Jump to content

Closing Only


MillerThomas227

Recommended Posts

I think if IG is a reputable company and wishes to exit small caps spread betting it ought to close to new bets but allow customers three months to exit their positions at their own speed. 
 

I personally use spread bets to avoid capital gains so would still be interested in trading these stocks even with 100% margin requirements. 

Link to comment

@CharlotteIGi would be interested in your views. 

 

I think if IG is a reputable company and wishes to exit small caps spread betting it ought to close to new bets but allow customers three months to exit their positions at their own speed. 
 

I personally use spread bets to avoid capital gains so would still be interested in trading these stocks even with 100% margin requirements. 

Link to comment

I agree with MalcolmBell1

there have been several occasions where I have been unable to open a position on an aim company. I have then resorted to buying via a broker. Defeats the purpose of having an account with IG if your only interest is in AIM. 

 

Link to comment

If IG is a genuinely responsible company which I believe it is then it must treat customers with open positions fairly - its one thing to cease allowing customers to open new positions but if a customer has a position in a stock open they must be allowed to exit when they want over 3-6 months. It would be responsible to increase margin rates only a certain amount (why not 50% so its half way / treating customers fairly?), give a month's notice and not to impose a deadline on having to exit the stock any less than 3 months away. It seems outrageous after this three month period not to then allow open positions at 100% margin. The FCA would surely be horrified at hundreds of customers being forced sellers of stocks with a few days notice.

Edited by Malcolmbell1
  • Like 1
Link to comment

@CaseyNotes:

I am asking you and I am saying that a post about men's Jean pockets has nothing got to do with the very serious question of IG setting positions to "closing only" nor the hypothesis being promulgated on social media that up to 1000 IG product offerings will be set to 100% margin on 26 February thus requiring clients to deposit money to fully fund positions or potentially suffer forced closure.

Now if you are trying to obfuscate the thread it would say something for itself.  We have had IG on the thread already and we do need IG coming back in the thread to clarify what their intention is.

Link to comment
3 minutes ago, StormChaser said:

@CaseyNotes:

I am asking you and I am saying that a post about men's Jean pockets has nothing got to do with the very serious question of IG setting positions to "closing only" nor the hypothesis being promulgated on social media that up to 1000 IG product offerings will be set to 100% margin on 26 February thus requiring clients to deposit money to fully fund positions or potentially suffer forced closure.

Now if you are trying to obfuscate the thread it would say something for itself.  We have had IG on the thread already and we do need IG coming back in the thread to clarify what their intention is.

And the point I am making is that IG has always shied away from markets if they become high risk, that's what their traditional client base expects. 

I and most other IG clients expect IG to close the book on any particular market if and when risk endangers all clients.

I was glad everytime IG closed the book on Bitcoin during late 2017 and on many other markets since.

There are plenty of other brokers who exercise a higher risk business model. Use them.

 

.

  • Like 1
Link to comment

It is NOT OKAY to close the book on open positions AND increase the margin with virtually NO NOTICE.  That is what is being discussed here.  Clients enter into a trade with certain expectations about their cash flow and to suddenly change that is unacceptable.  I have already said that.

I doubt you would be so glad if the book was closed on something that caused you to have to prematurely liquidate or raise cash to keep open.

I'd rather the Administrators respond to this rather than an IG forum fan boy.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
8 hours ago, StormChaser said:

It is NOT OKAY to close the book on open positions AND increase the margin with virtually NO NOTICE.  That is what is being discussed here.  Clients enter into a trade with certain expectations about their cash flow and to suddenly change that is unacceptable.  I have already said that.

I doubt you would be so glad if the book was closed on something that caused you to have to prematurely liquidate or raise cash to keep open.

I'd rather the Administrators respond to this rather than an IG forum fan boy.

Actually the OP of this thread was about 'closing only' and SPACs, you must be meaning a different thread. IG have always used closing only when markets suddenly go one way and high risk and the margin requirement does change for the same reasons, they have only ever said they will try to give advanced notification.

