Jump to content
  • 0

Probacktest wrong entry and exit time


Guest Jimmyboy

Question

Guest Jimmyboy

hi

i have a few proorder autotrading running. but today when i went and check on the probacktest, i notice the entry and exit time is different from my algo. note: i have not made any changes to my algo.

eg my algo entry time is 4am SG time and exit is 9.30pm SG time

the probacktest now show entry time 12am SG time and exit is 5.30am

my live algo seems running at my intended timing and seems ok

pls investigate and let us know

thanks

Link to comment

2 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

Is this something that has changed recently?

My guess is that proorder servers runs somewhere in Europe and if you use "Time" in the code the time will be in that timezone?

You could try to change the timezone in the backtest

 

Link to comment
  • 0
Guest Jimmyboy

hi

thanks for replying. i am aware of the timezone feature and had not made any changes to it or any of my algo. i just login one day and look at my probacktest results and was shocked that the entry and exit time is different. however, my live algo seems ok. this is quite a worry for me and i cant ignore it. can someone from IG help?

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • image.png

  • Posts

    • @FrancoisT, even if there are no trades happening, evolving market conditions make market participants modify the price they're willing to sell or buy a certain symbol at, i.e. they re-quote bid/ask. Ultimately, when you're trading a centralized exchange-traded instrument (e.g. AAPL non-CFD stock) you can have access to both trades and bid-ask quotes, though not all platforms provide this. When you're trading a non-centralized instrument (e.g. FOREX), by design trades are not reported so you can only see bid-ask quotes and not trades. When you're trading a CFD (like at IG), even if it's of a centralized exchange-traded instrument, showing trades makes little sense. Showing trades from the exchange would be factually wrong - the CFD correlates but does not equal to the trades on the exchange. Showing trades from the broker (e.g. IG) platform only would capture very small volume and would not be representative of the whole market.
    • @Franswa38, if I'm not mistaken, on your photo you're pointing at April 17 22:45 BST 15 minute ask candle. If I'm not mistaken, at that point in time, EUR/USD bid-ask spread was around 0.00050. If you are basing your 42 pips in profit on the demonstrated ask graph, you're ignoring the spread you will have to pay to close long position - you will sell using bid, not ask price. If you subtract ~0.00050 spread from 42 pips you think you're in profit, $9.28 makes much more sense. In short, to monitor the profit on a long position you need to look at the bid, not ask graph. For that, click on the "Ask" text near "15 Mins" and choose "Bid". You should use ask graph only when you're opening long position, not when you're monitoring it.   P. S. From the photo alone, I would imply the bid price was where the horizontal blue line is, much lower than the ask price you're pointing at.
    • Yes I agree Guru, giving current examples is a good way of doing it! I have been trading for over 20 years and in the last 11 years I found myself mainly trading DAX (Germany) 40, because it is the easiest and most profitable. Which market do you find easiest to trade, Guru? Does anybody else find DAX easier to trade than other markets?  I am interested in hearing other traders' experiences.
×
×
  • Create New...
us