Jump to content

IG (Wall St) DOW accuracy?


ChrisN

Recommended Posts

Been using the "Wall St" index over the past few years and occasionally noticed the odd anomaly. The low over the past couple of weeks is a case in point.

IG show it on 6th Aug (midnight 5th) @ 25077 whereas NYSE show 15th Aug @ 25339, Investing.com also 15th @ 25365 and Bloomberg 14th @ 25479.

IG typically say Cash or Futures? I say makes no difference - both show 6th Aug about 9 days before the other providers.

I once got "copyright" as a reason for calling this Wall St and not DJI, Dow or DJIA. Who provides their data feed....the chinese?

Why such a massive discepancy in days? Anyone?

Link to comment

An index price quoted by the exchange is a indication of the sum of the constituents within that group - it is not an asset you can trade. For example you can't 'buy a FTSE index'. To get a price you can trade off, IG will take the direct feed from the underlying futures exchange - for example the FTSE futures - and make a fair value adjustment to bring it back to a more accurate spot price. This means stripping away any dividends between now and then, and taking off interest. This means there will always be a discrepancy with the highly publicized index price.

Alternatively you can always trade the Futures price on our platform which is a direct feed from the corresponding Futures exchange

 

Link to comment

Thank you JamesIG for your explanation of how IG determine their price charts.

"This means there will always be a discrepancy with the highly publicized index price" ...

Yes that is also noted but your company "interpretation" has the low 9 days before the other outlets. However you want to spin (explain) it. That makes it incredibly difficult to ascertain what a real low is.....is it the one you show or the one the others show? It also, at least to me, appears that best practise would be served if the resulting price chart reflects the index it purports to follow/promote.

EWT users ( I follow a US analyst) will know the frustration. His DOW chart shows a different low....and therefore a different count.

Tongue in cheek.....so when was the recent low in the past two weeks?

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      16,577
    • Total Posts
      79,200
    • Total Members
      65,050
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Zhr
    Joined 28/11/21 19:26
  • Posts

    • Hi, sorry to be too late but a reminder that for when the market moves against your week day position over the weekend consider a hedging position in the weekend market in the opposite direction to your weekday trade so that overall your PnL remains fixed.
    • I don’t think you can as the market is closed - I’ve researched this and if “slippage” occurs and you have a “normal stop loss” which happens to be lower than opening price then you get executed at opening price, (which I guess is 11pm tonight)  apparently you need to select “guaranteed stop loss” to allow yourself to guarantee a stop at your chosen price.  fingers crossed. I’m in too deep really, it’s been an awful weekend worrying!!🤦🏼
    • Hi Rob, pretty sure you can still change your stop loss or take it off entirely, if that was something you wanted to do, just go into positions and adjust or if you wanted to take off you delete and press return, good luck with whatever you decide 
×
×
  • Create New...