Jump to content

George Soros is wrong on Brexit


Mercury

Recommended Posts

Forget about the Brexit angle on this article and focus on the Fundamentals argument for why GBP must be devalued.  Regardless of the result this week I firmly believe GBP is going down and this article shows is just one reason why.

 

 

You might have read George Soros’ warning in The Guardian yesterday that sterling would collapse if Britain votes to leave the EU tomorrow. 

Bernard Connolly, a highly respected analyst and a man whose experiences working at the very heart of the European Union led him to write the acclaimed and brutally honest “The Rotten Heart of Europe”, has written an exclusive response to Soros’ view for MoneyWeek. 

We wanted you to see it right away. Connolly argues that Soros has it entirely wrong – the real disaster will be if we don’t vote for Brexit tomorrow.

If you only read one thing before you vote tomorrow, make it this piece.


John Stepek

George Soros is wrong about Brexit and the pound
by Bernard Connolly


Natalie StantonGeorge Soros has at times been a very successful speculator. But in his article in yesterday's Guardian he asserted that Brexit would bring a sharp fall in sterling that would be very damaging to Britain. That suggests that he is confused about the underlying needs of the British economy – as is the Bank of England.

Soros says that unlike the obviously beneficial depreciation of sterling after “White” Wednesday in September 1992, when sterling left the ERM, a post-Brexit depreciation would cause a recession, because the Bank of England has virtually no room to cut interest rates and because Britain has a large current–account deficit. But the reality is that Britain, in the EU or out of it, has a severely unbalanced economy in which, because of abnormally low interest rates, far too much spending has been brought forward from the future. Britain is not alone in that – it is a problem faced by many economies. But the huge current-account deficit (7% of GDP – an all-time record) is an indication that the problem is significantly worse in Britain than elsewhere.



That deficit cannot run on forever. It is not financed by “the kindness of strangers”, as Mark Carney notoriously claimed, but by the greed and folly of markets. It is quite simply inevitable that at some point markets will realise that Britain's external position is unsustainable. Britain is living beyond its means, in part because of the wholly illusory perception of “wealth” created by inflated house prices – in turn the result of aberrantly-low interest rates which are distorting the economy and creating a looming crisis for pension funds and life insurers.

The increase in British “living standards”, relative to underlying productivity growth, simply has to decline for a time. Britain needs higher interest rates, lower house prices and a weaker currency. That truth is undoubtedly unpalatable. But burying our heads in the sand, as Soros – and, irresponsibly, the Bank of England – seems to want to do, would only make things worse. The longer it takes for that recognition to take hold, the more disruptive will be an eventual “sudden stop” in the financing of the deficit, the bigger will be the sterling depreciation required to support output and employment in the face of reduced domestic demand (in the economics jargon, this comes mainly from switching demand from internationally-traded goods, mainly produced abroad, to non-traded goods, produced and sold only at home – a mechanism Soros seems not to have grasped) and the greater will be the risk of financial crisis.

The most serious risk of all for the British economy is that if the opportunity for political escape and economic re-balancing afforded by Brexit is not taken, market recognition of unsustainability will come in the context of the inevitable next phase of the euro crisis, or of a global financial crisis. There are only three things the EU does not like about British financial markets: they are British; they are to do with finance; and they are markets. EU officials at all levels have made it clear that in a crisis, London, the biggest financial centre and the hub of trading in the euro, would be the focus of their concern and that the British economy and the British financial sector would be sacrificed to protect the euro area. It is even likely that the EU, relying on Article 140 of the treaty, would seek to force the British government to resist a sterling depreciation which would “distort the Single Market”. In such circumstances, Britain would be forced to choose between a Greek-style depression (and ruining bank depositors via the EU bail–in rules) and emergency exit from the EU in far more contentious and recriminatory circumstances than in the present.

This is not a happy message. We might wish we were not starting from here. But if the opportunity of Brexit is not taken, Britain will suffer far more pain in the future – probably a near future.

All this is about economics. The argument for lancing the economic boil is compelling enough. But the political and constitutional arguments for Brexit are even more compelling. It is perplexing that Soros, whose family survived the house-to-house destruction in the Battle of Budapest between the tank armies of two totalitarian powers, should be so enamoured of the new totalitarianism incarnated in the European Union, with its European Gendarmerie Force and its plans for a multinational army – as JS Mill described such armies, “the executioners of liberty throughout modern history”.

