Jump to content

Stopped out even though price didn't actually reach the stop level?


Guest effortless

Recommended Posts

Guest effortless

Hi All

 

I entered a short trade on NOKSEK last Friday 23rd March 22:14:07.

 

The history shows I was stopped out at 1.06629.  But when you look at the pricing action from the time I entered the trade to now, the pricing action didn't even go to 1.06629. The highest it went was 1.06620. 

 

So can someone please tell me why my trade closed at 1.06629 when pricing action didn't even reach that point? 

 

Thanks

Daniel

 

 

Link to comment
  • 2 months later...

James you didn't correct me on the above reply. I've just been told when you are short it's the bid price you should be looking at. Please recheck this and reply with the correct answer. You should not allow people to give wrong advice to others. Thanks

Link to comment

The charts will show either the bid, mid or ask. This is the sell (bid) price, the mid price, and the buy (ask) price respectively. 

The original question was referring to an open trade which was short and had an attached stop. Therefore you do need to look at buying back to close, and you do need to be looking at the ask price. The post you made was correct in this context and therefore you didn't need correcting.

I believe you may now be referring to the opening of a new trade? If this is the case and you have a working order to sell (which is different from this threads original query), then yes - you will need to be looking at the bid price. 

Link to comment

Hi @Situation, it's not really surprising this one comes up so often as it's so easy to get spun around as you just found having given the correct answer first time then getting mixed up, I hope all my posts don't get vetted.

 

To get into a trade you need to buy the ask or sell the bid.

To get into a short you sell the bid. To get out of your short you need to do the opposite and buy the ask.

 

Link to comment

No worries @Situation - that's exactly what the community is for! A bit of back and forwards chat, and any clarification where needed. We all get things wrong sometimes and it's very possible that I could have misphrased or misinterpreted something, so always call me / any other moderator or staff out on it if it's not expressly clear. 

Have a good day all ?
*mini fist pump*

Link to comment
  • 1 month later...

Hi, I have a similar problem. I bought sugar at 1125 with a stop of 16 points... so it should only be triggered at 1109.  However, when I logged in this morning I found it was stopped at 1110. When I did a mouse over the last bar, it said lowest was 1110... so do you mean to say that the stop should actually be lower than 1109 to take into account the spread?

Link to comment

Hi @CKau,  you were stopped out at 1109, you were long so your example is the opposite to the one above in this thread, so to get into your long you had to buy the ask and to get out (your stop) you had to sell the bid.

As you can see the bid price tagged 1109. So yes you do need to consider the spread and also bare in mind the spread can widen and narrow depending on volatility

bid1.thumb.PNG.ac173f5ae2dc7c778f26e5c5d4de617b.PNG

 

Link to comment
Guest 202925
On 7/27/2018 at 1:43 AM, CKau said:

Hi, I have a similar problem. I bought sugar at 1125 with a stop of 16 points... so it should only be triggered at 1109.  However, when I logged in this morning I found it was stopped at 1110. When I did a mouse over the last bar, it said lowest was 1110... so do you mean to say that the stop should actually be lower than 1109 to take into account the spread?

Thanks for playing CKau

 

Link to comment
Guest crispy4747
On ‎3‎/‎25‎/‎2018 at 10:56 AM, effortless said:

Hi All

 

I entered a short trade on NOKSEK last Friday 23rd March 22:14:07.

 

The history shows I was stopped out at 1.06629.  But when you look at the pricing action from the time I entered the trade to now, the pricing action didn't even go to 1.06629. The highest it went was 1.06620. 

 

So can someone please tell me why my trade closed at 1.06629 when pricing action didn't even reach that point? 