Are you sure you're not in the wrong shop? Maybe you should try Robinhood, oh wait, they're nearly bust aren't they.

Link to comment
6 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

Actually the OP of this thread was about 'closing only' and SPACs, you must be meaning a different thread. IG have always used closing only when markets suddenly go one way and high risk and the margin requirement does change for the same reasons, they have only ever said they will try to give advanced notification.

Are you sure you're not in the wrong shop? Maybe you should try Robinhood, oh wait, they're nearly bust aren't they.

IG will force close all those positions after 30 days, it's not just a margin requirement thing, they will not allow us to keep our positions even if we have the margin. Doesn't make any sense at all.

Link to comment

What fun when a broker goes bust, remember IronFX and the Chinese traders who charted a plane to take them to protest outside the regulators office for weeks on end? Didn't do them any good though.

What about that slow mo car crash that was FXCM, wiped out in the SNP peg move, had to borrow massive to try to keep going til SEC finally shut them down as the were just running on fumes.

Took years to sort out clients money, some got some back some got nothing, tough.

One of the big changes introduced by ESMA in 2018 was the introduction of negative account protection, that shifted a lot of risk onto the broker and there was always going to be a price for that.

Personally I have always avoided the higher risk markets, remember late 2017 when everyone was piling into crypto? Go long, couldn't lose - except most did because the intraday swings were so violent poor peeps were continually getting stopped out on the bounce. I was reminded of that when looking at the intraday GameStop chart, on the daily it looked like a one way ride but intrady price was swing 150% up AND down. Hard to control risk on that sort of market.

Most of IG's current clients would leave IG if they were ever seen to be a high risk broker.

 

.

Link to comment

I am a premium client and was not contacted. I am very angry about this and the false market that was created - i phoned last week to ask why my stocks were close only but was told completely incorrect information. These are equities  - i absolutely do not get forced closure under the spread bet wrapper with a few days notice and differential disclosure to different clients, fair enough increasing margins. There is no doubt Ig moved these markets in the last few days as a result. A reputable company would have allowed customers 6 months to close. Maintaining dealing account dealing in these stocks suggests they should have maintained spread betting for the tax benefits at 100% margin.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
20 hours ago, StormChaser said:

Charlotte: There's commentary doing the rounds on Twitter that IG is going to raise the margin on a whole range of stock SBs to 100%?  Is this true?  I have received no notice to this effect.

Here is the information you need regarding the stocks we've set to closings only on leverage: 


We constantly review the products we offer in line with client demand. We have reviewed associated returns across our 12,000 leveraged share markets and decided to withdraw around 900 small-cap shares for spread betting and CFD accounts. These markets will continue to be available for share dealing – find out how to open a share dealing account below.

The list of affected shares that will be withdrawn from spread betting and CFD accounts are listed in this PDF. Please read on for details about the process, but in summary:

1.We are increasing margins so that all positions on these shares will have a margin requirement of 100% at 3pm on Friday 26 February

2.Please close positions by Monday 29 March 2021, from which point we will start to close any remaining open positions

3.You will still be able to buy the majority of shares outright using our share dealing service

What happens next?

For a small subset of the affected markets (listed as ‘set 1’ in the PDF), margin requirements are already at 100%. For the remaining markets (listed as ‘set 2’ in the PDF), margin requirements will increase to 100% from 3pm (UK time) on Friday 26 February.

You have until Monday 29 March 2021 to close your open positions on affected markets, from which point we will start to close any positions still open. Positions will be closed as soon as practical from this point, while ensuring that all reasonable steps are taken to obtain the best results for our clients. This action is taken in accordance with Term 28(3) of the latest version of the applicable customer agreement governing your account(s) with IG.

We encourage you to review your exposure and consider how best to manage your position(s). Should you wish to maintain your existing position(s) with IG in the short term, please ensure that you have enough money on your account(s) to cover the new margin requirements.

We understand that you may need time to decide what to do, or to seek alternative exposure. Nonetheless, we urge you to close your position(s) before Monday 29 March to ensure that you have discretion over the closure.