Bernard Connolly
Money Morning

 

 

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      23,568
    • Total Posts
      96,869
    • Total Members
      44,139
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    rama1
    Joined 29/11/23 08:50
  • Posts

    • Analog Devices Inc., Elliott Wave Technical Analysis Analog Devices Inc., (ADI:NASDAQ): 4h Chart 29 November 23 ADI Stock Market Analysis: We have been looking for upside on Analog Devices as 183$ as been acting as tested support for some days now. Looking for continuation higher into Minor Group 2 and potentially all the way up into 200$.   ADI Elliott Wave Count: Wave {iv} of 1. ADI Technical Indicators: Below 20EMA. ADI Trading Strategy: Looking for longs into wave {v}. TradingLounge Analyst: Alessio Barretta Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!         Analog Devices Inc., ADI: 1-hour Chart 29 November 23 Analog Devices Inc., Elliott Wave Technical Analysis ADI Stock Market Analysis: Looking for some sort of complex correction into wave {iv} as we are moving sideways, alternating with the corresponding wave {ii}.   ADI Elliott Wave count:  Wave (y) of {iv}. ADI Technical Indicators: Above all averages.   ADI Trading Strategy: Looking for longs into wave {v}.    
    • The poor performance of Chinese stocks continues, with the Hang Seng down sharply overnight, bucking a slightly more positive session for Asian markets. Previous Fed hawk Christopher Waller made waves by hinting that the Fed might begin to cut rates relatively soon if the decline in inflation continued, in order to engineer its much-vaunted 'soft landing' for the US economy. This gave risk appetite a lift in what was otherwise a generally quiet session. Australian inflation came in below forecasts, though the New Zealand central bank warned markets that more hikes could still be on the table if inflation did not ease. German inflation, the second estimate of US Q3 inflation and weekly EIA oil inventories are on the calendar for the day.   
    • USD/CAD Elliott Wave Analysis Trading Lounge Day  Chart, 29 November 23 U.S.Dollar /Canadian Dollar(USD/CAD) Day Chart USD/CAD Elliott Wave Technical Analysis Function:   Counter Trend Mode: corrective   Structure: blue wave C  of black wave B Position: black wave B Direction Next Higher Degrees:black wave C Details: Blue wave B looking completed at 1.37679 , now blue wave C of black wave B is in play and near to end between fib level 50.00 to 61.80 . Wave Cancel invalid level:1.30878 The "USD/CAD Elliott Wave Analysis Trading Lounge Day Chart" dated 29 November 23, delves into a detailed analysis of the U.S. Dollar/Canadian Dollar (USD/CAD) currency pair using Elliott Wave principles. This analysis is focused on a day chart, offering insights into longer-term trends and corrective movements. The primary "Function" identified in the analysis is "Counter Trend," suggesting a focus on potential reversals or corrective movements against the prevailing trend. The current "Mode" is classified as "corrective," indicating that the market is currently undergoing a correction rather than a strong, impulsive move. The specific "Structure" being examined is "blue wave C of black wave B." This indicates a meticulous exploration of the ongoing correction within the broader structure of black wave B. The identified "Position" is "black wave B," highlighting the larger degree wave within the Elliott Wave structure. This implies that the analysis is centered on a correction within a broader upward trend. The directional guidance for "Next Higher Degrees" is "black wave C," signaling that the broader corrective structure is expected to continue with the development of black wave C after the completion of blue wave B. Regarding "Details," the analysis notes that "Blue wave B looking completed at 1.37679," suggesting that the corrective wave at the lower degree (blue wave B) is potentially reaching its completion point. Additionally, "blue wave C of black wave B is in play and near to end between fib level 50.00 to 61.80." This indicates an expectation of the final stages of the corrective move within the specified Fibonacci retracement levels. The "Wave Cancel invalid level" is set at 1.30878, serving as a crucial reference point. This level acts as a guide for potential invalidation of the current wave count, providing traders with a key level to monitor for confirmation or reversal signals. In summary, the USD/CAD Elliott Wave Analysis on the day chart suggests that the currency pair is in a corrective phase within the broader upward trend. Traders are provided with insights into potential reversal levels and key reference points for decision-making over a more extended time horizon. Technical Analyst : Malik Awais Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!    
×
×
  • Create New...
us