Jump to content

Why do most trading robots (EAS) fail?

Recommended Posts

Why do most trading robots fail?


To understand this take a look at youtube videos on factory robots,  robots in mercedes factory, robots  in bmw factory.Do a google search  as follows, click  and observe how many robots are used to make a car, then apply logic to market conditions for trading.There are twenty different markets conditions, for traders, to apply 20 different robots at the same time.Each market condition requires a robot coded, the robot can only do the specified function, in trading it means each robot operating in a specific market condition.Most amateurs apply one robot to do 20 functions in 20 different markets, when they need to apply 20 robots.


It is similar to a trader doing 20 markets at the same time,this leads to disaster.Robots can backtest and forward test any system, the theories and trading system /illusions/delusions of traders can be tested by robots.


https://www.google search


Here are logics of successful  versus failed robots.

A  profitable robot is made for different 20 market conditions using 20 magics and 20 different  signals  from same EA .Most amateurs try to use one robot for 20 market conditions,inplace of using 20 different robots.


99.9 % of forex robots designers/coders are not suitable for coding  profitable eas on mql5 site.The /ROBOTS are designed by amateur traders,learners, internet scammers and charlatans.






GARBAGETRADER IN + GARBAGE CODER = GARBAGE EA (SELL THE EA).Most eas are sold, not used by he developer.They fail.


They want one robot to do the task of 20 robots.If you see  video, you will see that one robot can not do everything, you can not design one EA (robot)for all market conditions.


It is virtually impossible task for the little man to design profitable robots, one has to experience and understand profitable trading The industry is the blind leading the blind.Those who failed write books,teach,coach,sell seminars,signals and generally breed the failures of tomorrow.Those who can do, those who can't teach,write books,sell  signals.coach, educate and sell maps of technical analysis..Those who can trade,trade!Those who know nought are gurus to the new failures of tomorrow.These people mislead ea developers.We have industry of >98 % failures, they don't know how to trade, never traded profitably, these failures made money from selling education via books, signals,educationalist courses,trading seminars,trading advice,selling eas,  pretending to be traders and stooges for bucket shops, they are  teaching how to trade profitably, when they don't know how.


Most amateurs use knowledge of fake gurus, have it coded into an EA, only to find the robot does not make money, only the  guru ran off with a $1,000  dollar trading course.The guru has disappeared, with a notice "all trading carries risk of loss".


Everything you learn't from book writers can also be back tested,to see if the book guru was a BS  merchant,before you put any money on his snake oil opinions.


How many other ways can robots help?Do you know of any other reasons why robots fail?




These fake gurus start brandishing opinions on Robots, putting other traders off, so traders waste more of time on the failed EAS, after realizing the fake guru wasted his time.

Link to comment



EAS robots can not change, what they did in the past, unless broker platform creates a bug for the EA. As a result the EA performs differently.Good point.


They can not run out  of money,unless you programmed them to run out of money.In other words robots will only risk money according to parameters.Each robot will calculate the risk, it is preprogrammed with, before placing a trade.Usually my robots are programmed to sustain 10 losses in a row each.

Link to comment

 aka oilfxpro aka apadhani aka El Cid aka **** aka foroom lluzers, if you want people to try out your ea's don't forget you can post code by tapping on the 'insert code' icon, oh wait, you're trying to sell them via private messages here on the forum aren't you, I forgot.

Link to comment

Here is evidence of the forum crowd willing to take money for programing work.The people who are not professional coders want trader's money,their records show amateurs  learners applying for coding jobs.The same applies to trading gurus,they want to your hard earned money, to sell a trading course,because  they can not make money from trading.


Good EAS are not sold by owners, as per the first post.The coding work may cost only $300 to $500 dollars for a decent EA, but the golden nuggets are the testing of EAS/robots and the logic, these can be priceless.A typical cost of making 1 robot is around $2,000, so why should anyone hand them for free on a forum?The true cost of 50 robots working together is around $100,000, the logic can be priceless, because these robots can earn 70 to !00 % a year ++++++.Goldman Sachs may offer $50m for them.




Link to comment

 Ah yes, rechecking my PM's I see you were only willing to 'rent' out your ea's, not actually sell them, so that's completely different then.

I remember at the time words like snake oil salesman and charlatan sprung to mind, I wonder where they came from, someone on the forum must use them regularly but I can't think who.

Link to comment

I call them Gurus/teachers, they should start selling EAS/robots, because there is no demand for price action courses, trend trading courses, psychology education,  technical analysis education, there is no longer any demand for gurus  who can't do, but teach.Traders can just search for all trading education for free on google search.


google searches for free education youtube


Robots are the new goods to market on the internet, after all those who fail at trading can get an income from selling robots.

