Jump to content

Is spread betting for fools?

Recommended Posts

What I'm asking is, is there anything obvious in this that i'm not aware of, that i should be considering?

I know it's a slow mover and with only £1ppp it's not going to make me smile after 4hrs.

I'm just going over my own ideas to see where i might be going wrong.  

Share this post


Link to post
15 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

How's this for a Trade Idea folks.?  Back to DB.

Any thoughts on it.

There was a strong bullish open with a test and acceptance of support at 682 so need to be a bit cautious shorting, the H1 chart looks to be the give away one with the last candle (10am) an inside pause, the next candle could be either a continuation up candle or a reversal candle. A close of this 11 am candle below the 9am candle would seem to signal the reversal scenario was in play.

Share this post


Link to post
6 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

There was a strong bullish open with a test and acceptance of support at 682 so need to be a bit cautious shorting, the H1 chart looks to be the give away one with the last candle (10am) an inside pause, the next candle could be either a continuation up candle or a reversal candle. A close of this 11 am candle below the 9am candle would seem to signal the reversal scenario was in play.

Thanks.  and as a trade, where would the Buy'Sell position be?  Or am i doing it wrong again by anticipating the direction?  Am i too early?  I thought myself it could go either way, but what signals are there if any?

Recent news being Top Millionaire Bankers are being brought in to crate a Super Team.

What Time frame should I be considering when looking to Place?

Edited by nit2wynit

Share this post


Link to post
1 minute ago, nit2wynit said:

Thanks.  and as a trade, where would the Buy'Sell position be?  Or am i doing it wrong again by anticipating the direction?  Am i too early?

What Time frame should I be considering when looking to Place?

you are anticipating this pullback to roll over, wait to see if it does.

two ways to play it but the H1 chart looks key so you could play it straight off that, so a close below 696 and entry on the 12pm bar continuation down or switch to the lower time frame and wait for a pullback to enter short.

This 11am bar is crucial, after an inside bar the next bar should be directional, either continuation up or reversal back down, don't really want to see continued uncertainty with another pause bar but it's looking like that may happen, see if someone steps in in the last 15 min.

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Is this proof why I keep failing?  Am I getting in too early before a clear direction is proven?
Regardless of the direction on this one, it was necessary to prove what I keep doing wrong.  Guessing instead of following.  This will be the last time I enter a trade until the direction is clear.  possibly another £6 lesson.

129159087_ProofofFail.thumb.jpg.20d14908f4421c56651b1d02d54cbf46.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
3 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

Is this proof why I keep failing?  Am I getting in too early before a clear direction is proven?
Regardless of the direction on this one, it was necessary to prove what I keep doing wrong.  Guessing instead of following.  This will be the last time I enter a trade until the direction is clear.  possibly another £6 lesson.

yes, the H1 chart players halted the 11am bar going down further right at the 9am bar close level, they stepped in to prevent a reversal pattern showing up indicating they are still in control of price.

The stop is fine because if hit the idea behind the trade would be invalidated, but the entry was before it was clear the bears were actually in the driving seat.

Share this post


Link to post
1 hour ago, nit2wynit said:

How's this for a Trade Idea folks.?  Back to DB.

@nit2wynit

Just a different prospective. 👿 

DBK-1-hour.png

  • Thought provoking 1

Share this post


Link to post
6 minutes ago, Foxy said:

@nit2wynit

Just a different prospective. 👿 

DBK-1-hour.png

Yes it was always possible.  The recent News suggests a big shakeup.  Could provide enough to drive it back up.

Seems it's going now.  There's my £6 quid gone.. Pooof


I think for me with DB is I had no faith in a recovery.  Looking at the Weekly, it's the lowest it's ever been; relatively.

Since the big drop last week I figured it was numbered.  I expected it to drop back to 580.  

I seem obsessed with Drops :O

Maybe it can turn around.

Edited by nit2wynit

Share this post


Link to post

 

35 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

Am I getting in too early before a clear direction is proven?

there is always a case for either direction so look at structure, decide on probabilities then decide what you need to see to validate the decision before entry. The mistake wasn't the call, it was not waiting for validation.  

the 11am turned out to be another pause bar so with the entry too early are stuck in a 50/50 situation when you really need probability on your side.

 

Edited by Caseynotes
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Well, I got it wrong.  what would normally happen now is I'd let it Fail, then assume it's going the other way, for it to be Fake then drop lol.  Then I'd end up chasing it............

Maybe I'll leave this one and walk away.  I think I'll wait to see if there is a big drop and find a way to go Long instead.


i know you're not supposed to move your stops, but would it be wise to move up up to 709?  This is a £10 Stop for me.  10points.  Let it Fail or Add?  Just advice.  I won't shoot you if you're wrong lol

 

1318813175_DBfail.thumb.jpg.48d3b5a0eb10710c9f6ba8a72caccdbe.jpg

Edited by nit2wynit

Share this post


Link to post

Hmmm, I moved my Stop to see where it would end up now i can't move it back down.  Is this right?  

