Jump to content
  • 0
Sign in to follow this  

PRT Demo forward testing hopeless since IG server problem

Question

Back on the 9th August IG's demo server crashed or was accidentally switched off and all demo strategies running live in PRT were stopped and orphaned trades were left on the market. Since then not a single one of my end of day or end of week strategies across three demo accounts have opened a position. It took a few weeks to realise this was happening and I reported it to IG/PRT immediately I noticed - yet it is still not fixed.

Now I have found that two of my shorter time frame strategies that appeared to be working normally now have orphaned trades. They were shown as being under ProOrder control but had not been closed despite the exit conditions having been met on several occasions.

From my communications so far I understand that these issues are down to IG and not PRT.

To have no auto-trades opening when they should have for 40 days is completely unacceptable even if it is just on demo and then the icing on the cake of now having the shorter time frame strategies not closing trades is doubly unacceptable.

IG might think that demo is unimportant and low priority but traders use demo testing to decide what to trade live. I have now waited 40 days without being able to compile any test data or make any decisions on my strategies. This appalling level of service in fixing these IG /PRT demo major issues is ultimately costing IG money and potential customers.

Can someone from IG please confirm when (if ever) end of day/end of week strategies will ever be working again on PRT demo?

 

Share this post


Link to post

6 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

Hi @Vonasi this is a demo issue that PRT Developers are still looking into. I've asked them for an update on when this might be and will let you know.

Sorry for the time this has taken to solve, demo is a lower priority however I understand it is useful for testing.

Cheers,

Will

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

As a moderator on the ProRealCode forums I am in regular communication with Nicolas and from his communications with PRT I was under the impression that the issue was on the IG side of things and was out of the hands of PRT. The problem only started exactly at the same time that the IG demo server crashed/got switched off so this seems most likely to be correct.

Generally if a problem on PRT demo takes forever to get fixed it is due to IG's lack of priority to the demo side of things but 40 days of end of day/end of week strategies not opening trades in ProOrder is beyond comprehension.

IG need to put more priority to this major fault even if it is only demo.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

49 days now since the IG demo server crash and still no end of day or end of week strategies opening live positions on the PRT demo platform.

Rome wasn't built in a day but I suspect it would never have been built at all if IG and PRT were tasked with getting it done.

49 days is beyond joke for such a major bug. Add in all the other bugs that are being reported recently and I imagine confidence in the IG/PRT relationship is at an all time low for most users who develop strategies and test ideas using the PRT demo platform.

Testing is about building confidence - but how are we supposed gain this if the platform never opens trades - even after 49 days of waiting!?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
Guest Guest x

You get what you pay for?

Live trading using proorder works fine, and i suppose they are working hard with other things thanks to ESMA?

 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
On 26/09/2018 at 12:32, Guest Guest x said:

You get what you pay for?

Live trading using proorder works fine, and i suppose they are working hard with other things thanks to ESMA?

 

Working hard looking for a new boss for IG? I'm not surprised that he jumped ship. It is now 56 days and there is still no fix for this major bug.

IG told PRT it was fixed on the 26th September and all I needed to do was stop and restart my strategies. I did - twice - it still does not work, it is now 4th October and the fault started on 9th August!

It is great to hear that it works on live accounts but a working demo platform is needed for forward testing of auto-strategies before putting them live. How IG expect confidence in their live trading when demo and the customer service that goes with is so appalling is beyond me. 

Those of us who want to auto-trade go through a basic set of development stages:

1. Write a strategy.

2. Back test it.

3. Forward test it on out of sample data using live spreads and fees.

4. Put it live if it works as expected - bin it if it doesn't.

Without being able to do stage 3 then we can never reach stage 4 and this is costing IG income.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Hi Vonasi,

This is Despair. Are you still stuck with PRT? Don't you see what is going on? Nicolas is as usual blaming all on IG while it is probably PRT that screws up.

I can only recommend you to leave PRT and use IG's API instead. This will generate quite some work in the beginning but it is worth it!

My life has become so much better since I stopped using PRT. You have so much more possibilities and are not exposed to PRT's permanent errors (you are lucky now that all this affects only your demo strategies but going live with proorder is not much better - continuous errors that finally will result in financial loss and PRT not taking responsibility will not compensate you).

I earn significantly more money now compared with what I did with PRT and I'm running the same strategies!!

  • Thought provoking 1

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      12,772
    • Total Posts
      65,571
    • Total Members
      86,350
    Newest Member
    AdamKavan
    Joined 22/10/20 23:20
  • Posts

    • https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/when-performance-matters%3A-nasdaq-100-vs.-sp-500-second-quarter-20-2020-07-13 should look similar with GICS - i.e. NDX underweight (vs SPX)to Financials (incl. RE), Energy, Materials and Utilities together roughly 25%... and those went kinda nowhere over the more or less recent past...:     ...of course this is rather superficial, but (together with comparisons posted earlier) suggests really exactly two - closely linked - segments in global asset markets have been trending (up) recent years:  US large cap tech and consumer (incl. Healthcare) stocks.   ...apparently a significant share of all the money printed globally this period  seems to eventually somehow have found its way into these highly concentrated segments...
    • I know relative to some brokers (who are taking the absolute $%&*) IG fx conversion fee of 0.5% is okay, however its still an absolute joke that they and the industry can get away with this flagrant ripping off of customers. I would like to know if IG have any plans to reduce their conversion fee ( trading US stocks in an ISA) to compete with others such as Trading212 who don't charge fx fees at all.... I have a moderate account with substantial turnover, like others I know, I'm now considering transferring my account to 212 as I cant see any justification for such high fx conversion fees now its been shown thats its possible to remove them al together... Perhaps 0.1% to cover costs would be understandable, but 0.5% so 1% round trip on trading any size is ridiculous. I easily give IG thousands, if not tens of thousands a yr in fx fees...
    • Hey,  Unfortunately in Singapore we don't offer a non-leveraged account. We offer these types of accounts to other clients in other countries but not for Singapore.   Apologies for the inconvenience. 
×
×