Link to comment

A quick reminder of the terms of service. Please remember to

  • not post any personally identifiable information such as real names / emails etc
  • not push or peddle services or personal business. Moderators of this forum can see all posts, including personal messages, and if this ever happens to anyone else please make sure you report this. 
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
    • Total Members
    • Most Online
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Joined 19/05/22 11:32
  • Posts

    • Target has joined the long list of retailers showing decreasing profit margins on the back of increasing input costs, which factored in to already weakening sentiment in equity markets.     Daniela Sabin Hathorn | Presenter and Analyst, London | Publication date: Thursday 19 May 2022  The S&P 500 posted its worst session since June 2020 with the tech sector taking the brunt of the losses, while the Nasdaq shed another 4% on Wednesday. Wall Street close Let's take a look now at the Wall Street close in yesterday's session - really negative sentiment they're pricing in for the markets as you can see. The Dow Jones Industrial Average down about 3.57%, shedding over 1160 points throughout the session. The S&P 500 had its worst day since June 2020, down just above 4% there. And the Nasdaq once again taking the heavy brunt of the losses, down about 4.73% throughout the session. Technical analysis Let's take a look now at some charts of this early US trade, because the negativity started yesterday before the opening bell. We did have earnings from US retailer Target coming out throughout the morning. And like Walmart, the day before, Target announced that sales were up, but profits were down thanks to increasing costs and those tightening margins that we have seen in the markets. Now, it was quite a negative sentiment, but it is a bit of a correction of what we've seen throughout the pandemic. We've seen a lot of evaluation in a lot of these shares, especially tech shares, throughout the pandemic and it's kind of a situation where we've seen that decline and getting to more sustainable levels. As you can see here, the S&P 500 now really undoing those gains that we've seen steadily over the last week heading towards that low that we saw on Thursday last week when we saw that momentum turning. And it seems to me that every time we see a steady increase there, we see those daily gains building to the upside, we then see a day of big reversal, those sellers piling into the market as soon as we see some negative sentiment. It looks like those sellers are really watching out for any attempt to jump into the market, looking to sell the top, and that seems to be what happened in yesterday's session once again. So it does seem that we are stuck in this sellers market, this bear market, where any attempted recovery is met with some fierce resistance from sellers. And it only takes one day of heavy selling to undo those steady gains that we've seen throughout the week. So more negative sentiment likely to come here. Nasdaq 100 Let's quickly look at the Nasdaq to see how that is performing. Similar scenario here, those daily gains were mounting there, not quite managing to see those higher highs on the upside. So it was showing a little bit of reluctance from those sellers to give in some further space. Once again, we saw that intense selling, pretty much undoing the gains for the week, heading around the low of Thursday last week.    
    • EUR/USD, EUR/GBP and AUD/USD try to retain recent gains EUR/USD, EUR/GBP and AUD/USD defend their recent advances amid 40-year inflation in the UK and lowest monthly unemployment data on record in Australia.      Axel Rudolph | Market Analyst, London | Publication date: Thursday 19 May 2022 EUR/USD tries to retain recent gains EUR/USD is trying to retain its gains from last week’s $1.035 low amid its softest pace of growth in construction activity since December. Construction output in the Eurozone increased 3.3% year-on-year (YoY) in March, easing from a downwardly revised 8.9% rise in the previous month. While yesterday’s low at $1.0461 isn’t being slipped through, yesterday’s high and the one-month resistance line at $1.0563 to $1.0604 may be revisited. The long-term downtrend will remain firmly in place, though, as long as the next higher early May high at $1.0642 isn’t overcome.  A fall through and daily chart close below yesterday’s low at $1.0461 would put the early May and January 2017 lows at $1.035 to $1.0341 back on the plate. Source: IT-Finance.com EUR/GBP remains above the 200-day simple moving average (SMA) post UK inflation data EUR/GBP’s bullish reversal off Tuesday’s £0.8393 low has taken the cross back above the 200-day SMA at £0.8446, above which it has stayed as UK YoY inflation hit a 40-year high at 9% in April. The 200-day SMA and yesterday’s low at £0.8434 are expected to act as support today, if retested. In case of failure, the 55-day SMA at £0.839 would be eyed, together with the early May low at £0.8368. A rise above yesterday’s high at £0.8494 is needed for the late March high at £0.8512 to be back in focus. While Monday’s high at £0.8534 isn’t bettered, however, downside pressure should retain the upper hand. Source: IT-Finance.com AUD/USD holds recent gains amid lowest unemployment rate on record in monthly survey AUD/USD holds its recent gains and stays above yesterday’s $0.695 low as Australia’s seasonally adjusted unemployment data came in at 3.9% in April, its lowest level on record in the monthly survey, which was slightly above a lower figure seen in August 1974, when the survey was quarterly. A rise above the 11 May and yesterday’s highs at $0.7046 to $0.7053 is needed, for the mid-to-late February lows and the two-month downtrend line at $0.7087 to $0.7119 to be in focus. If overcome, the March low at $0.7165 may be reached as well. A drop through yesterday’s low at $0.695 would engage the 10 May low at $0.6911 below which the currency pair’s near two-year lows can be spotted at $0.6829. In case of it giving way, the June 2020 trough at $0.6777 would be next in line. Source: IT-Finance.com
    • @CharlotteIG I've been downloading an Excel share list on a regular basis up to yesterday, but it's not returning anything today. Is that a temporary problem? The PDF is there, but I need to be able to filter etc. in Excel. "http://www.marketdatasystems.com/content/files/StockbrokingShareList.xlsx"
  • Create New...