Can I invest in these markets via share dealing?

Yes, most of them will remain available via share dealing. While you won’t be able to transfer existing leveraged position(s) from a spread betting or CFD account to an IG share dealing account, you can use an IG share dealing account to buy the majority of affected shares outright.

To add a share dealing account if you don’t already have one, log in to My IG and click ‘add account’, then ‘share dealing’ – or simply click the button below.

Link to comment
4 minutes ago, CharlotteIG said:

Here is the information you need regarding the stocks we've set to closings only on leverage: 


We constantly review the products we offer in line with client demand. We have reviewed associated returns across our 12,000 leveraged share markets and decided to withdraw around 900 small-cap shares for spread betting and CFD accounts. These markets will continue to be available for share dealing – find out how to open a share dealing account below.

The list of affected shares that will be withdrawn from spread betting and CFD accounts are listed in this PDF. Please read on for details about the process, but in summary:

1.We are increasing margins so that all positions on these shares will have a margin requirement of 100% at 3pm on Friday 26 February

2.Please close positions by Monday 29 March 2021, from which point we will start to close any remaining open positions

3.You will still be able to buy the majority of shares outright using our share dealing service

What happens next?

For a small subset of the affected markets (listed as ‘set 1’ in the PDF), margin requirements are already at 100%. For the remaining markets (listed as ‘set 2’ in the PDF), margin requirements will increase to 100% from 3pm (UK time) on Friday 26 February.

You have until Monday 29 March 2021 to close your open positions on affected markets, from which point we will start to close any positions still open. Positions will be closed as soon as practical from this point, while ensuring that all reasonable steps are taken to obtain the best results for our clients. This action is taken in accordance with Term 28(3) of the latest version of the applicable customer agreement governing your account(s) with IG.

We encourage you to review your exposure and consider how best to manage your position(s). Should you wish to maintain your existing position(s) with IG in the short term, please ensure that you have enough money on your account(s) to cover the new margin requirements.

We understand that you may need time to decide what to do, or to seek alternative exposure. Nonetheless, we urge you to close your position(s) before Monday 29 March to ensure that you have discretion over the closure.

Can I invest in these markets via share dealing?

Yes, most of them will remain available via share dealing. While you won’t be able to transfer existing leveraged position(s) from a spread betting or CFD account to an IG share dealing account, you can use an IG share dealing account to buy the majority of affected shares outright.

To add a share dealing account if you don’t already have one, log in to My IG and click ‘add account’, then ‘share dealing’ – or simply click the button below.

So in reality what will happen is that IG will catch your clients out because many will not have the funds available to meet the 100% margin required by 26th February.

They will then go on margin call and be forced to close on Friday or Monday rather than having until March 29th.  This is likely to force some clients to have to liquidate and accept losses on positions which might have pending newsflow which would make them come good.

Whether or not this is within IGs terms or not, it is going to make IG look very bad.  If there are 900 stocks there are likely to be many hundreds, if not thousands, of affected clients.

It would be difficult to justify maintaining a relationship with IG following this action.

  • Like 3
Link to comment

As I already said to my account manager, if I'm forced out of any positions I'm leaving. It doesn't matter if the decision comes from the CEO or not, this is my personal choice. I want to be doing business with a company that has my interests at heart too, not just theirs. To ask me to close out my positions while I still have the money in my account doesn't make any sense at all. If IG doesn't have the money to hedge just issue senior notes or a common offering to raise funds. It's very easy to come up with funds. At least leave us the choice to transform the CFD to a common stock, this choice is not available to me. Why ? You should give us more time than just 30 days, at least 6 months to close our positions. 30 days will force many of us to close trades at very unfavorable prices, booking losses. 

Link to comment
1 hour ago, StormChaser said:

So in reality what will happen is that IG will catch your clients out because many will not have the funds available to meet the 100% margin required by 26th February.

They will then go on margin call and be forced to close on Friday or Monday rather than having until March 29th.  This is likely to force some clients to have to liquidate and accept losses on positions which might have pending newsflow which would make them come good.

