Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Technical Analysis - Finding Patterns!!

Recommended Posts

Hello all,

 

I am new to trading and having spent a month learning as much as I can and writing up a trading strategy I am now starting on my Demo Account.

 

I am mainly trading around patterns with indicators to help confirm trades. I am looking at typical NASDAQ & FTSE companies. When I do my TA I only seem to see lots and lots of channels, upward, sideways and downwards. Occasionally on the hourly there is a flag or two. I just don't seem to come across Head and Shoulders, Double Tops/Bottoms etc. 


Does this sounds correct or am I just not seeing it?

 

Thanks for any help.

Share this post


Link to post

Hi @rachelbarnes,  sounds correct, H&S and double tops/bottoms are major reversal patterns and they don't come along every day. Flags and pennants need a pole and they also don't happen every day.

As @elle points out they do happen but suspect you were hoping for a greater frequency than once a year so as elle is suggesting you may need to scan many charts to find them on a regular basis. Or you may also want to consider adding a strategy that finds a way of getting in on the move between the major reversal points. 

 

Share this post


Link to post

Hi @rachelbarnes, a month to learn doesn't sound very long to me but I see you are now testing on demo, very good!

What sources did you use for your study?

As others have noted, all the patterns you mentioned do exist but not all the time and it depends on what time frame you are looking at.  The problem with chart pattern techniques is that people can start seeing the patterns everywhere if they are really pre-disposed to want them.  The trick is to sort out all the false signals vs the true ones and that takes practise.  

A few thoughts from my experience that may help:

  • Get a really good source publication or two and in particular not just a text book but something that real traders have used (In addition to a good technical publication I would suggest Trading for a Living by Alexander Elder - old but still on the money for me)
  • Don't just dive in on today's market.  Test your learnings by analysing a variety of market types back as far as you can get data.  Compare different and similar types of markets and note that some work more consistently than others and some patters are more reliable than others
  • It is not just about recognising the pattern but figuring out the likely next direction from this pattern (i.e. what it is telling you).  To do this you have to (in my opinion) put the charting in context of wider Fundamentals, historic price action and current day environment (this includes, crucially, sentiment)
  • Some charting, technical analysis, price action analysis etc works better in longer term time-frames than others.  For instance there is a school of thought, which I subscribe to, that Head & Shoulders and double tops only work well on Daily and Weekly charts not so well on 1 hour or lower charts.  In addition the turning points need to be well spaced (several months apart) to be relevant.  Too close and it is just not statistically significant, in fact you often get short term double tops in consolidation phases (so-called steps) before prices move on beyond the alleged double.
  • Many of the great old time traders used charting and many people still do.  Is it a self fulfilling prophesy or something more intrinsic?  Does it matter if it works?  Recently @Caseynotes posted a great video from RealVision, an interview with one of these old timers.  In it he noted that the impact of algo trading has muddied the waters for him in terms of trading signals.  Although he is principally and News and Fundamentals trader rather than a technical trader I think the observation is equally relevant for traditional technical trading.  My solution has been to blend a number of techniques and require all of them to signal in the same direction.  This has improved things for me but the waters are still a bit murky.  However that may be bout to change if we the great Bull stock market comes to an end...

Stick with it and spend a good longtime practising and refining you method before you trade live but expect to lose when you do go live, because trading real money has a completely different psychological impact than demo.  My final piece of advice is to learn as much as you can about this psychological side and come up with mechanisms in your trading methodology to combat the market influences on you.  This is one thing I really wish I had known when I started...

Share this post


Link to post
On 21/11/2018 at 14:31, Mercury said:

Hi @rachelbarnes, a month to learn doesn't sound very long to me but I see you are now testing on demo, very good!

What sources did you use for your study?

As others have noted, all the patterns you mentioned do exist but not all the time and it depends on what time frame you are looking at.  The problem with chart pattern techniques is that people can start seeing the patterns everywhere if they are really pre-disposed to want them.  The trick is to sort out all the false signals vs the true ones and that takes practise.  

