Jump to content
  • 0

PRT 10.3 and IG Trailing Stop Woes


Guest NickWallbridge

Question

Guest NickWallbridge

I have been using PRT for sometime now with various strategies. I started using PRT because it is part of the IG package, but the integration between the two seems to be woeful.

 

I have been trying to get a strategy with Trailing Stops to work.  Should be a piece of cake, simply put something like

 

BUY TradeNo CONTRACT AT MARKET
SET STOP pTRAILING 13

 

Setup your entries code and off you go. Did lots of backtesting on the EUR/GBP mini market and then set it live.

 

Problem 1 - The Minimum stop distance keeps changing. Between yesterday and today it went from 5 to 15 and back to 5 again.  This meant that while it was at 15 my strategy was stopped because my code which happened to be at 13 (8:58 BST 23/5/2017).  As far as I can tell there is no way to get the minimum stop distance from IG in the PRT code so the first thing you know your AUTOMATED strategy has stopped is if you go in and look! This really isn't very good. The whole point of an automated strategy is fire and forget at least for a while.

 

So I re-coded to use 16, re-tested and off we went.

 

Problem 2 - The Step distance apparently can't be set in PRT and differs between backtest and live.  As far as I can tell and from info on this forum (https://community.ig.com/t5/Charts/PRT-Automated-trading-issues-and-suggestions/td-p/1388) when PRT backtests it uses a step of 1 (or the same as the initial value?) and when it is live, the step is the minimum for the market, which was now back at 5 (16:31 BST 23/5/2017). So all the Backtesting is invalidated. This makes creating and testing a strategy akin to shooting at a moving target, blindfolded.

 

As IG are clearly promoting PRT (it is now upfront on the dashboard), surely these things ought not to be the case? If  PRT 10.3 can find out the current minimum stop (why does it change anyway?) and if the step can be set in backtesting to match live I would be grateful to know how? 

Link to comment

1 answer to this question

Recommended Posts

Hi . You are right that the PRT auto trailing stop is difficult to manage. I see (via your link)   has noted difficulties between backtest and live previously.

The minimum stop level does increase in accordance with increased volatility such as caused by a news event or data release, the increased volatility also increases the spread and the prospect of, and degree of, potential slippage. I presume IG would respond by saying all they could do to avert increases would be to set everything higher in the first place.

In my experience the live auto trailing stop seems to be stepped by 5's, so if set at 6 will step up in the next level up (10's). I agree there is a lack of flexibility and a lack of clarity which is why I only use it occasionally. 

Hopefully Stef can shed more light on the automated strategy and backtest issues. 

