Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

How to use Commitments of Traders data

Recommended Posts

Recently we have touched on an interesting and oft little know resource that technical and fundamentals traders alike leverage.  The US Commodity and Futures Trading Commission issues the positions "commitments" of traders on the exchanges covering a wide range of markets (see link below).

https://www.cftc.gov/MarketReports/CommitmentsofTraders/index.htm

Now traders will use this in different ways, as with everything in trading there are likely to be several different approached.  Here is how I use COT data within my trading methodology.  Note that I am a long term swing traders so I am looking for major trend changes to enter high probability/low exposure positions.  Note also that a big part of this strategy for anyone doing it is to be contrarian when it makes sense (i.e. bet against the herd at the end of the trend as they pill over the cliff!).

I am using Gold to illustrate this as I have been actively using it to inform my Gold trading, especially when I went Long in Sept  & Nov 2018 (see my Gold and Silver Rally thread for the history on that one if you are interested)

The bottom line on this is quite simple.  When the the Non Commercials are heavily net one way or the other, based on historical swings and peaks and this occurs where my technical analysis is showing a turn I get ready to go the opposite way.  most of these Non Commercials are trend followers and have to be in the market, where as retail traders can sit it out and wait, this is our one big advantage.  The chart below shows annotations of where the Non commercials have been peak Long when the market turns down and vice versa.

Food for thought.  PS I use the combined Futures and Options data set.

XAUUSD-Weekly-211218COT.thumb.png.5a7c88b2c2f2140fcf5e02414bc96adf.png

 

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

@Mercury,

May I ask a question? Let's say a trend follower was riding the trend and it was a big trend. Someone using your strategy then identifies an opportunity to go the opposite direction based on the end of the trend.

What I would like to better understand is which strategy would be more profitable? Riding the trend or your strategy? Which strategy would consistently make more profits? Which strategy would give you a better percentage of winning trades?

Have you done any analysis on this comparison? I have not but I am wondering if you have and what the results were? 

Share this post


Link to post

Here is the COT assessment of the S&P500.  It isn't as clear cut as Gold, which is not surprising really.  The Miners clearly know more about the Gold industry, especially supply and demand, than anyone else so they drive the market and the Financials are left to respond to events that the Miners obviously know about first.  Also when it comes to commodities the players are generally few and powerful (Miners, Oil companies and cartels etc).  When it comes to Stocks futures the commercials and many and varied so the playing field is more even, maybe even tipped towards the Financials.  Certainly this seemed to be the case during the 2007-09 credit crunch crash when the Net COT positions were heavily Bearish at the 2007 top and switched heavily Bullish at the early 2009 bottom (not shown on the chart below).  However since then things have been more mixed with Financials Net longs peaking early in the Bull trend as traders got nervous about the whole trend and everything seemed to hang on Central Bank policy perhaps?  Non Commercials were net evenly split between Bullish and Bearish at the Wave 1 (Purple) turn and were Max Bearish when the market went Bullish at Wave 2 (Purple) .  They did better at Wave 3 (Purple) being very Bearish but actually didn't max out net Bearish until the Wave B (Pink) point.  This is not that surprising as many people including myself, thought this was the end of the Bull.  The Commercials were almost still as Bearish when Wave 4 (Purple) turned Bullish, perhaps showing that the majority of the Non Commercial Professionals though this was the end.  Nice to know I was in such good company back then...

After that though it seems that euphoria overtook all market players and we began to hear why this time it would be different.  Economists came up with the concept of ZIRP and NIRP as the new normal.  MSM were awash with articles extolling the virtues of high dividend stocks and companies were borrowing heavily at low rates to fund M&A and share buy backs at crazy prices.  Non Comms were net max Bullish for the rally at wave 3 (pink) and again net max bullish at wave 5 (Purple) the recent Oct top, and I believe the All time high and end of the Bull.  It is this COT story, together will my well documented assessment (see other threads) leads me to believe the end has already come for the raging Central Bank Bull, a Bubble that will doubtless be the subject of many an academic thesis I am sure.

SPTRD-Weekly_221218COT.thumb.png.34ac514c4bf0f424eb72160b6132d6cf.png 

Share this post


Link to post

COT data can be very interesting and insightful. I believe it was brought to my attention by Community actually... possibly casey?

Anyway, the following on DailyFX I find very clear and may be interesting to some. https://www.dailyfx.com/forex/education/trading_tips/daily_trading_lesson/2018/12/12/the-predictive-power-of-the-cot-report.html

there is also a Podcast on it as below

iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/trading-global-markets-decoded/id1440995971

Stitcher (to listen live in the web browser if you're at work or something): https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/trading-global-markets-decoded-with-dailyfx

Soundcloud also useful: https://soundcloud.com/user-943631370

Google Play: https://play.google.com/music/listen?u=0#/ps/Iuoq7v7xqjefyqthmypwp3x5aoi 

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      7,638
    • Total Posts
      39,331
    • Total Members
      49,550
    Newest Member
    georgiadavis
    Joined 23/10/19 15:25
  • Posts

    • Hey @dmedin I've spoken to the marketing team about this. Although we have the footnote regarding the 6 hour time off, I do see where you're coming from so I will pass on the information. Luckily they sit very close to me!  Thanks for leaving your feedback
    • Bitcoin continues to follow my road map.  The 8800 level remains a vital resistance zone but right now a more important zone of support is coming up.  This is an area I highlighted previously as a make or break as I feel a break lower through this area (circa 7200, the Fib 62% level, or between 7000-7400) would suggest a full breakdown in the market and possibly signaling the end is nigh. The fundamentals could be construed as supporting this scenario if you believe the price action is more indicative of a highly speculative mania.  Certainly the % or IG traders Long suggests that everyone is eager for another massive rally, despite the technicals...  In order for crypto to supplant either Gold as a store of value or Fiat currency as a means of barter the speculation has to stop and cryptos like Bitcoin (well in fact for the ultimate vision to become reality there can be only one really) have to be essentially valueless (in the sense that it cannot be valued in USD).  Crypto has to resolve the split personality issue as well.  Is it a challenge to Gold or a challenge to Fiat?  Can it credibly be both?  If we get a major financial system crash in the near term I don't think any of the Cryptos will be sufficiently established to be either.  So that leaves speculation for now and such markets are not much different to other speculative financial markets so for now I am leaning towards a bounce off the bottom of the consolidation Triangle (maybe around the Fib 62%) and a final rally. If that occurs then the projection for a rally end is about 18000, which is lower than the previous ATH as around the Fib 88.6% level.  However that unclosed gap still lurks around 6000...  Interestingly the 8800 level is setting up to align with a break of the upper Triangle line.  If we do see a bounce then the next big make or break will be a test of that resistance zone and a breakout of that to the upside should herald a big rally phase.
    • First a miss from Cat and then a slight beat from Boeing though with a reduced production outlook sees Dow down then climbing back up from S2.
×
×