Jump to content

I suck at exiting positions


Recommended Posts

I seem to be getting into the right trades.

But I do suck at getting out at the right time. It's either way to early, or too late...i.e. the trade reverses on me and wipes out all profits.

I am a fan of trailing stop. But even trailing stops seem to cash me out way too early.

What do you guys & girls do to squeeze enough out any particular position? (i.e. make your profits run)

 

Link to comment

If you have a trade journal, you can do some backtesting and see what you can do to improve results. For example, what would have happened if:

  • Enter with reduced size and add when the trade turns a profit. (enter 50% of full position add 25% and 25% - 3 clips to full size)
  • Take partial profits instead of closing profitable positions and leave the trailing stops to do the work. Take 50% off the table when you feel closing a winning position. If it keeps going, great, you make more money. If it turns back and hits the stop, you have covered some or all of the cost.
  • Increase trailing stop distance

Every trader/strategy is different, if you are getting into good trades, you might just need some finetuning, and that's unique to you.

Good luck

 

Link to comment
Guest Karma

I hear you, I have a similar problem I have decided to trade with lower amount on the spread and so far it seems to be better. Also I must confess it makes me feel more confident as like if you want to put a pound a point I now put 0.25 per point come in with another 0.25 and then 0.5. I found it better in one sense especially because it allows you vary your stops and limits. Gonna try a trading journal. Think its a great idea

Link to comment
Guest Andre
8 hours ago, wimo said:

Cheers Alex 👍I'll definitely be trying some of your suggestions

Good and safe practice is to automatically place trailing stops when you open a trade.
TS (trailing stop) points depends on time frame and amount you trade. The longer time frame the bigger the TS points away. All markets have different TS points because the move in different ways/volumes.

A good indicator to which point the market is going to move is it's history.
Look back at the support and resistance levels of the market you trade in. Mark those with indicator lines that will indicate to you the previous support and resistance levels. This goes for any time frame you trade on.
Place indicator lines on support/resistance levels on Daily, 4H, 1H, 10min time frames.

Look through the history of the FX/Indices/etc you trade and see how many points the market moves in a certain time frame. Example: TS points for DowJones would be more than for Nasdaq.
The time of day you enter/exit the trade is also important. Note how the market moves at certain times. Example: when the NYSE/LSE/DAX opens or closes. Important times - 90min, 60min, 30min and 15min before any stock market opens or closes.  Those are normally the times the market makes it's biggest moves.
 

Link to comment
On 26/06/2020 at 15:23, wimo said:

I seem to be getting into the right trades.

But I do suck at getting out at the right time. It's either way to early, or too late...i.e. the trade reverses on me and wipes out all profits.

I am a fan of trailing stop. But even trailing stops seem to cash me out way too early.

What do you guys & girls do to squeeze enough out any particular position? (i.e. make your profits run)

 

I'm a scalper, and so it is important to get out early in both a win and a loss situation. Especially when markets are as bouncy as they are at the moment. I take half profit at Target 1 and move SL to breakeven. My expectancy is that a winning trade will average 2.4*R, so I normally fully close the trade at 2*R. If I am going to leave it running in the hope for more, then I move the SL up to 3 pips under the 3rd bar back from the current price. My strategy gives me at least two entry opportunities every day, so I don't mind getting stopped out in profit.

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      21,617
    • Total Posts
      91,854
    • Total Members
      41,888
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Mhada
    Joined 23/03/23 08:10
  • Posts

    • #GBPCAD: Pullback From Key LevelGBPCAD reached a major horizontal resistance.The price has nicely reacted to that, forming a bearish engulfing candle on 4H time frame.I expect a retracement from the underlined structure.Goals: 1.68 / 1.677
    • #EURUSD: Important Breakout 🇪🇺🇺🇸   Bulls push 🟢EURUSD heavily after yesterday's Interest Rate Decision and FOMC. The price has successfully broken and closed above a solid horizontal supply cluster.   The next solid resistance that I see is 1.099 - 1.103 area. Probabilities will be high that it is the next goal for buyers.   For those, who missed entries, I strictly recommend waiting for a pullback first. I will post an update later on. For Additional confirmation use: Xmaster Formula MT4 Indicator
    • The Nasdaq’s gains are starkly contrasted with relatively weak performances this year from US index peers the S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average (Wall Street 30), suggesting some sector rotation has occurred. Source: Bloomberg   Indices Nasdaq-100 S&P 500 Dow Jones Industrial Average Nasdaq Technical analysis  Shaun Murison | Senior Market Analyst, Johannesburg | Publication date: Monday 20 March 2023  The Nasdaq 100 index, after being out of favour in 2022, has managed to produce double digit price gains within the first quarter of 2023. These gains are starkly contrasted with relatively weak performances this year from US index peers the S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average (Wall Street 30). The failure of smaller financial counters Silvergate, First Republic and Silicon Valley Banks, has sparked fears around a mini banking crisis prompting weakness in larger banking peers which make up some of the S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial index constituents. In turn there is a suggestion that we are now seeing some sector rotation by investors back into technology stocks found within the Nasdaq 100 index. Relative strength comparison: Nasdaq 100 vs S&P 500   Source: IG The chart above shows a ratio comparison of the Nasdaq 100 (numerator) and the S&P500 (denominator) from the beginning of 2022 up until now (20 March 2023). The red trend line (arrow) highlights the downtrend in this ratio which reflects a significant underperformance of the Nasdaq against the S&P500 in 2022. The blue arrow highlights the upward trend of this ratio which began in early 2023. The upward trend now prevalent, highlights the Nasdaq 100’s outperformance of the S&P 500. Relative strength comparison: Nasdaq 100 vs Dow Jones Industrial Average   Source: IG Similarly, to our previous chart (Nasdaq100 / SP500) the above chart of the Nasdaq 100 (numerator) and Dow Jones Industrial Average (denominator) ratio highlights these same trends, i.e. in 2022 Nasdaq 100 consistently underperformed the Dow, while in 2023 that trend appears to have reversed. Year to date index moves compared   Source: IG Albeit from a lower base, the Nasdaq 100 has outperformed its benchmark peers the S&P500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average significantly in 2023. Nasdaq 100 – Technical analysis Source: IG As highlighted in a previous article, the 50-day simple moving average (50MA) (green line) has recently crossed above the 200-day simple moving average (200MA) (blue line). This moving average crossover is commonly referred to as the ‘golden cross’ in technical analysis terms. The suggestion is that it marks the beginning of a new longer-term uptrend in a market, in this case the Nasdaq 100. While we have seen some short-term gains to follow in the index, the Nasdaq 100 does now also trade in overbought territory. The overbought signal suggests that trend followers looking for long entry might be afforded an opportunity to do so through either a near term price pullback or sideways consolidation.   Source: IG The price break above resistance at 12350, now sees this level as possible support, should a pullback ensue. Traders supporting the long-term uptrend might look for long entry on a pullback to either this level or trend line (solid black line) support. Preferably a pullback would need to end with a bullish reversal (candle) pattern. In this scenario, 12900 and 13190 provide initial resistance targets, while a close below the reversal low might be used as a stop loss indication for the trade.
×
×
  • Create New...