Jump to content

ESMA RULING AND WHAT I AM DOING


Guest Medusa123

Recommended Posts

Guest Medusa123

Hi Caseynotes,

I checked IG Australia but did not like that there was a no withdrawal of funds to  debit cards as it states 'not available'.  I also do not have a restriction on how little I put in with ICMarkets whereas with IG it is £250.00p every time I fund.  I tried to get help from IG Australia but was not able to.  My impression of IC is excellent at the moment as they actually have a chat line which is always open so I was able to gen up on them, liked what I heard and saw, so opened an account.  Unfortunately I could not upload identity papers as my printer has broken down.   Anyway, yesterday in came an e mail from IC asking if I needed help as they had not received any upload on identity.  I immediately got onto IC CHAT whose people seem to be on the ball and was told that I could photograph documents and upload.  I really do think IC is safe and they certainly seem to treat clients well.

For me it is not always the case as the old saying goes, 'Better the **** you know than the **** you don't.'  I like to make informed choices and not get stuck in preconceived ideas and a fearful mindset.  If I want absolute safety then that will only happen when I am dead as I shall certainly be safe then.

Link to comment
Guest 202925
On 7/28/2018 at 11:41 AM, JohnRoxton said:

Actually I think if you lose or win money it goes to or comes from the other traders who have an opposing view to your trade. That was my understanding anyway. 

If you win on a long trade your profits come from those who went short and lost.

IG makes its money from the spread or from fixed charges if not a spread bet.

Just my thoughts.

Hi John

Its IG who face off the other side of your trade.

In your example if 90% of clients are long and the trade is winning, then those winnings would come from the 10% who are short. Mathematically impossible.

Link to comment
14 hours ago, 202925 said:

Hi John

Its IG who face off the other side of your trade.

In your example if 90% of clients are long and the trade is winning, then those winnings would come from the 10% who are short. Mathematically impossible.

Yes I see your point. But they also hedge like a bookmaker when trades are significantly in one direction. I am thinking mainly about forex and the major indices. 

From IG: 

"Mostly, our clients offset each other’s positions. For example if client A buys one lot of the DAX and client B sells one lot of the DAX, both sides of the trade are covered. This means IG is not exposed to the profit or loss of either client. Instead, we make our money via the spread (i.e. the transaction fee) that each client pays to trade.

Sometimes, a large majority of clients will trade in one direction. When this happens, we will protect our exposure to risk by hedging in the underlying market. For example, if client A and client B buy the DAX, we may buy actual DAX futures. This then covers the amount we will pay out if both clients are successful."

  • Like 1
Link to comment
On ‎7‎/‎30‎/‎2018 at 8:14 AM, JohnRoxton said:

If anybody is interested I just put my charts up and on DAX a £1 spread bet requires a margin of £641.62 so my stakes will have to be reduced but to be honest I am pleased overall compared to the shock at the beginning of the year when IG first wrote of this ESMA change. I thought I wouldn't be able to trade at all. 

It's not as bad as it first seemed. Granted that's still a lot of money, but still. Also there are these new products coming from IG which I am excited about. Does anyone know what they are? Has there been any news?

Also I read somewhere else that MT4 will offer 1/10th of the size if you wanted? So you can DAX trade with £64 for 10p a point. Not sure how exciting that would be to trade ... but anyway. At least you can do multiples of that so say margins of 60 / 120 / 240 GBP for 10, 20p and 40p a point for example.

Link to comment
Guest PandaFace
48 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

Do they mean us? ???

Surely tounge in cheek tho on that one because that’s their entire audience. And also the word pledian is just so funny to use these days ... I think they’re taking a jibe at ESMA for their illogical policy and poor implementation (irrespective of an ‘ok’ concept to protect those who need it).

Link to comment
10 minutes ago, JohnRoxton said:

Just curious as to why their are margin differences between DAX and FTSE.

Both are in the major indices group re leveraging but DAX is almost double the required margin  of what the FTSE is.

