Jump to content
  • 0

Discrepancy between IG MT4 and Online platform


Guest RWw

Question

Hello!

So I was looking through the charts the other day and noticed something a bit odd. Well actually that IG MT4 platform is showing faulty price action. Something quite different from the Online platform but also other brokers.

The screenshot attached shows IG MT4, IG Online Platform and IC Markets MT4. In that order.

I added the trend line, in black, to highlight even further how the prices and candles don't add up. Notice how the trend line only touches two highs in IG MT4 but on the online platform it touches three tops and does so also in IC Markets MT4.

To highlight further the part where the price action is wrong in IG MT4 I added a red square in IG MT4 chart and a blue square in the charts where the price action is the same(which is also the correct one).

What is going on and how often does this happen?

mt4_IG_online_platform_IC.JPG

Link to comment

7 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

Hi @RWw, what you are highlighting is the difference between demo and live and weekend. Demo is not a mirror of live, it has it's own separate feed. Demo is a test bed for technicians that brokers allow clients to use to practice on, weekend is a derivative add on incorporating futures pricing and so not comparable to live or demo. Below are the screen shots for the same period for the web based platform live and mt4 live, and they are identical.   

image.thumb.png.efc3e80f7557f5024de2984984e77509.png

Link to comment

So, just to see if I understand this correctly. Here is a chart attached from my live CFD account with us30 cash and not weekend. Just to be extra clear this is an actual account where I can make trades with real money. Notice anything different from the previously posted chart? granted the previous one was weekend but this one isn't. Blue box for added focus.

So are you telling me my real account on the online platform is getting a data feed with demo data?

ig online platform wallstreet cash live.JPG

Link to comment

Hi @RWw,  ok, so to clarify, in your IG cfd web based platform chart pic above all the Sunday bars are missing, same in your IC Markets mt4 but not in the IG mt4 (first post).

So the difference is presumably related to being on European time zone where IG web based platform and IC Markets mt4 leave out the Sunday bar but the IG mt4 platform does not.

The pic below is from my cfd web platform (demo) UK time zone that have the Sunday bars included.

 

 

 

image.thumb.png.0f98ba50f02da6765e432b0cc2f97108.png

 

Link to comment

Hello!

Yeah that explains the Sunday bars missing, which I have no issue with. I don't necessarily agree with it working one way in MT4 and another with the web based platform but those are minor issues, kind of.

The Issue I have is the candles on 20181206 and 20181205. In MT4 it is a big red candle and then a green huge bullish Pinbar, but in Web platform(no matter what account I'm using be it CFD, Metatrader or Demo) it is a small green candle and then a huge red candle. How a Sunday candle affects Wednesdays(2011205) and Thursdays(20181206) candle is beyond me. It really shouldn't, unless looking at a higher time frame than daily of course but these charts are Daily. 

Link to comment

Turns out you are correct @Caseynotes. I finally had some time away from work and got in touch with a tech support and mt4 has it's cutoff point basically at midnight while Web version does it at close of NYSE. That is also what the charts show when looking at the 1H. e.g. The Huqwei CFO got arrested after NYSE had closed but not before MT4 had it's cutoff point for the daily candle. Hence the different candles.

Thanks for taking the time!

