Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Hi

I am little bit confused with how IG handle selling PUT options and was wondering if someone can help please :-

Lets say SHARE A i has March PUT option selling at 40 and I sell one contract. Later on when market moves against me I buy it back at  80.

I was expecting to be initially credited with £400 premium for selling the option and then it would cost me £800 for buying it back ie total loss of £400.

HOWEVER with IG I do NOT get the premium and instead have a loss of £800

Can anyone explain why is that please as I have tried contacting IG number of times without reply

Thanking you in advance

  • Thought provoking 2

Share this post


Link to post

Hello,

 

Disregarding spreads and commissions, your exact loss should be £400 not, £800, ensure you have done your calculations correctly, as it does not make sense to me,

 

Cheers

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post

You don't receive the premium when selling options via spread-bet/CFD as you are not actually writing an option, just a trade based on the movement of the underlying instrument e.g never any possibility of shares being assigned etc.

You may be able to do this over the phone, but not on the site, currently. Possibly not writing naked options, not sure of IG policy.

I think its an interesting question how any virtual initial premium might be reflected in P&L if options sold expire OTM, as planned Maybe someone else has more knowledge on this?

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

you only get the premium after the expiration date ( assuming the trade hasnt gone against you/ you and the option is “in the money”...

Share this post


Link to post

Hi MAKTRADER6970,

I puzzled by this as well.  You're right this is not how options really work.  I trade options all the time in the US and make money by selling calls on shares I own and selling puts on shares I want to buy.  When you sell you should get the premium immediately the option is sold.

J_Bernard appears to be correct.  We're not buying and selling options just betting on the option prices.  You can't  use them sensibly or profitably, so I think we should not bother with them.  It appears to me CFDs and spread betting is just that - gambling where the broker wins every time.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post

Of course you can use them sensibly , you just have to wait for the exp date for premium as i said in my post above....I also sell put options on us shares in a broker account...what I like with IG is that I can do the equivalent of selling puts on SPY with US500 spread bet here, but without needing a big account as the underlying is much less ....its just a shame its only indices you can trade online and not individual stocks

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

I was looking for anyone that has become confident with an options strategy on IG.  Perhaps anyone out there would like to exchange ideas?

Being able to use leverage on IG and the tax advantages of spread betting, it seems there is great value in using Options on IG for the markets they cover.

I have been shorting monthly out of the money PUT options on the S&P 500 to earn circa 6-8% return monthly. Typically the strike price ranges from 23-25% below the current market price.   Historic volatility on this index shows it rarely breaches this level of drawdown in any 30-day period, and the success rate is comfortably high enough that any losses can be offset by a long term discipline to sticking with the strategy (3-4 years minimum).  In effect, it's not investing or trading, it's selling insurance. 

Be good to connect with a serious market participant willing to share ideas! 

Share this post


Link to post

This is classic tail risk. It works really well, till it doesn't. Then you will wipe out your account.

Be clear what your trading here, (not the underlying), your trading the assumptions in the options pricing model.

If (and when) the trade goes against you, make sure you have an exit plan! You could either cash out at a fixed loss or try and delta hedge or something else.

Share this post


Link to post

Agree.  Getting my account wiped out is something I am mindful of.  To mitigate this I have applied the following:

1) Must have min 20pc margin between the strike price and market price at time of taking the position.   Previous trades I have averaged around 23pc margin.

2) I have three years worth of premiums in cash.  I add to positions monthly and compound last months returns, and then will rebalance at the end of the year.  

3) dont be greedy for the premium

If I get wiped out in one month, maybe i get wiped out for the next two consecutive months, but that would represent a considerable drawdown in the market - it is unlikely to continue.  In such instance, I would probably take a separate long position in the index.  If the market crashes like this, my odds for success historically improve.