A few thoughts from my experience that may help:

  • Get a really good source publication or two and in particular not just a text book but something that real traders have used (In addition to a good technical publication I would suggest Trading for a Living by Alexander Elder - old but still on the money for me)
  • Don't just dive in on today's market.  Test your learnings by analysing a variety of market types back as far as you can get data.  Compare different and similar types of markets and note that some work more consistently than others and some patters are more reliable than others
  • It is not just about recognising the pattern but figuring out the likely next direction from this pattern (i.e. what it is telling you).  To do this you have to (in my opinion) put the charting in context of wider Fundamentals, historic price action and current day environment (this includes, crucially, sentiment)
  • Some charting, technical analysis, price action analysis etc works better in longer term time-frames than others.  For instance there is a school of thought, which I subscribe to, that Head & Shoulders and double tops only work well on Daily and Weekly charts not so well on 1 hour or lower charts.  In addition the turning points need to be well spaced (several months apart) to be relevant.  Too close and it is just not statistically significant, in fact you often get short term double tops in consolidation phases (so-called steps) before prices move on beyond the alleged double.
  • Many of the great old time traders used charting and many people still do.  Is it a self fulfilling prophesy or something more intrinsic?  Does it matter if it works?  Recently @Caseynotes posted a great video from RealVision, an interview with one of these old timers.  In it he noted that the impact of algo trading has muddied the waters for him in terms of trading signals.  Although he is principally and News and Fundamentals trader rather than a technical trader I think the observation is equally relevant for traditional technical trading.  My solution has been to blend a number of techniques and require all of them to signal in the same direction.  This has improved things for me but the waters are still a bit murky.  However that may be bout to change if we the great Bull stock market comes to an end...

Stick with it and spend a good longtime practising and refining you method before you trade live but expect to lose when you do go live, because trading real money has a completely different psychological impact than demo.  My final piece of advice is to learn as much as you can about this psychological side and come up with mechanisms in your trading methodology to combat the market influences on you.  This is one thing I really wish I had known when I started...

thankyou so much!

Share this post


Link to post

@rachelbarnes,

I would like to add something different to this thread but keeping it relevant. 

@Caseynotes and @Mercury may well comment.

Algorithmic 'Black Box' trading has taken over in recent times. They have emerged and changes the so called rules of the game. They did not exist in the 1920's or even the 1970's. Therefore any trends and historical patterns in those time periods are kind of just historical. Large institutions and Hedge Funds who use such 'techniques' if you can call them that can move very large sums of capital and very quickly too. They can be in and out of an asset with basically total automated risk control. As they are in effect a machine they have no fear or emotion to contend with. 

Such 'bots' as I call them which are controlled by these large financial institutions and large Hedge Funds can really exploit lots of traditional technical analysis. They can analyse all these past historical trends and patterns over the last 100 years and create strategies that take into account what 'technical traders' will do and they can counter such moves. They can force false breakouts on both the long and short side. They can manipulate and 'play' with trend-line traders and can really manipulate volume and price with off-exchange 'dark pool' trades. 

I know someone who I shall not name who traded currencies at an institutional interbank for well over a decade. He traded around $100 million a day and provided liquidity to the biggest banks and Hedge Funds in the world. He advised me that he ran back tests with years or price data to find the most 'optimal' moving average combination for any time frame. He stated that he tried and tried but there was no combination that was constantly better than any other. He stressed to me that there were no magic numbers of Fibonacci sequences which made any more difference. 

The point I am trying to articulate is that in most cases just keeping things simple with price action and volume does work as in my personal experience the most important factors are your research process, execution, discipline and risk management. I am not against technical analysis but I do not believe that past patterns necessarily correlate into future patterns. Some may do but how would one know in which asset this is going to occur as a lot of them just simply do not.

I just thought I would offer different thoughts on this thread. These are my personal opinions and I could be just as easily be wrong and totally misguided so I am not trying to force my views upon anyone else. I am just offering a slightly different viewpoint that others in the IG Community may wish to consider. 