Link to comment

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • image.png

  • Posts

    • Silver Elliott Wave Analysis  Function -Trend Mode - Trend Structure - Impulse for blue wave A Position - Wave 5 of (5) Direction - Wave 5 of (5) in play Details -Wave 5 of (5) extends higher. There appears to be room for more before prices start turning down for a retracement. Same interpretation as the previous update. Silver has moved sideways for nearly 72 hours amid a strong year-long bullish trend. The price is more likely to break to the upside to continue this trend. However, if it breaks to the downside, buyers are expected to push the price up again shortly thereafter. Nevertheless, a significant pullback lasting several weeks is anticipated at some point. The question is: how much higher can the metal go before this pullback?   On the daily chart, the price extends the bullish sequence that began at 11.645 in March 2020. This sequence could either complete a double zigzag with a 100% target at 37 and potentially extend further to 48.3. If 48.3 is breached, the likelihood that the sequence will turn into an impulse wave increases. Whether it becomes an impulse or remains a corrective sequence is not crucial at this point since both scenarios project further rallies, with the impulse wave having a higher target. Currently, attention should be on the impulse sequence that started in January 2024, which is expected to complete blue wave A of the primary degree or blue wave 1 of an impulse. The impulse is close to completing its 5th wave—wave 5—after which a pullback is expected. The H4 chart shows the progress of wave (5) of the impulse and how much further it could go before the pullback begins. The price is currently in wave 3 of (5). Wave 3 appears to be incomplete, with the current triangle serving as the 4th sub-wave of wave 3, i.e., blue wave iv. Traders can expect the triangle to break to the upside to complete wave 3, followed by a minor pullback for wave 4 and further advances for wave 5. At the end of wave 5, we can expect a peak and a downward turn for primary degree wave B (in blue on the daily chart), which could last for several weeks. Technical Analyst : Sanmi Adeagbo Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!  
    • SPOT Elliott Wave Analysis Trading Lounge Daily Chart, Spotify Technology S.A., (SPOT) Daily Chart SPOT Elliott Wave Technical Analysis FUNCTION: Trend MODE: Impulsive STRUCTURE: Motive POSITION: Minor 5. DIRECTION: Upside in Minor 5   DETAILS: Looking for start moving higher after trading around TL3 at 300$. Looking for further upside towards at least the end of MG2 at 330$.   SPOT Elliott Wave Analysis Trading Lounge 4Hr Chart, Spotify Technology S.A., (SPOT) 4Hr Chart SPOT Elliott Wave Technical Analysis FUNCTION: Trend MODE: Impulsive STRUCTURE: Motive POSITION: Minor 5. DIRECTION: Upside in Minor 5   DETAILS: Looking for a triangle in 4 to be completed. There is a possibility we just completed wave {iv} and not 4, as equality of  Minor 3 vs. 1 stands at 340$.     Welcome to our latest Elliott Wave analysis for Spotify Technology S.A. (SPOT). In this report, we provide a detailed examination of SPOT's price movements and future projections using the Elliott Wave Theory. This analysis will cover both the daily and 4-hour charts, offering insights into the current trends and potential trading opportunities. Whether you are a seasoned trader or a market enthusiast, this analysis aims to enhance your understanding of SPOT's market behavior.   * SPOT Elliott Wave Technical Analysis – Daily Chart* In our latest Elliott Wave analysis of Spotify Technology S.A. (SPOT), we observe a bullish trend with an impulsive structure. Currently positioned at Minor wave 5, SPOT is gearing up for an upside move in Minor 5. After trading around Trading Level 3 (TL3) at $300, we anticipate further upside towards at least the end of Major Group 2 (MG2) at $330. Traders should be prepared for a potential continuation of the upward trend as the market gains momentum.   * SPOT Elliott Wave Technical Analysis – 4Hr Chart* On the 4-hour chart, SPOT is also exhibiting an impulsive mode within a motive structure, specifically positioned in Minor wave 5. We are looking for the completion of a triangle in wave 4. However, there is a possibility that we have just completed wave {iv} instead of 4, with the equality of Minor wave 3 vs. 1 standing at $340. This scenario suggests further upside potential as SPOT continues to move higher in wave 5.   Technical Analyst : Alessio Barretta Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!  
    • The anticipated drop in UK's CPI data for April is a key determinant for a potential interest rate cut in June by the Bank of England.   Source: Getty Images   Forex Shares Consumer price index Pound sterling Market trend GBP/USD Written by: Richard Snow | Analyst, DailyFX, Johannesburg   Publication date: Wednesday 22 May 2024 07:14 On Wednesday, the UK's Consumer Price Index (CPI) data is expected to decline for both headline and core measures. Consensus estimates project the headline measure dropping significantly from 3.2% to 2.1%. This lofty expectation could lead to market disappointment if the figures come in higher than anticipated. Even a small miss to the upside would still represent substantial progress. Economic calendar   Source: DailyFX In April of last year, services inflation re-accelerated more than expected, continuing into May and June, prompting the Bank of England to raise interest rates during its June 2023 meeting. However, this year’s guidance suggests that the data may be less extreme due to generally lower headline prices. Services prices, often index-linked to headline prices, are not expected to pass through as significantly as in 2023. UK Services CPI Year-on-Year Change (April -July)   Source: Refinitiv A UK inflation print that meets or undershoots expectations could catalyse bearish sentiment for sterling, particularly given the waning GBP/USD price action below the 1.2736 level. Given the high inflation expectations, even a slight upside miss might still exert bearish pressure, reflecting the overall progress towards the 2% inflation target. The presence of upper wicks and small candle bodies in GBP/USD charts suggests diminishing bullish momentum, potentially leading to a lower move if catalysed by appropriate data. Should prices cap at 1.2736, a downward movement would remain constructive following a better-than-expected CPI print. The pound has rallied against the dollar since April's lower US CPI print. A short bias would be invalidated at 1.2800, with support and a short target set at 1.2585. GBP/USD daily chart   Source: TradingView Markets currently view a June cut as a 50/50 outcome ahead of UK CPI – enhancing its importance in the lead up to the central bank meeting. A softer CPI print, followed by dovish comments from BoE officials creates an environment where the first rate cut since the hiking cycle may be upon us sooner than expected. However, if inflation fails to match up to the lofty expectations, pricing may reflect a preference for August or even later in the year. Implied rate cuts into year end (in basis points)   Source: Refinitiv       This information has been prepared by IG, a trading name of IG Australia Pty Ltd. In addition to the disclaimer below, the material on this page does not contain a record of our trading prices, or an offer of, or solicitation for, a transaction in any financial instrument. IG accepts no responsibility for any use that may be made of these comments and for any consequences that result. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information. Consequently any person acting on it does so entirely at their own risk. Any research provided does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and needs of any specific person who may receive it. It has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is considered to be a marketing communication. Although we are not specifically constrained from dealing ahead of our recommendations we do not seek to take advantage of them before they are provided to our clients.
×
×
  • Create New...
us