Jump to content

Share Trading Vs Share ISA

Recommended Posts

Hey - So the only difference as far as I can see is the fact that you have to pay tax on profits in the regular share dealing account. In the ISA share account you can put up to 20k GBP in there per year and any profits you earn are tax free. This is part of a government allowance. This means that you should use the ISA acct before the share dealing in order to maximise your benefit. 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
3 minutes ago, Fletch said:

The ISA is just a wrapper that protects the investments from UK tax. Other than the funding limitation (£20,000 per tax year) and some restriction on the type of ETFs that can be put in an ISA, they are essentially the same thing.

IG's ISA page: https://www.ig.com/uk/investments/isa

So it would be subject to the same charges and commissions as a share trading account,  but the profits from this are Not taxable, is this correct? Also like standard bank isas any funds within the account are not subject to being locked in the account for a period of time?


is this correct, many thanks

Link to comment

is it 20k funding each year or profit/capital gains?


i believe with normal share dealing the first 12.5k of profit is not taxable anyway if you have no other capital gains  elsewhere in the tax year

Edited by DannnoB
Link to comment
33 minutes ago, DannnoB said:

is it 20k funding each year or profit/capital gains?


i believe with normal share dealing the first 12.5k of profit is not taxable anyway if you have no other capital gains  elsewhere in the tax year

20k of funding. And yes, for most people, in the short term it probably won't save you tax, because you wouldn't be earning enough from the shares to liable for it anyway. However, over the course of 10, 15, 20 years of investment, the story might be very different.

Link to comment
  • 2 weeks later...
15 minutes ago, BASA said:

So to summarise throughout the year I can put up into 20K nvestment into the account,  by taking money out, putting money back in etc but I am only paying tax on anything over 12.5K


You're not paying tax on anything within the ISA. That is fundamentally the point of it. Unless of course the government decides to change the rules at some point in a desperate bid to raise some money.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Guest Reply to tax question
21 hours ago, BASA said:

Thanks Fletch, I had done some reading after I posted  so basically, I gather, any profit from up to 20k investment is non taxable at all, 

I did some research on this, a lot in fact and discussed it with my accountant. 

ISA: You can transfer up to £20,000 INTO your ISA in any tax year (April to April). If you take some out then pay it back in, the withdrawal is not included in your allowance. eg you pay in £10,000, you take out £5,000, you can now only put in another £10,000. You cannot also replace the £5,000 you took out in addition to the £20,000 deposit limit. 

If you are in a Fund and Share type of ISA where you can trade and deal, any profit you make is tax free. So, for example you could pay in £20,000 a year for 5 years, and be a mega-successful trader and trade up to £1,000,000 or more (hypothetically) and there would be no tax to pay on your £900,000 gains. None, of any kind. 

Outside of an ISA you are only allowed the Income and Capital Gains allowances that are relevant to that year. Above those all gains are taxed. There is, however, an interesting loophole: If you use Spread Betting (this doesn't apply to CFDs), and if it is not your main source of income, then gains from spread betting can be treated by the Inland Revenue as gambling, and are therefore not taxed. What constitutes "not your main source of income" is the grey area though. If you have a regular job and pay income tax, you can claim that spread betting is secondary. However if you build an account up to a size where you are regularly making more than your salary, the Inland Revenue can, at their discretion, claim that it has become your main source of income, and that you are a professional trader - at which point you might get a pretty big tax bill. So, as long as it's small you can spread bet outside an ISA and put £20,000 into an ISA for CFD trading each year. 

Link to comment

Do you know if the share trading account has limits on it?

i am getting close to maxing my ISA out for the tax year, so if I have money later in year I will need to invest in Share dealing & just wondering if I can invest in both & there is any limits.

