How did you trade it though? The one on the left shows a break above R1 then a fall back down. The one on the right shows a sustained break for one candlestick period. So, if you are trading a breakout from R1 you lose 50% and win 50%. Not great odds really. If you wait for a pullback, then you miss all of the substantial breakout and get very little. Tricky. Difficult to call.