Jump to content
  • 0

Info on technical Indicators, Simple Moving averages


Guest Mpx83

Question

Good morning,

I would like to know how technical indicators are compute, in particular the simple moving averages. I am asking this question because I am slowing migrating to the IG platform and I see some differences between your platform and the others that I am using. Just to give an example, if I consider:

the USD/CAD forex pair

the 200 Days moving average is 1.3172

With other forex brokers the same 200 Days moving average is between 1.3135 and 1.3145

This is a 30 pips difference in the moving average that is difficult to explain for me. At the same the prices are the same, with differences less that 1 pip. 

This is only one example. I have similar differences with other pairs and timeframes

So I am wondering if the computation of moving averages is different or there is something wrong in my platform.

I am currently using a demo account and the web platform on google chrome.

thanks in advance for your help

Link to comment

5 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

Could be Sundays or it could be the price you're using it from. IG uses close price, others might use open/high/low or give the option to choose.

Are you comparing with a platform in particular?

Link to comment
4 minutes ago, GavinB said:

Could be Sundays or it could be the price you're using it from. IG uses close price, others might use open/high/low or give the option to choose.

Are you comparing with a platform in particular?

I am also using closing price. I was comparing both with tradingview and ICmarkets.

By the way, if the reason is Sundays, is there any way to change how they are handled?

Link to comment

@Mpx83

Not at the present, but there is a way for you to check if that's the issue. Go to PRT (ProRealTime) and check the moving average with Sunday data removed (I believe it is possible there).

Then you can see whether that is the issue or not!

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • image.png

  • Posts

    • The price shown on the graph is the price after the IG's fee taken. That is the reason for discrepancy.
    • I am a relatively newbie. I have seen similar and also have seen automated closed position has a loss though the close price I have set was above the price I have bought. After about 6 months with a lot of mysterious losses though my closing price was above the opening price, I discovered this was because of the amount charged for opening/closing a position. This is right below BUY and SELL boxes on the right in very small font. This amount vary from  0.9 to 33 or more depending on the level of trading at the time you open or close. It also happens (god knows why it is set to be so, except that the trader is not watching) when there is a lot of buying and selling going on, like an important news has suddenly been out and the result was not the market expected. As a result, I delete all my automated BUY/SELL values before I stop trading for the day. Remember, the the software is set up to favor the IG, not the retail seller. That is why 70% or more end up in loss.  
    • oh thank you, as a complete beginner it was interesting + useful! https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/price-change.asp can i read this site and take it as the truth?
×
×
  • Create New...
us