Jump to content

IG Tool Bar issues - can anyone help me understand this?


Recommended Posts

Screen Shot 2017-11-08 at 11.07.00.png

I am new to IG and have just received the invite to enter the competition to post on here and I guess I am shooting myself in the foot for posting something negative but this is something I really do not understand can exist.  

 

In short in the UK we pay Stamp Duty and this adds to our purchase price (0.5%) along with the commission we pay IG.   However, for some reason IG do not include this value in the Book Cost.   Consequently the Profit/Loss on your open position does not take these costs into account and so when looking at your Open Position it shows a better P/L position than actually exists?    

 

When I brought this up I was informed I could edit the Book Cost to include all my costs?   This is is not automation as I know it and really annoying.   On my current position with one stock I have have bought 3 times at different prices and each time I have had to re-calculate the book price in order to get the Profit and Loss calculation to work.

 

Please can anyone out there provide me with a solution to this nightmare?   

 

Thanks

Link to comment

Hi,

 

Welcome to IG community. We take the number of shares x the executed price. This is designed to show the real P/L based on the buy and sell price to avoid any potential confusion. The commission and stamp duty are shown on the trading ledger. We are more than happy to take your feedback and pass it on to the relevant team.

 

Thanks,

Claire

Link to comment

How can that be the real profit and loss when you have not taken into account the full cost of the transaction?   You actually have to still calculate if you are actually making any money.    You are saying you have to go to the trading ledger, add up all the values for multiple transactions and then take a look at what the potential sale figure will be to work out your gain?   I am only here because Barclays completely self imploded and now have a system which can not give me an indication of how well I am doing because apparently people only want to know a figure which only gives part of the picture?   I should add that when I joined up I did report this and was told it would be fixed within 2 weeks.   That didn't happen.   Am I the only person here?????   LOL.   Makes me laugh, a sad laugh.....

Link to comment

Hi  

 

I can certainly understand your point of view, however I believe the current platforms layout and logic makes sense. Although factors such as tax and commissions are important to remember when looking at net profits/loses, the layout of the platform supports how we currently have it set up. Let me try and explain the reasoning. 

 

The platform shows the number of shares you've purchased and the direct market average price which you have received. Shares x Average Price therefore = Book Cost. If this book cost figure automatically took into account commissions etc then it wouldn't follow on from the number of shares and average price. Further more it would only include opening commission and taxes and omit any potential closing costs.

 

It would be far more complicated to have book cost = number of shares x average price - commission and taxes on the opening trade, but omit the closing trade costs. 

 

For this reason we quote the book cost as the book cost of the actual asset, and then allow you to take into account the commissions and taxes yourself. You can then edit this forward looking and speculative to take into account potential costs of the closing trade for a true reflection of the net profit / loss of the deal. 

 

I hope that clarifies our reasoning. 

 

EDIT: also don't feel like expressing your own opinion or asking a question would be seen as a negative on IG Community. The whole goal and aim of our forum is to provide an open and transparent area for clients to discuss trade idea, ask questions and submit feedback. All the best. :) 

Link to comment
  • 2 years later...

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      15,715
    • Total Posts
      75,168
    • Total Members
      63,173
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    OTG
    Joined 03/08/21 14:37
  • Posts

    • Oh for God's sake people, it's not difficult, look, - Fauci says that because of the delta variant everyone has to wear a mask again, - so Oz locksdown and introduces a $5500 fine if not wearing a mask when outdoors, - while Biden's covid advisor says “as we know today, many of the face cloth coverings that people wear are not very effective at reducing any of the virus movement in or out”, - while Biden says the vax bribes aren't working so we must have stronger 'incentives' for vax uptake, - while Johnson says it's not the vaccines that brought cases down, it was the lockdowns, - but Sweden has no lockdowns, no business closures, no masks and no covid deaths.   I just don't understand why people are so confused??? 👀 Sweden: Despite Variants, No Lockdowns, No Daily Covid Deaths – AIER        
    • EUR/USD, GBP/USD and AUD/USD gain ground in early trade EUR/USD, GBP/USD and AUD/USD on the rise, but questions remain for the Australian dollar despite hawkish RBA stance. Source: Bloomberg   Forex United States dollar Australian dollar Euro EUR/USD GBP/USD  Joshua Mahony | Senior Market Analyst, London | Publication date: Tuesday 03 August 2021  EUR/USD awaits breakout from continuation pattern EUR/USD is trading within a pennant formation, with the pair pausing after the gains seen last week. To the upside, we do need to keep an eye out for a potential break through the $1.1897 level as a signal that we are set for another leg higher. Meanwhile, a drop back below $1.185 would point towards a deeper pullback coming into play.   Source: ProRealTime GBP/USD turning higher after 76.4% pullback GBP/USD has started to regain bullish momentum following a retracement into the 76.4% Fibonacci level at $1.3876. The ongoing uptrend points towards a bullish session ahead, with a positive outlook in play unless the price drops below $1.3843.   Source: ProRealTime AUD/USD back into confluence of resistance AUD/USD has been on the rise overnight, with a hawkish Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) stance bringing gains for the Australian dollar. However, that takes us into the confluence of 61.8% and trendline resistance. With the trend of lower highs in place, this recent grind higher still looks like a potential precursor to further weakness unless the price breaks up through the $0.7503 swing-high. Source: ProRealTime
    • Gold and Brent crude start to regain ground after Monday weakness Gold and Brent crude look to regain ground after recent weakness, but do recent losses point towards further downside to come? Source: Bloomberg  Joshua Mahony | Senior Market Analyst, London | Publication date: Tuesday 03 August 2021  Gold attempting to regain ground after 61.8% retracement Gold has started to steady itself after the recent decline into the 61.8% Fibonacci support level at $1806. Coming off the back of a rally into the $1834 region, there is a chance we could see the bulls come back into play before long. Greater confidence comes into play with a rise through $1819 bringing greater confidence that this pullback is over. Ultimately this current pullback does look like a retracement and precursor to further gains unless price drops back below the $1790 support level. Source: ProRealTime Brent crude starts to gain strength after decline into key support Brent crude has been on the back foot in the beginning of the week, with price falling back down into the $7214 support level established last Monday. The decline through $73.12 does raise question marks over the potential for further downside following the recent breakdown. A break below the $72.14 level would bring greater confidence in a more protracted breakdown. Nonetheless, for the time being, we are seeing the bulls come back into play as price aims to regain ground lost yesterday. Source: ProRealTime   See opportunity on a commodity?  
×
×
  • Create New...