast said:

Thanks @CharlotteIG for your response.

I am fully aware of the commission as well as the exchange rate as posted in the screenshots above. I have gone through my statements and understand the breakdown.

My question is why my overall profits are so inflated / overstated on the IG screen? This is very mis-leading and causes clients to sell thinking they would get X amount of profit but actually they end up with only 40% of that. What is the reason behind the huge discrepancy?

I did e-mail so am waiting for a full response hopefully too.

Hey @Gold_Coast

You're right if you have instant conversion rates on your trades and the profit is 40% different then there is a problem. I will speak to our client facing team and ask them to pick the email us as soon as possible. They will be able to take a deeper dive into what has happened. 

I hope you get the outcome/ answers and it would be great if you could share them once you do. 

All the best 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      20,104
    • Total Posts
      88,179
    • Total Members
      69,098
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Protato
    Joined 04/10/22 18:59
  • Posts

    • Stocks: AAPL, AMZN, NVDA, TSLA, GOOGL, BRK.B, SQ, META, NFLX, ENPH, MSFT, BAC, JPM. Elliott Wave  SP500 US Stock Bear Market: AMZN, AAPL, NVDA, TSLA, GOOGL, BRK.B, SQ, META, NFLX, ENPH, MSFT, BAC, JPM, GS. Elliott Wave Technical Analysis  Stock Market News: Stocks rise, however the move up continue to move up on lower volume, divergence and corrective bear market rally, that should complete in the next trading session Stock Market Summary Elliott Wave Count: Elliott Wave Analysis - (iv) of c) of 4 of (1) Analysis US Stocks: Tesla TSLA, Amazon AMZN, Nvidia (NVDA), Apple AAPL, Microsoft MSFT, Berkshire Hathaway (BRK/B),Block, Inc (SQ), Meta Platforms, Netflix (NFLX), Enphase (ENPH), Alphabet GOOGL. XFL Finance Sector ETF, JPMorgan JPM & Bank of America BAC, Goldman Sachs Group Inc (GS) Stock Market Trading strategies: Looking to short the top and turn in the trading session Video Chapters 00:00 SP500 06:58 Apple (AAPL) 12:22 NVIDIA (NVDA) 14:40 Amazon (AMZN) 18:35 Meta Platforms (META) 20:17 Netflix (NFLX)  21:41 Enphase (ENPH) 24:14 Tesla (TSLA) 27:59 Alphabet (GOOGL)  30:35 Microsoft (MSFT) 31:31 Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B) 32:33 Block Inc. (SQ)  33:38 Banks JPM, GS 36:14 End. Thanks for supporting! US Stocks: Basic Elliott Wave Counts Apple AAPL  Elliott Wave 4  Corrective rally Amazon AMZN  Elliott Wave 4 Nvidia (NVDA) Elliott Wave  ii) Berkshire Hathaway BRK/B Elliott Wave 4 Alphabet GOOGL  Elliott Wave 4 Meta Platforms FB Elliott Wave iv) Netflix (NFLX)  Microsoft MSFT  Elliott Wave 4 Tesla TSLA  Elliott Wave iii) Square SQ /Block Inc. Elliott Wave 4 JPMorgan Chase (JPM) Elliott Wave 4 Analyst Peter Mathers TradingLounge™ Australian Financial Services Licence - AFSL 317817 Source: tradinglounge com  
    • US DOLLAR TALKING POINTS: The US Dollar has dropped by as much as 3.3% from the high that was set last Wednesday and many are asking if the USD has topped. Given how aggressively overbought the greenback had become, this retracement looks to be a correction in the trend with no evidence yet of anything larger. However – price is approaching some major supports and performance around those levels will be key for determining near-term strategy. Of particular importance is the fact that the US Dollar is a composite of global currencies so the bigger question is when sell-offs in EUR/USD or GBP/USD might return and, in a related item, how will USD/JPY hold up with the pair pegged to the 145 level thought to be the line-in-the-sand for Japan’s Ministry of Finance? Oct 4, 2022 | Full article on DailyFX James Stanley, Senior Strategist
    • EUR/USD and GBP/USD edge up while USD/JPY falters at ¥145.00 again A pause in the dollar rally sees USD/JPY stuck below recent highs, but both the euro and sterling have made gains in early trading against the greenback.    Chris Beauchamp | Chief Market Analyst, London | Publication date: Tuesday 04 October 2022  EUR/USD rebound continues After falling to a twenty-year low last month, the euro continues to rebound against the US dollar with EUR/USD. This still looks very much like a counter-trend bounce that sees the price head back to the 50-day simple moving average (SMA), currently $1.1018 and then begins to falter. This would be in line with previous bounces since April, all of which have found it impossible to hold above the 50-day SMA. This move could see the price head back to $1.01. Further targets lie at $1.02 and then $1.0374. Source: ProRealTime GBP/USD recovers $1.13 The GBP/USD continues to defy the doomsters with a recovery above $1.13. Its own counter-trend bounce remains intact, and if previous bounces are any guide there is still some potential for upside, even if it only reaches the 50-day SMA. Like EUR/USD, the pound is still making lower highs and lower lows against the dollar, with the previous peak at $1.176 marking out the initial target for this bounce. Both stochastics and moving average convergence/divergence (MACD) have room to move up to support this move, but selling the rallies still appears to be the approach here for this downtrending market, although it looks like for now there is still a desire to push the pair higher in the short-term. Source: ProRealTime USD/JPY stalls below ¥145.00 It does look like ¥145.00 is the ceiling in USD/JPY for the time being – repeated attempts to break higher have come to naught, despite the continued strength of the US dollar. Indeed, it is perhaps precisely that we need a pullback in order for the trend to revive. The pair rallied hard from the August-lows, and now sits at some distance from the 50-day SMA (currently ¥139.15). A pullback towards this level might ‘clear the air’, create a higher low and provide a springboard for fresh bullish momentum. Source: ProRealTime
×
×
  • Create New...