Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Signal centre

Recommended Posts

Has anyone tried following the 'advice' of PIA First?

I'm almost tempted to think that it deliberately gives false signals to encourage punters (sorry, valued clients) to enter bad trades for IG to profit from.

Why else would IG pay for something that generates such appallingly bad signals?

Share this post


Link to post

@dmedin,

I am not a fan of PIA at all.

In fact IG's Analysts tend to post reports/blogs well after the price action has created a trading opportunity which many have profited from and looking to exit with their profits. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Okay, sounds like I need to be on Twitter then.  I've held out on social media for years, but since companies are now using it (and not offering alternatives) I guess I have no choice.

Share this post


Link to post

@dmedin,

I am not sure what trading style you adopt or what your trading strategy is. I follow 'Trend Following' principles for trading only and not investing. My investment philosophy is very different but anyway that is for a different time. 

The best way to trade is to establish which indicators you wish to use and why? What signals are you looking for and which indicators will best serve those signals for you? If you can do this then there is absolutely no reason that I can think of why anyone needs to follow the likes of PIA. 

PIA are for those as you call them 'punters' that want to make quick money but do not want to learn to trade to put the effort and time in which is required. They are lazy and want to try and trade and earn profits the easy way. Well guess what? Trading is extremely difficult and there is no easy way. So these 'punters' follow the likes of PIA and others. They dare not question their technical analysis or challenge their trading ideas. 

The amount of traders that I have come across who do not have the following is shocking:

  • Trading Plan
  • Trading Strategy
  • Trading System

Without the three above it is very difficult for any trader to make any profits consistently throughout the year and then year after year.

Share this post


Link to post

@dmedin,

Just one more thing. No amount of charts, lines, arrows, more charts, etc. can help predict the future movement of prices. No amount of technical analysis can predict with any precision future price behaviour. Technical Analysis and charts are based on historical price action. They are very useful to see what has happened in the past. The most important information is what is happening currently. 

What both technical analysis and charts can do is assist to show you how the price has reacted in the past. This can be used in the 'decision making basket' to assist you in making an informed decision. When you use certain signals and indicators using technical analysis it can increase the probability and put the odds in your favour for a potentially profitable trade. That is all. It does not guarantee it any profitable trade.

Share this post


Link to post

Not sure youse are understanding the signal service at all. Firstly both providers are third party companies and stand aside of IG so IG blogs and analysis etc have nothing to do with PIA or Autochartist. Secondly they provide computer generated chart patterns that are in the process of forming and nearing completion so they are more a screener than purely analytical. Sometimes the pattern completes and sometimes not but completed patterns and the resulting price movement are well studied and have stats to back up their probability of success. 

So you are looking at a screener that is flagging up the possibility of a chart pattern completion but it is computer generated and it's up to the client to decide if the trade and risk/reward involved is acceptable. 

Share this post


Link to post

I'm actually finding the PIA First suggestions useful, when comparing carefully with my own analysis, rather than simply agreeing with everything.  I'm sure it's right more often than I am though.  😋

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

@dmedin,

I would think more in terms of what can you do in terms if identification work, using indicators and signals to come up with your own suggestions. Then look to see if they are similar or different and try and find out why?

Share this post


Link to post

PIA First gave a nice signal last Friday.  Since the down move has retraced > 70% it's likely to retrace all the way and then some.  It gave a good recommendation to wait for a slight pull back before entering a trade and I agreed with it and committed to it on this occasion.  (See my humble graph)

Today however PIA First is recommending buying at 11010.  That's going in completely the opposite direction to the trade they recommended before the weekend.  Dodgy?

usd.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
4 minutes ago, dmedin said:

oday however PIA First is recommending buying at 11010.  That's going in completely the opposite direction to the trade they recommended before the weekend.  Dodgy?

Computer generated and may be for a very different time frame, and the target was for the info available at the time of publishing the signal, things might have changed so will need to watch closely.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      7,234
    • Total Posts
      35,855
    • Total Members
      45,836
    Newest Member
    Kwoods993
    Joined 17/08/19 18:08
  • Posts