I suppose it's the 6pt minimum.?

Edited by nit2wynit

Share this post


Link to post
2 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

Hmmm, I moved my Stop to see where it would end up now i can't move it back down.  Is this right?  

I suppose it's the 6pt minimum.?

yeah, probably.

  • Sad 1

Share this post


Link to post
10 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

i know you're not supposed to move your stops, but would it be wise to move up up to 709?  This is a £10 Stop for me.  10points.  Let it Fail or Add?  Just advice.  I won't shoot you if you're wrong lol

no, for the reason I gave concerning the stop previously, you might get away with this time but one day you will be really really sorry.

Share this post


Link to post

I've proven my point to myself.  I got out for -£2.80  I don't care which way it goes.  It was a lesson to myself.

Stop buying into Consolidation areas!

Stop buying Slow moving Instruments.

Share this post


Link to post
12 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

I've proven my point to myself.  I got out for -£2.80  I don't care which way it goes.  It was a lesson to myself.

Stop buying into Consolidation areas!

Stop buying Slow moving Instruments.

your original stop level was in a reasonable place in relation to the trade idea and hasn't been hit as yet, so lessons from this one trade so far are;

not to get in too early

not to get out too early

wait for validation of the trade idea

be wary of consolidation especially on the lower time frames.

Edited by Caseynotes
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
2 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

your original stop level was in a reasonable place in relation to the trade idea and hasn't been hit as yet, so lessons from this one trade so far are;

but my Stop changed to 10-points when I moved the slider and couldn't put it back.  I didn't know that could happen.  I knew i'd end up chasing the Stop if it kept going up to previous High.

Smarter move was to get out.

Share this post


Link to post
9 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

the fucker looks like it's going down lol

@nit2wynit

Just read the chart simple support, resistance and pivot levels should tell a story. 👿

 

DBK-3-minutes.png

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
8 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

your original stop level was in a reasonable place in relation to the trade idea and hasn't been hit as yet, so lessons from this one trade so far are;

not to get in too early

not to get out too early

wait for validation of the trade idea

be wary of consolidation especially on the lower time frames.

Additional:

5/ don't move my stop unless it's to lock in profit.

6/ remember that spread and min stop values are variable.

7/ Let the trade play out, avoid trying to micro manage during the trade.

to be continued ... 

Share this post


Link to post
1 minute ago, Foxy said:

Just read the chart simple support, resistance and pivot levels should tell a story. 👿

I've only just discovered the Pivot Point s :D though they're clearly Support Resistance lines they are very useful already.

Would you trade this going Long? if where from where?

 

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
2 minutes ago, Foxy said:

I already answered that. 👿

Sorry, I was reiterating.  

are you actually trading it? :D

Share this post


Link to post
14 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

to be continued ... 

Hopefully I've finally clicked.  

According to the Vids you suggested, the Conservative Stop was at 10pts or previous High.  I've always just kept them as close as possible to my point of entry.  A good point for me to learn was the moving of the Stop.  It's not something I've really done before as I've always placed at Reversal points, they've either failed or gone the right way.

It's also important for me to remember not to go back to a trade I've just left.

As much as I may be down, £300 was in the first day chasing a Reversal on Gold.  £250 in the same Day.....Chasing Gold.  All of my losses are usually on the same Instrument as I chase an Idea that comes eventually. lol  So in perspective. of the 1k down since March, about £600 of that is in 2 days.  The other £400 took about 4 weeks.

My main lesson that has finally sunk in, is:

Use the 1hr to plot SR points and 1minute to fine tune the point of entry.  Don't get in till the Trend is revealed.

1m chart is noise.  Wow, i get it now.  Yeah you can find patterns everywhere, but I've been waiting for the realisation that True patterns are over hours, not minutes.

Let's hope some success can come from it.

Edited by nit2wynit
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
2 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

Sorry, I was reiterating.  

are you actually trading it? :D

@nit2wynit

No I trade the Dow or the Dax because you get bigger moves and a lower spread. 👿

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
3 minutes ago, Foxy said:

No I trade the Dow or the Dax because you get bigger moves and a lower spread. 👿

Am i wrong in my assumption about Indicies:  They're so Random they cannot be Predicted?  

I've always assumed they are based on so many factors they don't follow normal pattern rules?

When trading the FTSE i'd get in an out asap as I had no faith in the direction.

Share this post


Link to post
1 minute ago, nit2wynit said:

Am i wrong in my assumption about Indicies:  They're so Random they cannot be Predicted?  

I've always assumed they are based on so many factors they don't follow normal pattern rules?

When trading the FTSE i'd get in an out asap as I had no faith in the direction.