 

Both margin requirements are 5%, however because the DAX value is nearly double the current FTSE index value, the margin required in GBP terms is going to be larger. I.e. the same percentage on a larger number is going to equate to a larger deposit requirement. 

171454903_2018-08-0209_39_58-IGTradingPlatform_SpreadBetting.png.71a4a35bf3d8c3fc037c0bcd814241f9.png

  • Like 1
Link to comment
3 minutes ago, JamesIG said:

Both margin requirements are 5%, however because the DAX value is nearly double the current FTSE index value, the margin required in GBP terms is going to be larger. I.e. the same percentage on a larger number is going to equate to a larger deposit requirement. 

171454903_2018-08-0209_39_58-IGTradingPlatform_SpreadBetting.png.71a4a35bf3d8c3fc037c0bcd814241f9.png

Thanks for the explanation James

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Guest 202925
22 hours ago, Caseynotes said:

Don't look at the Dow, you'll have a heart attack.

Yep its a real Classic-may as well just stick with an ETF

 

20 hours ago, elle said:

yes saw that   , I am waiting with eager anticipation. 10 p lots would mean I would trade a great more -

Wont happen Elle I'm afraid! I asked already months ago, and got the usual moronic "We will look into it response". Customer service at its best....

 

Luckily I kept it real and started checking with other service providers and have now been accepted as a Professional Client by two separate providers. The beauty is, I used my trading file from IG, and it was perfectly acceptable, with no issues. Service was excellent from start to finish, compared to the saga I had applying here at IG,where they would bend the rules when it suited.

 

 

 

 

Edited by 202925
spelling
Link to comment
Guest PandaFace
2 hours ago, 202925 said:

Luckily I kept it real and started checking with other service providers and have now been accepted as a Professional Client by two separate providers. The beauty is, I used my trading file from IG, and it was perfectly acceptable, with no issues. Service was excellent from start to finish, compared to the saga I had applying here at IG,where they would bend the rules when it suited.

I’m interested in your logic. You realise IG WANT you to be a professional client, and that you’re far more profitable if you WERE. 

Link to comment
Guest 202925
1 minute ago, PandaFace said:

I’m interested in your logic. You realise IG WANT you to be a professional client, and that you’re far more profitable if you WERE. 

Eh they don't want you to be a professional client! They want people with 500k in their account

Link to comment
Guest PandaFace
5 minutes ago, 202925 said:

Eh they don't want you to be a professional client! They want people with 500k in their account

Nooooo.... that’s the law. As in, an actual legal requirement (one of three) from the regulators. 

Link to comment
Guest 202925
1 minute ago, PandaFace said:

Nooooo.... that’s the law. As in, an actual legal requirement (one of three) from the regulators. 

I know that's the requirement!!!!!!!

I meant IG what people with this requirement of having 500k for obvious reasons...

 

 

 

Link to comment
Guest PandaFace
2 minutes ago, 202925 said:

I know that's the requirement!!!!!!!

I meant IG what people with this requirement of having 500k for obvious reasons...

Whilst I can imagine there’s a correlation between account value and value to IG... they don’t really give a monkey do they - otherwise they would have implemented this if their own valuation years ago. 

This is purely required by the regulator, andsome companies like IG are just implementing in their own subjective manner. IG just want you to trade loads. Someone with a £5k account who trades 100 times a day on a £1 contract is better than a half mil account who trades £100 a point once a week...

Link to comment
Guest 202925
1 hour ago, PandaFace said:

Whilst I can imagine there’s a correlation between account value and value to IG... they don’t really give a monkey do they - otherwise they would have implemented this if their own valuation years ago. 

This is purely required by the regulator, andsome companies like IG are just implementing in their own subjective manner. IG just want you to trade loads. Someone with a £5k account who trades 100 times a day on a £1 contract is better than a half mil account who trades £100 a point once a week...

It would appear not!  I qualified easily on the other 2 requirements- no go apparently????

However when I applied to other spread betting companies with my trading record with IG- not a problem!!!