    • US Dollar - The World's Reserve Currency: The US Dollar as the world's reserve currency is an issue which causes mix reactions and thoughts. When the US Dollar  became the reserve currency there was no Euro or Chinese Renminbi. Since their introduction it has eaten into the US Dollar's world dominance and as a result has led to it declining from the 70%-80% range to the 60% range. If one remembers, the UK Pound Sterling, once was the world's reserve currency but it now only accounts for around 4% at the moment. So things can change and it is not a given that the US Dollar will remain the world's reserve currency forever. It will have to earn that right which it may well do.  The US Dollar’s share of global central bank reserves hit a 5-year low, according to the International Monetary Fund. Now is this the beginning of a significant change here? Is the US, the world superpower it once was? There is no doubt it is the mightiest country in the world at this moment in time in terms of economics but imagine if the US Dollar lost its reserve currency status. This would have a large impact on the economics within the US.  I do not envisage the US losing its status anytime soon but if things continue to get worse and other countries find ways to conduct international transactions / transfers / payments without the need to hold US Dollars, and an alternative arises then who knows. 
    • Going back to my FTSE analysis I see things as follows: 2 scenarios present themselves, other than fresh ATHs that is: 1) the move down to the turn on Thursday was a wave 1 (blue) off a larger scale wave 2 (purple) that should retrace, maybe in a complex fashion with a lot of whip saw price action maybe not, let's see; 2) the recent rally and drop to a new low was a 1-2 (red), which indicates a much stronger leg down is immanent. The #2 scenario would only be valid if price holds below the previous high (circa 7300).  I favour the #1 scenario. There was PMD on the 4H chart at wave 1 (blue), which suggests this is a turning point.  Also the 4H chart shows a 1-5 wave down to the 1 blue, which would be motive and suggests a trend change to the bearish side. There was strong NMD at wave 2 (Purple) which is consistent with a large scale retrace move. Just as with the US large caps, after the stop and turn up there was a sharp retrace drop to the Fib 76/78% zone before the current rally.  As the FTSE was in out of hours at the end of the week this market has not rallied as hard as the US markets.  Also we may yet see fresh ATHs on US large caps while the FTSE100 only puts in a counter trend rally. If we do see fresh ATHs on US large caps and only a retrace on FTSE and probably Dax and Nikkei as well then comparing these markets will be instructive for calling that top on US large caps.  We may, alternatively, see only a retrace on US large caps too if the top of the market in already in. Conclusion: we can anticipate a bullish period on all major indices BUT should guard against a quick reversal on FTSE 100 that would set up scenario #2.  Either way this market looks to have topped out so the coming months though to the Autumn will be critical to deciding things on all indices, and likely quite a few other markets. I am Long the FTSE 100, coincident with my Dow Longs and will swing this up for now but my bearish bias for the long term will keep we watchful for a break down of this rally and I will not be pyramiding this one, far too risky until things are resolved.
    • "....more broadly we have seen currency wars but these have not really captured the imagination of the MSM yet" Actually I'd argue we have had currency wars for some years already. History shows it goes in the following order: Currency war, Trade war, War. (Regrettably).  If I recall correctly the market falls of early 2015 (about 20% down) were blamed on Yuan being devalued by Chinese manipulation. Way before Trump! "....we suddenly get a super massive set of central bank policies that drop rates to zero" Again I'd say that has been going on for some years. Arguably you could say about 35 years since the Plaza Accord. Once fiat became unaccountable (no gold standard) the politicians proceeded to spend, spend spend =debt,debt,debt. Expect MMT  (US Democrats pushing modern monetary theory) to allow them to continue in that vein. Again history says these currencies will all eventually disappear, like species, approx 95% no longer exist.  Broadly I agree with what you say. The present financial system is critically sick that's for sure. It has propped up assets with huge doses of QE and zero rate interest policy (expect more of that when the ECB meets next month). You are correct about the size of stock markets. If the global market was a horse the bond market would be three legs of it! I digress.... However, if you are faced with massive debts then here are your options: 1) Default - Argentinian/Zimbabwe style. Not likely, at least until all other options tried - as that's the end game. 2) Grow the economy at a fast enough rate to meet and exceed future repayment obligations. In a global low anaemic growth environment? Unlikely. 3) Inflate like mad. It's the only viable option. You could, reasonably say, that after 3 massive QE sessions and ZIRP and now  NIRP that deflation is winning. Arguably it's all been a waste of time / money. Where's the kitchen sink? Presumably more of the same and then some helicopter money? It seems to me that this is more in line with Japan (targeted 10yr bond rate = 0%) which someone said in the 90s was  "...the dress rehearsal. The rest of the world will be the main event". Trying to get inflation without destroying the USD global reserve status is unlikely in my opinion and you can't help but feel that some sort of Bretton Woods global RESET will eventually emerge. It's certainly what Russia, China, Syria, Iran, Turkey etc are angling for.....and their central banks have been big buyers of bullion recently. That's why I'd recommend holding gold. Not as a trading strategy (which is what I appreciate this forum is). Nice sharing these thoughts with you>
×
×