I am trying to review what would be a suitable hedge  - perhaps you can help? Unfortunately, I don't think the IG Options are priced favorably where I could buy a PUT to hedge but keep a sufficient margin with the index while maintaining a decent premium as my return (it then becomes questionably if its worth the time and just buy the index with some leverage for the long term and roll over the futures).  Hence why I am looking at this like an insurance salesman, reviewing the statistics and the odds, Im not concerned about the volatility of the Put, just the likelihood of it expiring out of the money based on the fundamentals of the market and the strike price.  Back testing 1-month rolling returns on the S&P it breaches -20% approximately once every 10 years.   

Would be most grateful to hear your feedback.  Thanks. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Posted (edited)
59 minutes ago, Sam252 said:

Being able to use leverage on IG and the tax advantages of spread betting, it seems there is great value in using Options on IG for the markets they cover.

If only they would offer a wide ranger of options online.  They seem to be completely resistant to do this. (Maybe it would cause their dodgy web platform to go TDAU)

Edited by dmedin

Share this post


Link to post
Just now, dmedin said:

If only they would offer a wide ranger of options online.  They seem to be completely resistant to to this.

Agree.  I have asked for the Nasdaq options to be made monthly, but i guess that fell on deaf ears as I am just one client.  I am not too sure how many products are traded against the market or against IG.  I guess it is down to how profitable a product would be for IG and if it wins for them more times than not they would make it available.  

Other platforms such as Interactive Brokers have really good tools for being able to design an options strategy, but the IG platform is sufficient enough for what I am doing.  

Saxo Bank provides a lot more, but while you could open an account through a company and let the returns grow free of tax, you would pay UK tax on withdrawals as income (assuming you are a UK resident like me).  

As I only want to trade on the S&P its good for me.  Out of interest, what are you wanting to trade?  perhaps I can help.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Quick question hopefully on-topic. Put £350 on WTI May Call 1600 option yesterday.  Now in profit £60. If I sell option now how much do I get back ie only  £60 or £60 plus part of  £350 initial cost?

Share this post


Link to post
2 minutes ago, sinkmac said:

Quick question hopefully on-topic. Put £350 on WTI May Call 1600 option yesterday.  Now in profit £60. If I sell option now how much do I get back ie only  £60 or £60 plus part of  £350 initial cost?

As I understand it you would get your balance in the P/L plus the margin used to purchase. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Hi Sam, when you say nasdaq options not monthly , isn’t the us tech 100 on IG the equivalent of nasdaq/ QQQ  and these are showing as monthly as far as i can see?

Share this post


Link to post

Thats correct yea, I just only have Jun and September options available.  On the US 500 for example, I can still buy May.  You see the same?

Share this post


Link to post
18 minutes ago, Sam252 said:

Agree.  I have asked for the Nasdaq options to be made monthly, but i guess that fell on deaf ears as I am just one client.  I am not too sure how many products are traded against the market or against IG.  I guess it is down to how profitable a product would be for IG and if it wins for them more times than not they would make it available.  

Other platforms such as Interactive Brokers have really good tools for being able to design an options strategy, but the IG platform is sufficient enough for what I am doing.  

Saxo Bank provides a lot more, but while you could open an account through a company and let the returns grow free of tax, you would pay UK tax on withdrawals as income (assuming you are a UK resident like me).  

As I only want to trade on the S&P its good for me.  Out of interest, what are you wanting to trade?  perhaps I can help.

I'd love to be able to trade options on individual stocks and to a lesser extent commodities like coffee which need huge amounts of margin.

Share this post


Link to post
Guest Homer Enronride
1 hour ago, Sam252 said:

I was looking for anyone that has become confident with an options strategy on IG.  Perhaps anyone out there would like to exchange ideas?

Being able to use leverage on IG and the tax advantages of spread betting, it seems there is great value in using Options on IG for the markets they cover.

I have been shorting monthly out of the money PUT options on the S&P 500 to earn circa 6-8% return monthly. Typically the strike price ranges from 23-25% below the current market price.   Historic volatility on this index shows it rarely breaches this level of drawdown in any 30-day period, and the success rate is comfortably high enough that any losses can be offset by a long term discipline to sticking with the strategy (3-4 years minimum).  In effect, it's not investing or trading, it's selling insurance. 

