Jump to content

Trailing guaranteed stops


Recommended Posts

Second suggestion: Trailing guaranteed stops


I am tremendously surprised how this feature has not been implemented yet.

I wonder what the rest of the community think about this.

Out of curiosity, which percentage of customers used this feature on any given day?

Link to comment
  • 9 months later...
Guest Futures

I was trading Euro past few weeks and i had one open order on weekend with normal stop loss it gapped down and my position in profit went heavy loss that sets up a series of down days for me.


if i would have used guaranteed stops it would have been small loss.


Ive been on phone with IG support and after many minutes i got this idea


1. Guaranteed stop price is dependent on volatility. if normal day hours its of no use unless black swan event takes Now since its based on volatility under high volatility your trailing guaranteed stop instead of in your favor can go against you as it wil lbe calculated dynamically


2. Guaranteed stops payment only when its hit if its not hit then its not charged

 This one i couldn't understand because the cc agent told me that they include the premium for guaranteed stop when you place the order so instead of spread being .6 they will charge you 1.6 so that means you have already paid for guaranteed stop


Here's how ill use them

1. You could use Daily ATR*1.5  as guaranteed stops as an insurance during market hours who knows

2. On weekends if ive positions open ill definitely use guaranteed stops.

3.If you are using PRT then you cant place Guaranteed stops so either go to portal or call IG

Link to comment
Guest Futures

i asked iG how can they support guaranteed stops wouldnt this means absorbing trader loss. i wanted to make sure that they will honor guaranteed stops no matter the gap couldnt find a suitable answer any ideas fellas



Link to comment

Futures wrote:

i asked iG how can they support guaranteed stops wouldnt this means absorbing trader loss. i wanted to make sure that they will honor guaranteed stops no matter the gap couldnt find a suitable answer any ideas fellas



If they take the other side of the position the risk should be minimal?


and they have open trades i multiple markets in both directions so what can be a catastrophe for a single trader may not hurt them much


I hope it will be available in prorder soon as a "max loss stop" and if it can be moved its perfect

most trades are closed as markets order anyway




Link to comment

Always remember that when ever you take a position its not just the broker that can take the other side of the position, but its all of us that perform this action which is what is ideal for everyone hence why it is a zero sum game, so if i buy one lot of aud usd, someone in the market will short the same amount, but when this cannot be done which is common when dealing with swaps and call and put options then the broker must perform the trade, it does not affect your chances of making money, but you cannot buy or sell without another buyer or seller being matched. The problem is with flash crashes is that temporarily their are no buyers until a threshold level is reached, this is why Level 2 data can be very useful as you can constantly observe the amount of liquidity being provided. 

Link to comment
Guest Futures

Execution in IG is much better but im assuming if you want to trade big sizes margin as well as execution will suffer.


As i understand IG calls its accounts DMA but the DMA account is different than spreadbet account :) if i'm correct.


Now about Guaranteed stops its still not clear one way im thinking is IG moves risk to their banks over weekend for a small fee.



Link to comment

@Caseynotesi asked iG how can they support guaranteed stops wouldnt this means absorbing trader loss. i wanted to make sure that they will honor guaranteed stops no matter the gap couldnt find a suitable answer any ideas fellas



Answer: IG makes money when traders lose money. This fact might have been well known for many, but I didn't know it at the beginning.

So IG doesn't need to cover your loses when a guaranteed stop is triggered. It simply won't take as much of your money as it would have had, if you didn't use a guaranteed loss.

Link to comment

Tri, IG makes their money through spreads and commissions, it is not in their interest for clients to lose money, otherwise they would have nobody left. They are not actively betting against you, it would not even be financially feasible,  contract sizes are to big, instead they hedge almost all client positions in the underlying market which is expected to ensure their is sufficient liquidity provided and manage client exposure. We all take each others side of the trade, this is normal in not just spread trading, but in stocks, futures, call and puts, swaps etc. Remember you cannot buy unless someone is selling to you and visa versa. Stop losses are also used by every single broker. With my HSBC broker i always used to instruct them to have a stop loss including guaranteed and if it got hit they would only take a tiny commission on the spread for the guaranteed stop loss. If you want examples of brokers actively betting against clients look no further than places like Barclays and CITI who have in the past purposely been betting against clients as they new where their stop losses where because they where actively managing their accounts. 

Link to comment
Guest Futures

i dont know sometimes when i compare the FXCM and IG charts i see the price tied above or below that i think is not normal only to get to profitable stops or not to reach profitable targets.


Execution in IG is better though IG doesn't allow scalping i was doing scalping on PRT and  the software put me immediately from 5pips to 10pips stop loss or i cant enter my orders thats gone now but it think scalping is not making money for IG.


Compared to City i think IG is much better i was with City their customer service is horrific and their mobile platform freezes so man times even when no news is coming. With City if your position is in profit and you want to close it early you cant do it because mobile platform will freeze i noticed that 20-30 times over a period of month and then i closed much better with IG. Luckily it hasnt happened with IG till now.


IG needs to have some documentation on how they use guaranteed stops i think Guaranteed stops are in favor of trader rather than IG but still want to know the mechanics so that i know it will be honored.

Link to comment
Guest Futures


 didnt knew about ODEY but i believe by the time news hits the market transactions are already done look at GBPUSD falling since 2014 but news only consider 24th June.


FCA should audit random check to price spikes especially City Index scammers


Link to comment

Donald, thank you for your comment. What you say is correct for other markets ,not for the playground that IG, Plus500 and the likes provide.

