Jump to content
  • 0


Guest clarkeytrade


Guest clarkeytrade

Hi Everyone

I am a newbie and still learning evryday. Do any experienced traders recommend using trading robots software? I've been bombarded with "offers" for these. On the face of ot and looking at reviews they look good, although expensive.

Any thoughts gratefully received.



Link to comment

8 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

Hi @clarkeytrade,  there are a couple of points to consider;

Bots tend to be designed either for trend following or range reversal and so applying the wrong type of Bot to the wrong type of market will always end in failure.

The publicity, stats and reviews will always be positive no matter what. 

Most crucially, the seller should be confident in the product and expect long use and so therefore should be willing to allow a demo period at no cost or commitment to allow the potential customer to trial the Bot for themselves before making a decision. If that is not the case I would never even consider it.

The majority of sellers won't allow a trial period because they know the Bot doesn't work, they have stopped working it themselves and concentrated on sales instead to try and recoup some of the losses it has cause them in both time and money.

Link to comment
  • 0
Guest PandaFace

Assume you can get the same sort of botswhich alert you rather than trade? 

Maybe this would be worthwhile and then you can make a more informed trading decision at that time? 

I tend to think of it likethis... if someone had a bot which consistently made money, why on earth sell it? 

Link to comment
  • 0

Hi @Mrk1977, IG don't have mirror trading aka social trading. It is an interesting subject and there are comparisons to Bot trading.

Oanda recently abandoned their mirror trading scheme, I was following this via David Jones's regular reports over a couple of years, what transpired was the problem with consistency in changing market conditions, just like Bots.

You would regularly see a trader doing well, working their way up the ladder, and then suddenly fall off a cliff. It seemed people have the same problem as Bots, they kept on with the same strategy that had worked well in the past in spite of changing market conditions that was now causing it to fail. 

Another problem is the compromised position between lead trader and the broker as they have entered a financial relationship which can adversely affect the followers. The broker after all is in it for the increased trading volume.

Interesting article here on the next new thing 'robo advisers'.




Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
    • Total Members
    • Most Online
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Joined 27/01/23 14:26
  • Posts

    • USDJPY has been regaining ground this week, but inflation differentials and a three-month trend signal the potential for another turn lower Source: Bloomberg      Joshua Mahony | Senior Market Analyst, London | Publication date: Friday 27 January 2023  USDJPY set for third monthly decline The USDJPY pair has been on the slide since its October high, with the historical 147.63 resistance level ultimately marking the end of the dramatic 21-month rally that saw the pair gain almost 50%. Much of that came through a period that saw US inflation soar as Japanese prices remain subdued. That disparity remains, but the direction of travel has certainly shifted as US CPI declines and Japanese price growth gradually ticks up. The overnight 4.3% figure for Tokyo core CPI represents a four-decade high, with the nationwide figures likely to follow on. The chart below highlights how USDJPY has been heavily correlated with the now tightening gap between US and Japanese inflation. However, it is more evident when shifting that inflation differential forward by seven-months. That close correlation highlights the potential for further downside as long as prices continue to trend in a similar manner. Source: ProRealTime Looking at the daily chart, the recent rebound has taken price up towards the top-end of a descending channel and Fibonacci resistance. This highlights the bearish pattern that has been playing out, with lower highs and lower lows in place in recent months. Unless we see price rise through trendline and 134.77 resistance, another turn lower looks likely for this pair. Source: ProRealTime
    • @MongiIG Hi - You recently covered Long NICKEL Trading the Trend and A. Rudolf did this morning but I see it is Closing only. Please clarify, Thanks D600
    • At the expire date IG sell/buy price is 93.8/94.95 and Bloomberg price is 92.12 Assume I bought at 100.0 If I close the trade myself I lose (100-93.8) = 6.2 If the trade expires I lose (94.95-93.8) + (100-92.12) = 1.15 + 7.8 = 9.03 Is that right?    
  • Create New...