@nit2wynits

I would say so, but you need to study how they move. Its about yesterdays close and overnight highs and lows that very often get tested before they move. The patterns repeat over and over. All that you have learned about candle patterns is not that useful to me. I just use moving average support, resistance and pivot and time of day. 👿

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post

I've got to get back to my video's today, but if anyone can shed some light on how this translates.

683129646_whatdoesthismean.thumb.jpg.57d1cc1a3c5e2487cc8de6dba7f289e3.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
11 minutes ago, nit2wynit said:

I've got to get back to my video's today, but if anyone can shed some light on how this translates.

683129646_whatdoesthismean.thumb.jpg.57d1cc1a3c5e2487cc8de6dba7f289e3.jpg

Awesome is a momentum indicator and is going to have some lag, the green AW bar is just saying that the downward momentum has eased compared to the previous bar so it's belatedly picked up on the 2 green chart bars detracting from the overall down momentum, another chart red bar or two will see the AW change back to red.

https://www.tradingview.com/wiki/Awesome_Oscillator_(AO)

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post

Ahhh well.  It may have gone the right way, but it was still wrong to get in so early.  And wrong again to get out so early too, but i was prepared for this.

i won't touch this now as it's 50/50 for £6.

 

1317326945_ahwell.thumb.jpg.4e05f22e81118e7dda32e14fda714912.jpg

Edited by nit2wynit

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      11,524
    • Total Posts
      58,689
    • Total Members
      77,712
    Newest Member
    InterMed
    Joined 13/07/20 12:00
  • Posts

    • FIRST MINISTER OF WALES MARK DRAKEFORD SAYS FACE COVERINGS WILL BE MANDATORY ON PUBLIC TRANSPORT IN THE NATION FROM 27 JULY - SKYNEWS
    • March;  Deputy Chief Medical officer Jenny Harries says masks are 'not a good idea' https://t.co/YnTijZGT5b   April;  Deputy Chief Medical Officer Jonathan Van Tam says 'We don't recommend face masks' https://t.co/UWf6hrcYYM   A few weeks ago;  Chief Medical Officer Chris Whitty says 'Don't wear masks' https://t.co/TYGWe4tbch   Today;  'more-mask-measures-coming-in-days' https://order-order.com/2020/07/13/more-mask-measures-coming-in-days/
    • Read an interesting article on Yahoo finance which showed the majority of gains in the Nasdaq is down to the big 6 tech firms and without them there would have been no gain in the Nasdaq since 2016 and the majority of movement is down to the price of 6 companies. It would appear, in the search for dividend and profit everyone has opted to buy Amazon, Facebook, Apple, Alphabet, Microsoft and Netflix, as a herd reaction. No one has stopped to question whether they are over-bought at all, or if they may have questioned that premise, the thought would have been quickly cast asunder in the wake of evidence to the contrary (prices of the big 6 only bulldozing up). This may have lead to a false narrative, where we may consider everything is rosy in the garden of equities and everything  will all be alright soon, as long as the big 6 keep on growing, even if much other evidence suggests the contrary. Which it is. From employment to housing arrears, from relationships with allies and perceived foes to actual communal transmission of Covid 19. From stratospheric  Fed and govt debt to trade imbalance, from irrational exuberance to actually facing reality now. Instead of relentless optimism, relentless realism.  It would appear we are in for another week of exuberance. The sun is shining, people are out enjoying themselves and one could be forgiven for thinking the crisis is over and we can all go back to doing exactly what we were doing before this inconvenience struck. Reassessment can be inconvenient too. No one likes to be wrong, (though we often are). Least of all the Potus, who's principle motivation may not be the well being and good health of his people, more the well being of the economy, more specifically the price of equity. He encourages more exuberance even when evidence may suggest otherwise.  It is earnings season for equities, the reports, many of  which would make grim reading in more sober times, will be ignored for even the merest hint that the future will be brighter or it wont get any worse, from a reaction to Remdesivir (which appears to improve more than it harms, improves 9 harms 3...a litigation lawyers dream) to any glimmer of positive data.  Then one looks at the price of Tesla and realise the equity markets really have gone potty. Look at Tesla's numbers and its price makes no sense at all. Herd irrational exuberance in a nutshell. VW and Toyota p/e  far less than 10, now look at Tesla and you know its share price is on steroids and anything else the doctor will prescribe.  I recently drove to the New Forest to visit a good friend. It is normally a patience sapping experience, but left on Friday 7 pm and arrived at 9;10 pm in record breaking totally unbelievable 2 hours 10 minutes. In July. Normally, it takes at least 3 hours. Roads are still quiet. Which leads me to question again the premise of a "V" shaped recovery  and consider whether those that suggested a "V" shaped recovery actually have very poor hand writing and their version of a V more closely resembles a flattish tick or even a very sloppy W. I digress, the point being there has to come a time when the US has to take off its rose tinted glasses and see the reality of Now for what it is, rather than wishing it all away for a brighter tomorrow. Might not happen this week as equities push higher but you can't escape it forever. Can you?  
×
×