Jump to content

Stops being closed by sudden price movements


Recommended Posts

  • 1 month later...

Impossible. Pricing is the market the whole world trades on... you just execute otc as a derivative. Unless your trade was posted to the market and there’s algos out there going for themwhich I doubt.

 

If you tell us what market / time / price etc then someone will probs be able to help :)

Link to comment

Hi there manwithbitcoin,

 

After many years of trading, all I can tell you is this. Although it seems as though the market is taking out your stops on purpose, it is all just basic movements which on many occasions seem to be basically just focussed on you.

 

I can guarantee that they are not.

 

The number of times I have had stops set which have been touched, just for the price to move in exactly the opposite way, are impossible to count. I am absolutely certain many others in the community have had periods of time where they felt exactly the same way.

 

The truth is that it is actually just a failure of our imperfect human mind. It is our tendency to dwell on and remember the 'unfair' and the 'failures', which until this point in time has helped us to survive. In trading you want to overcome this ingrained instinct.

 

Just remember, for every screw-up, ther will be 10 other opportunities. Look for them instead.

 

Cheers, Dan

Link to comment

Hi all. I just wanted to reiterate a point to follow on from  - when a stop is filled or a trade executed by IG, everyone else is also getting the same fill (if appropriate and the large size of consolidated client trades requires us to go to market with different orders) and the figure can be traced to the underlying market. 

 

For example, say you are in a Long position and another client is Short. You have you stop further down the market, and there is a sell off which causes your sell order to close to get triggered. Say hypothetically the other client has their take profit limit at the same level (when taking spread into consideration). Say also at these levels there are other buy orders from other clients. All of these would triggered. Your trade would realise it's loss, the short trader would realise his gain, and the clients looking to buy to open would all be filled (when taking spread into account).

 

The market then rebounds and moves up. Although this is frustrating for you it's important to remember 1) everyone was filled at the same prices when taking spread into account irrespective of the trade direct, 2) IG have no ideas what-so-ever on the direction which the market will take when we fill your trade. You have simply given us an instruction via an order, and we have executed it to the best of our ability basis the underlying market price and conditions at the time. There is no subjectivity in it.

 

If you would like a specific overview of the market price at that time, please get in contact via helpdesk@ig.com and someone will be able to provide evidence of this. You can also check out the Deal Execution Summary which is important to understand. Any questions, please add them below. 

Link to comment

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      15,725
    • Total Posts
      75,212
    • Total Members
      63,202
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    yellowsub
    Joined 05/08/21 08:36
  • Posts

    • SAGE modellers predicted 100,000 cases a day if restrictions were lifted. Wrong again. ''over 1,200 so-called experts signed ‘the Declaration’ – cooked up by the same people behind the John Snow Memorandum – warning of the terrible effect easing coronavirus restrictions on July 19th would have. The Declaration originally took the form of a letter in the Lancet, published on July 7th, in which 120 self-described ‘scientists’, many of them members of Independent SAGE, described ‘Freedom Day’ as “dangerous and premature”.  Have 1,200 Experts Ever Been Proved Wrong So Quickly? – The Daily Sceptic The reality is that a lot of modern science has been corrupted and no longer works for enquiry but now works for pay masters with an agenda, entire scientific fields have become completely politicised and scientists themselves acting to shut down and deplatform differing opinion. The exact opposite as to what science is supposed to be about. The start of the next flu season begins in a few months so all the BS will start all over again.     Meanwhile, @Virg2101 THIS is what living with the virus looks like. Sweden still has positive cases - 463/day - but its people are trusted & respected by the Government. 41% of the population is fully vaxxed with no lockdowns, divisive coercion, unvaxxed segregation or relentless campaign of fear.    
    • For more up to date news on how markets will open, the latest earnings and economic news, watch IGTV live in the platform at 07:30am UK. Today’s coverage:   Team GB 4th in medals table at Tokyo 2020 Indices: CAC hits 20yr high as Europe overall expected to open mixed. Asia mostly up, ASX200 new record high. FTSE250, yesterday hi t a new record high FX: Watching sterling ahead of Bank of England rate decision at noon. USD received a boost as more Fed commentators indicate bullish commentary Equities: UBER multi-month low as costs outweigh good Q2 earnings. SIE raises guidance. Watching RR AIG today Commods: Brent tests $70 support
    • Hi all, Could you please check in My IG > Settings > Prices & dealing alerts: You can check if the alerts are correctly set up on that screen. If you have set up your alerts on a mobile app you might need to setup the alerts on the web platform as they won't carry over.  We are working on syncing both alerts across. All the best - Arvin
×
×
  • Create New...