I'm now enjoying my professional status, and can now venture into commodities as the margins are lower

Good luck to IG and the tools in their credit dept. They are going to need it.......

 

 

 

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • image.png

  • Posts

    • Elliott Wave Analysis TradingLounge Daily Chart, Polkadot/ U.S. dollar(DOTUSD) DOTUSD Elliott Wave Technical Analysis Function: Counter Trend Mode: Corrective Structure: Flat Position: Wave C Direction Next higher Degrees: wave (II) of Impulse Wave Cancel invalid level: Details: Wave II Is equal to 61.8% of Wave I at 5.225 Polkadot/ U.S. dollar(DOTUSD)Trading Strategy: Polkadot overall is still in the period of correction. In the position of wave (II) with a double corrective pattern, the view is therefore for a short-term pullback before rising again in wave (III), waiting for the correction to complete to rejoin the uptrend. Polkadot/ U.S. dollar(DOTUSD)Technical Indicators: The price is below the MA200 indicating a downtrend, The Wave Oscillator is a Bearish Momentum. Elliott Wave Analysis TradingLounge H4 Chart, Polkadot/ U.S. dollar(DOTUSD) DOTUSD Elliott Wave Technical Analysis Function: Counter Trend Mode: Corrective Structure: Flat Position: Wave C Direction Next higher Degrees: wave (II) of Impulse Wave Cancel invalid level: Details: Wave II Is equal to 61.8% of Wave I at 5.225 Polkadot/ U.S. dollar(DOTUSD)Trading Strategy: Polkadot overall is still in the period of correction. In the position of wave (II) with a double corrective pattern, the view is therefore for a short-term pullback before rising again in wave (III), waiting for the correction to complete to rejoin the uptrend. Polkadot/ U.S. dollar(DOTUSD)Technical Indicators: The price is below the MA200 indicating a downtrend, The Wave Oscillator is a Bearish Momentum.       Technical Analyst : Kittiampon Somboonsod Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!  
    • Commodities Market Update: Discover the latest trends and strategies for trading in the futures market with a focus on Elliott Wave analysis. Learn about bond yields, USD DXY, and key commodity prices such as gold, silver, copper, iron ore, lithium, uranium, nickel, crude oil, and natural gas. Stay informed and make informed trades with our in-depth market summary and expert trading recommendations. Commodity Market Elliott Wave Update: - Bitcoin: Wave 2 low in place, awaiting confirmation. Support at 65k. - US Dollar: Awaiting more price action. Bonds expected to move higher, yields to lower. - Gold, GDX, and Silver: Possible lows in place, requires confirmation. Silver is looking more positive. - Base Metals: Copper approaching Wave 4 low. - Natural Gas: Wave b) of 4 correction lower. Video Chapters: 00:00 - Bitcoin (BTC) and Ether (ETH/USD)   07:28 - US Dollar Index (DXY) / TLT Bonds / US Gov Bonds 10 Yr Yields   16:51 - Precious Metals: Spot Gold (XAU) / GDX ETF / US Spot Silver (XAG)   27:10 - Base Metals: Uranium (URA ETF) / Copper   29:55 - Energy: Crude Oil (WTI OIL) / Natural Gas (NG)   32:27 - End   Analyst: Peter Mathers, TradingLounge  
    • The cryptocurrency world is being transformed by AI, making investing and asset management easier and more secure. Projects like Fetch.ai, Ocean Protocol, and SingularityNET use AI to analyze market data and predict trends, empowering investors with smart decisions. ROGin AI exemplifies this by providing market analysis and portfolio management tools, automating tasks to save time and reduce errors. AI also boosts security by detecting fraud on crypto platforms. ROGin AI's unique features include social learning and NFT integration, allowing investors to collaborate, get trading advice, and protect their strategies as NFTs. What excites you about AI in crypto? Have you tried any AI-powered crypto projects? What features would you like to see on platforms like ROGin AI?
×
×
  • Create New...
us