Thanks in advance

Link to comment

If you buys via the normal share dealing route then any gains are subject to capital gains tax - this tax year you can make gains of £12,300 the rest is subject to taxation at varying rates depending on your tax status - 10% for a basic rate tax payer and 20% for high rate tax status etc - see https://www.gov.uk/browse/tax/capital-gains

You can buy the SAME shares and ETF's within an ISA - its exactly the same as share dealing but you don't pay capital gains 0 its a tax-free wrapper for investments

Your first port of call should be an ISA, then one for your spouse if you have one, then share dealing - Then every year use the share dealing account to fund new ISA(s) contributions

I haven't bought a share or ETF outside of my ISA for the past 10 years - doesn;t make sense tax wise


Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
    • Total Members
    • Most Online
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Joined 25/09/22 18:52
  • Posts

    • Hey @pravid17 I hope you're well.  In the leveraged trading industry there are brokers who don't hedge client's exposure and brokers (like ourselves) who do hedge client's exposure.  In a perfect world the exposure of short clients would net off the trades of long clients however this is not always the case. Our hedging model allows us to take an exposure in the underlying market for the remaining exposure which doesn't offset - This way we don't need to hedge every trade, worry about profits of our clients and results in lower costs for hedging in the underlying market (commissions, interest etc.). So say 60% of IG customer exposure in the ASX was long and 40% of exposure on the ASX was short. The 40% would net each other off but there's a remaining 20% of customers who need to be hedged to cover their positions. We go into the market and hedge this.  We make our money primarily through our spreads and overnight funding  with other fees making up a small proportion of our revenue. I would like to remind also that IG is regulated by several bodies globally, including top-tier regulators like the UK's FCA, Germany's BaFIN, Australia's ASIC - This should be quite reassuring from a dealing execution and transparency perspective.  I hope this helps, let me know if you have any other question 
    • A survey from Reviews.org, which featured 1000 Americans, found that as many as 1 in 4 US subscribers may quit the service in the next year.    Jeremy Naylor | Writer, London | Publication date: Friday 23 September 2022  There was an interesting breakdown, but the main reason was affordability. Only 18% said they would move to a cheaper competitor. IGTV’s Jeremy Naylor looks at the numbers. Netflix subscription woes Netflix Inc (All Sessions) could be in for a rough time ahead over the next 12 months if a new survey is anything to go by, which was conducted in the US. Out of the 1,000 adults that took part in this survey undertaken by Reviews.org, around 25% of those that were covered said that they would be cancelling their Netflix subscription within the next 12 months. Now, it says with that 25% of US subscribers to Netflix considering leaving, not to join a competitor, but mostly because of pressures on household bills. This is how it is split: rising cost of subscriptions - 40% inflation - 20% a lack of content - 22% spending more time on the services of others - 18% So you can see, a minority said they were going to other services, such as those provided by Disney Plus or Amazon Prime. The cost of Netflix has risen dramatically this year as its basic plan increased by 11% in January and its other plans by 20% to 25%. Now these were the first price increases for three years, so that itself is relatively new for a lot of subscribers. Netflix share price Let's take a look at the Netflix share price. You can see on the far left hand side of this chart the COVID lows at $290.39. We saw a whacking great increase there of 141% to the top and the record high in Netflix shares back in November 2021. And that was when subscriptions were rising, people were paying more for their services, and it was all humming beautifully. And then all of a sudden people started questioning the numbers of streaming services they were undertaking with some deciding to withdraw from Netflix. All of a sudden the big drops started coming through with profit warnings and sales warnings. We've recently hit a new low of $162.50. Since then there has been a little bit of an increase. We're currently trading at $232.75, but we are down by a margin of 1.75% in today's session, which reflects this news that we could well see a relatively large drop in subscribers for Netflix in the US within the next 12 months.
    • Market data to trade the week of 26 September: Nasdaq; NXT From the economic calendar next week IG technical analyst, Axel Rudolph, picks up on a short trade on the Nasdaq around US inflation data. Meanwhile, despite another light week of corporate data, Axel picks out the chart of Next plc (NXT) as an interesting trade to think about.          
  • Create New...