Be good to connect with a serious market participant willing to share ideas! 

"23-25% below the current market price "

If VIX goes up from 12 to 80, do you buy back and sell new ones with a lower strike?

Share this post


Link to post

Yea that is frustrating.  Hopefully IG will make it available in time.  I don't understand why they haven't done it yet when other platforms can do it such as Saxo.  Perhaps it has something to do with the viability based on client demand and average account values.  Who knows..

Share this post


Link to post
19 hours ago, Sam252 said:

Agree.  Getting my account wiped out is something I am mindful of.  To mitigate this I have applied the following:

1) Must have min 20pc margin between the strike price and market price at time of taking the position.   Previous trades I have averaged around 23pc margin.

2) I have three years worth of premiums in cash.  I add to positions monthly and compound last months returns, and then will rebalance at the end of the year.  

3) dont be greedy for the premium

If I get wiped out in one month, maybe i get wiped out for the next two consecutive months, but that would represent a considerable drawdown in the market - it is unlikely to continue.  In such instance, I would probably take a separate long position in the index.  If the market crashes like this, my odds for success historically improve.

I am trying to review what would be a suitable hedge  - perhaps you can help? Unfortunately, I don't think the IG Options are priced favorably where I could buy a PUT to hedge but keep a sufficient margin with the index while maintaining a decent premium as my return (it then becomes questionably if its worth the time and just buy the index with some leverage for the long term and roll over the futures).  Hence why I am looking at this like an insurance salesman, reviewing the statistics and the odds, Im not concerned about the volatility of the Put, just the likelihood of it expiring out of the money based on the fundamentals of the market and the strike price.  Back testing 1-month rolling returns on the S&P it breaches -20% approximately once every 10 years.   

Would be most grateful to hear your feedback.  Thanks. 

 

Hi Sam,

I would be interested to know how this works out. What kind of market conditions have you tested this trade with? If the market rallies do you close the position and sell more puts with a higher strike?

As for the hedge, lets look at a nasty scenario:

You sell an Out-The-money (OTM) put option. The day after, the market crashes and is just above your strike. You now have a decision to make:

1) The put option you sold will now be worth considerably more. You could buy back the put, realising the loss, but it does draw a line under the whole event and you live to fight another day.

2) You wait, assuming the market does not move, the option will expire worthless. But you will have a drawdown on your capital which will be (slowly) returned by the theta decay on the option. If the market moves, could go either way.

3) Delta hedge, you accept that the trade has gone badly. There will be losses, its just how big. If you nullify the delta of the position by selling the correct amount of the underlying it will reduce your PnL to moves in the underlying. Upside, if the market continues to drop the loss on the put will be partly offset by gains on the position. Downside, if the market rallies, you will lose money on the position. Again, if the market is stable, the theta will slowly come back into your account.

Which ever method you use, just make sure you decide in advance!

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      12,811
    • Total Posts
      65,784
    • Total Members
      86,763
    Newest Member
    Somia1982
    Joined 28/10/20 12:03
  • Posts