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • image.png

  • Posts

    • KO Elliott Wave Analysis Trading Lounge The Coca-Cola Company (KO): Daily Chart Mode: Impulsive Structure: Motive Position: Wave 5 Direction: Top in wave 5 Details: Looking for a clear five-wave move into Intermediate wave (1) to be either completed or near completion as we have reached the medium level at $65.   The Coca-Cola Company (KO): 4H Chart Mode: Impulsive Structure: Motive Position: Wave 5 Direction: Top in wave 5 Details: Looking for either a top in wave 5 as we can count a five-wave move from the bottom in the triangle in wave 4, or else we just completed wave {i} of 5.   Welcome to our latest Elliott Wave analysis for The Coca-Cola Company (KO) as of July 23, 2024. This analysis provides an in-depth look at KO's price movements using the Elliott Wave Theory, helping traders identify potential opportunities based on current trends and market structure. We will cover insights from both the daily and 4-hour charts to offer a comprehensive perspective on KO's market behavior. KO Elliott Wave Technical Analysis – Daily Chart The daily chart indicates a clear five-wave move into Intermediate wave (1), which is either completed or near completion as the price has reached the medium level around $65. Traders should watch for signs of a potential top in wave 5, as this could indicate the end of the current bullish phase and the beginning of a corrective phase. KO Elliott Wave Technical Analysis – 4H Chart The 4-hour chart shows that a five-wave move can be counted from the bottom of the triangle in wave 4, suggesting that wave 5 might be completed or wave {i} of 5 is completed. This indicates that traders should be cautious of a potential top formation and be prepared for a possible corrective move.   Technical Analyst : Alessio Barretta Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!  
    • Semiconductor shares rebounded in Asia overnight but weaker commodity prices cast a gloom over the session. Disappointment over the lack of any major growth initiatives at China's recent Plenum have left indices there rudderless, while a strengthening yen has hobbled the Nikkei 225's rebound. Attention now turns to earnings from Tesla and Alphabet, following on from Netflix last week. These two member of the 'Magnificent 7' will set the tone for the rest of the week. Kamala Harris has achieved enough support to be the Democrat nominee, while raising a record $81 million in donations in 24 hours. Markets continue to await fresh polling on a contest between Donald Trump and the incumbent vice-president. 
    • KOSPI Composite Day Chart Analysis Elliott Wave Analysis by Trading Lounge Function: Counter Trend Mode: Corrective Structure: Gray Wave 2 Position: Orange Wave 3 Next Higher Degrees Direction: Gray Wave 3 Wave Cancel Invalid Level: 2551.59 The KOSPI Composite day chart analysis employs Elliott Wave Theory to provide a detailed examination of market movements. The primary function of the current movement is a counter trend, indicating a move against the primary trend. Mode and Structure: The current mode is corrective, indicating a retracement or consolidation. The structure analyzed is Gray Wave 2, a corrective wave within the larger Elliott Wave framework. Current Position: The market is currently within Orange Wave 3, the third wave of a higher-degree sequence in the orange wave category. According to Elliott Wave Theory, Wave 3 often shows strong, impulsive characteristics. Next Higher Degrees: The direction for the next higher degrees is towards Gray Wave 3. After completing the corrective phase of Gray Wave 2, the market is expected to transition into Gray Wave 3, which is anticipated to be an impulsive wave, resuming the primary trend direction. Details: Following Gray Wave 1, the market is now in the corrective phase of Gray Wave 2 of 3. This phase is crucial as it sets up the market for the next significant move, Gray Wave 3 of 3. Gray Wave 2 is a preparatory phase leading to the next impulsive phase. Wave Cancel Invalid Level: The critical wave cancel invalid level is set at 2551.59. If the market falls below this threshold, the current wave analysis would be invalidated, requiring a reevaluation of the wave count. Summary: The KOSPI Composite day chart indicates that the market is in a corrective phase, identified as Gray Wave 2 within Orange Wave 3. The next expected move is a transition into Gray Wave 3, which is anticipated to resume the primary trend. The wave cancel invalid level is set at 2551.59, serving as a key point for validating or invalidating the current wave structure.   KOSPI Composite Weekly Chart Analysis Elliott Wave Analysis by Trading Lounge Function: Trend Mode: Impulsive Structure: Orange Wave 3 Position: Navy Blue Wave 3 Next Lower Degrees Direction: Orange Wave 4 Wave Cancel Invalid Level: 2551.59 The KOSPI Composite weekly chart analysis utilizes Elliott Wave Theory to understand market behavior. The function of the current movement is identified as a trend, indicating alignment with the primary direction of the established trend. Mode and Structure: The current mode is impulsive, suggesting strong, directional market moves. The structure under analysis is Orange Wave 3, a significant and typically powerful wave within the broader Elliott Wave sequence. Current Position: The market is currently within Navy Blue Wave 3, a major phase in the market cycle characterized by substantial moves and increased trading activity. Next Lower Degrees: The direction for the next lower degrees is towards Orange Wave 4. After completing the impulsive phase of Orange Wave 3, the market is expected to enter a corrective phase, identified as Orange Wave 4, which will likely retrace some gains made during Orange Wave 3. Details: Orange Wave 2 appears to be completed, setting the stage for the current phase, Orange Wave 3 of 3. This phase is crucial as it represents a strong, impulsive move within the broader trend, often marked by significant price movements and increased volatility. Wave Cancel Invalid Level: The critical wave cancel invalid level is set at 2551.59. If the market falls below this threshold, the current wave analysis would be invalidated, necessitating a reevaluation of the wave count. Summary: The KOSPI Composite weekly chart analysis indicates that the market is in an impulsive phase, identified as Orange Wave 3 within Navy Blue Wave 3. The next expected move is a transition into Orange Wave 4, which will be a corrective phase. The wave cancel invalid level is set at 2551.59, serving as a key point for validating or invalidating the current wave structure.   Technical Analyst : Malik Awais Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!  
×
×
  • Create New...
us