 

Thanks

Daniel

 

 

 

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • image.png

  • Posts

    • Silver Elliott Wave Analysis  Function -Trend Mode - Trend Structure - Impulse for (A) Position - Wave 3 of (A) Direction - Wave 4 of (A)  Details - Currently in wave 4 dip before further rallies for wave 5 of (A) higher. We should see one more leg lower for wave 4. The current bullish resurgence on Silver started in January 2024 after a sideways move in over a year prior. By projection, it doesn’t look like this bullish run is ending soon. Buyers will continue to wait for dips to buy. With Elliott wave theory, we can identify the identity of the dips and when a bigger pullback is on the way. The current dip that started on 12 April 2024 is expected to take a leg lower before the bullish trend resumes. In today’s commodity blog post, we will look at the position of the current price in the larger framework and what target traders should expect for the current bullish trend.    On the daily time frame, we could identify that the current rally is part of a bigger bullish correction that started on March 20, 2022 at 11.645. Since then, a double zigzag pattern has been emerging upwards, labelled waves (w)-(x)-(y) of the supercycle degree. Wave (w) ended at 30.08 on 3rd February 2021 and wave (x) concluded at 17.56 on 31 August 2022. By projection, wave (y) could reach 44.995 if we get a 100% relationship between (w) and (y) which often happens with zigzag structured. From the 2022 low of 17.56, wave (y) is emerging and itself now sub-divides into blue waves ‘W’-’X’-’Y’ - a double zigzag pattern. Blue wave ‘W’ ended on 3rd February 2023 at 24.65 before price entered in to a triangle sideways structure for blue wave ‘X’ that lasted for over a year.  Currently, we are in wave (y) of the supercycle degree that can sub-divide into at least three waves. Current rally is the first leg or first leg of the first sub-wave of (x). If we go with the latter, then we are in wave (A) of w of (x) but if we go with the former, we are in wave a of (w). All these may sound confusing to a beginner in the subject of Elliott wave theory. We can just focus on wave (A) ahich is expected to be an impulse from 21.929. The H4 time frame shows its sub-waves more clearly. On the H4 time frame, we are currently in wave 4 pullback of wave (A). 1st and 2nd legs of wave 4 seem to have completed. We will expect another leg lower into the 26.86-26.07 Fibonacci extension zone where wave 4 might find a support for further rallies in wave 5 of (A). Therefore, we can conclude that current dip has not violated the bullish development in anyway. It’s just an opportunity for new and existing buyers to get in long positions from the dip.   Technical Analyst : Sanmi Adeagbo Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!    
    • This is like the Super Bowl for crypto folks, right?  My expectations are cautiously optimistic; we've seen history repeat itself with previous halving events leading to price surges, so let's hope the pattern holds true this time.
    • CRM Elliott Wave Analysis Trading Lounge Daily Chart, Salesforce Inc., (CRM) Daily Chart CRM Elliott Wave Technical Analysis   FUNCTION: Counter Trend MODE: Corrective STRUCTURE: Flat POSITION:  Intermediate wave (4) DIRECTION: Bottom in wave (4). DETAILS: We are reacting off TL3 at 300$, in what we labelled as wave (3) of Primary 1. We experienced a long term correction in wave IV which appears to be complete, and we are now looking for continuation higher.       CRM Elliott Wave Analysis Trading Lounge 4Hr Chart, Salesforce Inc., (CRM) 4H Chart CRM Elliott Wave Technical Analysis   FUNCTION: Counter Trend MODE: Corrective STRUCTURE: Flat POSITION: Wave C of (4).   DIRECTION: Bottom in wave C. DETAILS: We seem to have a three wave move so far in wave (4), with a sideways wave B which because of its characteristics it gives us additional confidence we could be in a corrective structure.       Here's the latest on Salesforce Inc. (CRM) from our Elliott Wave Analysis Trading Lounge, examining both the daily and 4-hour chart.   * CRM Elliott Wave Technical Analysis – Daily Chart* Salesforce is currently exhibiting behavior typical of a counter trend phase with a corrective mode and flat structure, positioned in Intermediate wave (4). The direction is indicating a potential bottom in wave (4). We've observed a reaction off the key level, TL3 at $300, which we have identified as wave (3) of Primary 1. Following a prolonged correction in wave IV, which now appears complete, the outlook suggests a potential continuation higher. * CRM Elliott Wave Technical Analysis – 4hr Chart* The 4-hour chart further supports the daily findings but focuses on the specifics of the ongoing correction in Wave C of (4). This phase is also characterized as counter trend, corrective, and flat. The chart shows a three-wave structure for wave (4), with a sideways wave B. The nature of wave B provides additional confidence that we are indeed in a corrective structure, setting up expectations for a bottom in wave C.   Technical Analyst : Alessio Barretta Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!  
×
×
  • Create New...
us