    • Hi, Can you please advise when is the last day to buy more TILS before settlement takes place? HL platform confirmed it is 30th October, can you please confirm the same? Thanks
    • The reason for the change is Rolls-Royce has announced a rights issue. The ex date is today. If you held shares from yesterday through to the open this morning you will be entitled to the following.  Rolls-Royce announces £2 billion rights issue The rights issue trading period for Rolls-Royce shares is now active, giving you the chance to buy new shares for the reduced price of 32p until the deadline date – 4pm (UK time) on 6 November 2020. You’ll be able to subscribe to ten new shares for every three you currently hold. This offer has implications if you have either long or short positions – learn how to get your preferred outcome below. How this affects your entitlement: You have a number of options depending on your original trade. If you have a long position, you can: ■Take up the rights issue by replying to this email (corporate.actions@ig.com) before the deadline, quoting your account ID and stating your wish to take up the rights. ■Do nothing and let the rights lapse – this is IG’s default option for clients ■Trade out of the rights by closing your position in the platform by 6 November 2020 – 4pm (UK time) If you have a short position, you can: ■Buy the rights back by closing your short position, before 6 November 2020 – 4pm (UK time), in the platform during the rights trading period ■Take no action. This will risk your rights being taken up automatically, depending on the result of the offer. This means that you may have a new short position opened on your account at the subscription price under the terms of the offer You’ll need to make your decision by 4pm (UK time) on 6 November 2020 – otherwise your entitlement will lapse by default. If you hold rights on multiple accounts, please reply to this email and state the relevant account IDs on which you wish to take up the rights. You'll also need to do this if your ISA is at the maximum allowance – please confirm that you'd like the new shares transferred to your share dealing account. If you hold shares in a share dealing or ISA account, please ensure the relevant one is adequately funded before this deadline date and maintained beyond 12 November 2020 – when the new shares will be booked on your account – or this election will lapse by default. All positions with guaranteed stops will be closed at the final price on the day before the ex-date. We’ll open a new position to automatically take up the above offer at an adjusted level and size. The monetary risk of the trade will remain the same. We’ll also remove all working orders on Rolls-Royce before the market opens on the ex-date. Please be aware that the information above could change. You can find quick answers to any questions about this rights issue in the FAQs.
    • You have to take what the market gives you, as that is impossible to know in advance you have to have a target and / or risk management strategy for trailing a stop - that's up to you to decide and fathom out what suits you Using a larger position and then dumping part of it at specific target points is perfectly fine and it can turn a losing position into a winning one to a certain extent  Take the chart below - This is a PERFECT swing trade run and I can confirm that I'm on moves like this all the time in my other accounts At the green line you would NOT have known that a trend was starting - BUT as a trader the set-up was typical of the start of a trend, so you take the trade Stop 1pt under the swing low point (green line), then you let the position just run, moving your stop to the last swing low point until stopped out As you can see the red line would have stopped you out - you would have got back in around the red line too, for the last sections Look at the points that resulted in - having set targets would not have got that result, which is why you need to have a set-up/method and stick to it (you can pyramid on EVERY swing low point too)  Obviously the below ONLY happens when the market trends - it goes skew-wiff in sideways markets The main USA markets are skewed naturally to the upside  - just take a look back from 2009 low to see how true this is and how much one could have stripped from the market using a set and forgot with a tiny tweak every now and then the chart below is the daily Nasdaq100 Every night I run a SCAN on my charting software that looks for Elliott Wave, Waves 2 - that scan picks up markets displaying the below formation to the green line - this formation is Gann's Secondary Reaction Kingfisher Plc had a pretty good run too of late as it works on stocks too To confirm a swing low the market HAS to CLOSE above the prior swing HIGH - then and only then do you move your stop to the most recently confirmed swing low point less 1pt and so on until stopped From a risk point of view on the Nasdaq100 this would have been 160pts and would have taken 2 attempts to enter, being stopped out on the 1st attempt - if placing stop under the reaction low point at the GREEN line it would have cost you 210pts in risk to make 2947 points This is a R:R of 14R using the 210pts as initial risk All you have to do is test EVERY EW 2 or Gann secondary reaction you find, so will work like this and others won't - BUT the ones that DO outweigh the others The one thing you should see is that WHEN the market does as expected after the 1st entry bar it does NOT retrace backwards to the high of the entry so as another safeguard you can shove your stop to breakeven virtually straight away or just below the high of the entry bar - up to you Then IF you're stopped its a very early indication that a trend might not be in play etc I'm willing to bet most people don't make 14R from a trade too The below set-up will only be achieved by the ultra patient and disciplined as most people can't simply wait  My 15 son traded this in his child trust fund this year
×
×