Share this post


Link to post
Guest @ rachel barnes + Mercury

Looking at patterns ! They do NOT work and never have. Its been proven through academic study that they do not work, even the Fed done a study a few years ago on things like the head and shoulders pattern and there was no statistical advantage of it. Its all 'educators' talk to try to get retail traders to 'like' something that is easy to learn (till you lose all your money). Bit like looking at the clouds all day....you see something nice up there - the other person does not and the MAIN players in the market, the huge funds running algos, do not buy on the basis of a 'bullish pendant head and shoulder - pin bar, reversal, MACD' candle ! Its ridiculous....good luck - I will stick to cloud formation. 

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      7,235
    • Total Posts
      35,857
    • Total Members
      45,841
    Newest Member
    lyt23
    Joined 18/08/19 07:35
  • Posts

    • Where can I find a list of the US ETFs which are tradable with IG? I can't receive market data for those via the API (same as for stocks), correct?
    • US Dollar - The World's Reserve Currency: The US Dollar as the world's reserve currency is an issue which causes mix reactions and thoughts. When the US Dollar  became the reserve currency there was no Euro or Chinese Renminbi. Since their introduction it has eaten into the US Dollar's world dominance and as a result has led to it declining from the 70%-80% range to the 60% range. If one remembers, the UK Pound Sterling, once was the world's reserve currency but it now only accounts for around 4% at the moment. So things can change and it is not a given that the US Dollar will remain the world's reserve currency forever. It will have to earn that right which it may well do.  The US Dollar’s share of global central bank reserves hit a 5-year low, according to the International Monetary Fund. Now is this the beginning of a significant change here? Is the US, the world superpower it once was? There is no doubt it is the mightiest country in the world at this moment in time in terms of economics but imagine if the US Dollar lost its reserve currency status. This would have a large impact on the economics within the US.  I do not envisage the US losing its status anytime soon but if things continue to get worse and other countries find ways to conduct international transactions / transfers / payments without the need to hold US Dollars, and an alternative arises then who knows. 
    • Going back to my FTSE analysis I see things as follows: 2 scenarios present themselves, other than fresh ATHs that is: 1) the move down to the turn on Thursday was a wave 1 (blue) off a larger scale wave 2 (purple) that should retrace, maybe in a complex fashion with a lot of whip saw price action maybe not, let's see; 2) the recent rally and drop to a new low was a 1-2 (red), which indicates a much stronger leg down is immanent. The #2 scenario would only be valid if price holds below the previous high (circa 7300).  I favour the #1 scenario. There was PMD on the 4H chart at wave 1 (blue), which suggests this is a turning point.  Also the 4H chart shows a 1-5 wave down to the 1 blue, which would be motive and suggests a trend change to the bearish side. There was strong NMD at wave 2 (Purple) which is consistent with a large scale retrace move. Just as with the US large caps, after the stop and turn up there was a sharp retrace drop to the Fib 76/78% zone before the current rally.  As the FTSE was in out of hours at the end of the week this market has not rallied as hard as the US markets.  Also we may yet see fresh ATHs on US large caps while the FTSE100 only puts in a counter trend rally. If we do see fresh ATHs on US large caps and only a retrace on FTSE and probably Dax and Nikkei as well then comparing these markets will be instructive for calling that top on US large caps.  We may, alternatively, see only a retrace on US large caps too if the top of the market in already in. Conclusion: we can anticipate a bullish period on all major indices BUT should guard against a quick reversal on FTSE 100 that would set up scenario #2.  Either way this market looks to have topped out so the coming months though to the Autumn will be critical to deciding things on all indices, and likely quite a few other markets. I am Long the FTSE 100, coincident with my Dow Longs and will swing this up for now but my bearish bias for the long term will keep we watchful for a break down of this rally and I will not be pyramiding this one, far too risky until things are resolved.
×
×