Jump to content

Cost efficient S&P ETFs? - London Exchange vs US Exchange


Recommended Posts

I am trying to work out what is the most cost effective method of investing in an S&P 500 ETF.  I am not factoring in the actual trade fees (£3 for UK shares and £10 for US) .

All thoughts are appreciated.

I know that the standard VOO , IVV,  and SPY which are traded on the NYSE also have LSE equivalents, VUSA, IUSA, and SPY5 respectively. Im based in London, UK.

 

Is option A or option B more cost effective?

Option A: Purchase VOO, IVV,  or SPY  on the NYSE. I assume I would then incur a currency exchange fee 0.5%, plus be taxed on quarterly dividends. Those returns would effectively incur more FX fee's if I was to reinvest them into the ETF.

Option B: Purchase VUSA, IUSA, or SPY5 on LSE. I read on their respective websites that they are Ireland domiciled but on the LSE, will I be charged an irish stamp duty of 1% or UK stamp duty of 0.5%? I assume this will be my only cost, as the 'management fee' takes into account everything on the ETF side.

 

Are there other differentiating costs that I need to consider?

 

Liquidity:  For ticker VUSA, Market data on IG says that less than 10 people have positions open for this stock. Do I only have access to trade with other IG people, therefore making this stock illiquid, or does IG pair my order with everyone on the stock exchange looking to sell?

 

Finally, is there any glaringly obvious reasons I should chose one provider over the other? I can see that ishares seem to be most popular on IG, and that the mgmt fees are similar (0.07% - 0.09%).

Thanks in advance

 

Edited by BNoble
Spelling
Link to comment
  • 1 month later...
  • 7 months later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • image.png

  • Posts

    • Hi KoketsoIG, Thank you for the clarification on that. Cheers
    • Dear @millennium_falcon, Hey there! Thank you for reaching out. Just a heads-up, you can only have one API key for each environment, either live or demo. No third API key can be created.  Thanks, KoketsoIG
    • To clarify my understanding. From my Usecase, I have three separate programs all operating interdependently from one another. A program to subscribe to tic data on a number of Epics via the LightStream API, another to grab historic on a number of Epics via the REST API, and finally another to manage positions via the REST API. I need to do this on my demo account initially to get API code stabilized. The IG website specifically says that I need separate API key for each distinct program connecting to IG over REST or LightStream. So in my understanding it looks like I need three API keys all for the demo account. Am I missing something or have I misunderstood how to use these API keys? I am aware of the API request limits and this is why I assumed you need a key per program. Currently I have one API key for the demo account and cannot seem to add more keys to the demo account? I have looked at the FAQ and cannot see an answer for my query.
×
×
  • Create New...
us