There is no real market here. Noone actually buys or sells anything. You simply bet on price movements of numbers that are said to follow the underlyng market. The prices are all made up, although spreadbetting conpanies claim that they follow the real market. Actually ,they even admit that their prices may diverge from the real prices.

IG doesn't bet against you. There isn't need for that. Just like a casino doesn't bet against a punter ,nor does one better bets against another one. We all bet on the outcome of the roulette,some on red others on black. Some win,others lose and so on.

I hope you can see the difference.


Of course our gambles are made easier by the fact that there is an underlying markets and we can follow the news ,draw charts , read candles and tea leaves...etc. So it's a bit of educated guess of a probable outcome ,not merely throwing the dice.


Most of the profits of spreadbetting companies come from wiping out customers' accounts. The commissions and so called 'funding ' charges that don't actually fund anything are just another income for the company.


Link to comment

Leveraged based products do carry an element of risk, but remember many professional traders as well as algo trading use leverage to trade CFD's originally was an institutional only thing. Stocks and shares are also risky except you only loose the amount you put in. The difference unfortunetly between professional and retail is that professionals put risk management before profits and retails do the opposite of that. Wins and loses are part of trading, no system and no professional trader will ever get 100% wins it is not possible and no system including algo trading will give you that either. As far as prices are IG does give real prices, nobody trades fake prices. Another issue is that individuals dont do their homework, they think charts do the job, charts should be used for execution only, i barely even look at indicators, statistical data and correlations is the bread and butter for me. I always see the market has basically a laboratory where you come up with a hypothesis and put it to the test and like any hypothesis the aim is to get either a scientific or monetary gain, but equally you may fail. It is a probability game, but what in life is not?

In summary nobody learns in this business unless they actively trade and able to distinguish the huge difference between analyses and trading which are completely different tactics.  

Link to comment

Good, we came to an agreement, Donald. With one exception - IG supplies their own prices. Look on their site what they say. It's not a real price. All spreadbetting companies do it. That's why charts differ from a company to company.

If it was a real price, then they would use the official LSE, Nazdaq, etc price 1:1.


Institutional traders don't bet on spreadbetting companies. The do so on the real market with real borrowing and leverage. They are those who sway the real market with their real trades of large volumes.

Good luck!

Link to comment

Hi all,

Giving the new FSA intentions to regulate IG and others I found the case for trailing guaranteed stops is more robust.

It will present IG with an edge against competitors and maybe it worth considering to apply by default on positions on new accounts.

This will certainly limit the risk for new guys.


I wonder if anyone from IG could give us some idea if they are considering this on a near feature.




Link to comment


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
    • Total Members
    • Most Online
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Joined 28/01/23 09:29
  • Posts

    • Capital, win loss ratio. If you have a trading edge and you can consistently win 50% of your trades, so your winning 5 trades out of 10. So if your risking 1% of your capital per trade, out of your 10 trades 5 would be losers, so that’s 5% loss and realistically out of the 5 winning trades, some would make small profits, some break even and 1, 2 or 3 could run nicely IF you can let your profits run, basically your making money out of 2 trades out of the 10 trades (80/20 Rule Pareto principle) So a $20,000 acct risking 1% is $200 per trade, this will keep the trader with his trade risk based on being able to win 50% of his trades. A long term trend trader can win with 30% wining trade. Basically you need to know your numbers. Rgds Pete
    • Investing in stocks can be a great way to grow your wealth over time. However, there are different approaches that investors can take when choosing which stocks to buy. Two of the most popular approaches are growth investing and value investing. Growth Investing Growth investing is an investment strategy that focuses on buying stocks of companies that are expected to grow at a faster rate than the overall market. These companies are often in industries that are growing quickly, such as technology or healthcare. Investors who use this approach believe that these companies will be able to generate higher profits in the future, which will lead to higher stock prices. One of the main advantages of growth investing is that it can potentially provide higher returns than the overall market. However, it is also riskier than other investment strategies, as these companies often have higher valuations and more volatile stock prices. Value Investing Value investing is an investment strategy that focuses on buying stocks of companies that are undervalued by the market. These companies may be in industries that are out of favour or have recently experienced challenges, but they have strong fundamentals and a history of profitability. Investors who use this approach believe that these companies are undervalued and that their true value will be recognized in the future, leading to higher stock prices. One of the main advantages of value investing is that it can potentially provide lower risk than growth investing. However, it may also provide lower returns in the long run, as these companies may not have the same growth potential as companies in the growth investing category. Comparing Growth and Value Investing Growth and value investing are two different approaches to stock investing, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Growth investing can potentially provide higher returns but is riskier, while value investing can provide lower risk but potentially lower returns. An investor may choose one approach or a combination of both. A portfolio that contains a mix of growth and value stocks can provide a balance of potential returns and risk. Conclusion Both growth investing and value investing can be effective ways to invest in stocks. The key is to understand the potential risks and rewards of each approach and to choose the one that aligns with your investment goals and risk tolerance. Analyst Peter Mathers TradingLounge™ 
    • I am a beginner, and I must say, there are a lot of rules to the trading game that one must abide by if they want to be successful.   Here, the writer mentions several basic rules for day vs swing trading.  However, I find that often times, the reasoning for these rules is not as  obvious for a beginner as it may be for an expert.   The 'why' factor if I may. For example, why must you have a large capital to trade with as a day trader? Because your positions must be large so that a small change in price will be augmented and turned into a large profit. Also, with such high risk, the margin will be specially high, given the trader is taking up large positions at a time.  Without a large amount of capital, positions may be forced to close due to funds being below margin requirements.  When this happens, you can expect to lose tons of cash, fast.  I learned the hard way. All the best, David Franco      
  • Create New...