Whether or not this is within IGs terms or not, it is going to make IG look very bad.  If there are 900 stocks there are likely to be many hundreds, if not thousands, of affected clients.

It would be difficult to justify maintaining a relationship with IG following this action.

 

47 minutes ago, Joo said:

As I already said to my account manager, if I'm forced out of any positions I'm leaving. It doesn't matter if the decision comes from the CEO or not, this is my personal choice. I want to be doing business with a company that has my interests at heart too, not just theirs. To ask me to close out my positions while I still have the money in my account doesn't make any sense at all. If IG doesn't have the money to hedge just issue senior notes or a common offering to raise funds. It's very easy to come up with funds. At least leave us the choice to transform the CFD to a common stock, this choice is not available to me. Why ? You should give us more time than just 30 days, at least 6 months to close our positions. 30 days will force many of us to close trades at very unfavorable prices, booking losses. 

I'm going to pass all feedback onto our senior team regarding these changes.

Apologies again for the inconvenience but know these comments are getting pushed to senior teams so thank you for posting them. 

All the best. 

Link to comment
Guest Magnolia

Why would anyone want to open a position in a market that is still available if IG might decide to terminate that market with no notice in the future? It isn't just small caps that are affected, Hikma is a FTSE100 company - why is that on the list?  and there are several FTSE250s that I've spotted e.g. Hiscox, Hochschild

Link to comment

I've just heard the rumour about this. To not yet give notice and expect 100% margin by Friday is not on!

I would be non the wiser had I not stumbled across it.

Please do rethink the timescales to cover.

Link to comment

I've already had to close a number of positions which were significantly up today, but which I expected more to come - mainly commodity related ETF's. This has hurt my trust in IG and the damage is already done as far as I'm concerned as i've now been forced to make a decision in preparation for Friday.

  • Like 2
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      16,650
    • Total Posts
      79,434
    • Total Members
      65,141
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    NastyBoss
    Joined 04/12/21 01:21
  • Posts

    • Hi ya i phoned ig to find out what time now in the uk do the markets close after hour went back. Im on , us oil  i was told 9 pm but its still trading just now at 9.36 thanks for nothing 
    • Hi.. I'm aware that there are I think monthly or quarterly fees for an account, and these can be minimised by doing X amount of trades per month.  But if I had for example 2 share dealing accounts and an ISA account (which I do), will I have to pay 3 sets of account fees? And if I do, do my number of trades have to be in just one to take advantage of reduction of fees across the board or it just applies to that account? Hope that makes sense, Thanks ,😊
    • NFP TALKING POINTS: This morning’s NFP report disappointed on the headline number and in Average Hourly Earnings. On the positive side, the unemployment rate fell to 4.2%, below the Fed’s threshold for ‘maximum employment.’ This morning’s NFP report had little to be excited about with the headline figure printing at a paltry 235k v/s the expected 550k. Also disappointing was the Average Hourly Earnings portion of the report, which denotes inflation in the more important mechanism of wage growth. On the positive side, the unemployment rank dropped to 4.2%, below the 4.5% expected and the 4.6% from last month. This is important as the Fed has been saying that they’re looking for ‘maximum employment’ before tilting policy in a more-hawkish direction. The Fed’s line-in-the-sand for maximum employment is 4.5% so, we’re there. The bank has previously said that they’d like to see multiple months of this before making any knee-jerk decisions, but this is something that will likely be noted at the December FOMC rate decision. In response to the this morning’s NFP report, little was clear across markets. The US Dollar put in a quick drop but that was met with a bullish response. As of this writing, 45 minutes after the release, and the US Dollar is trading at a session high after recovering the entirety of the NFP-fueled sell-off. As I had shared yesterday, the bullish theme in the US Dollar remains a major push point across FX markets, and this morning’s reaction to the NFP print has proven this to be correct again. US DOLLAR ONE MINUTE PRICE CHART Chart prepared by James Stanley; USD, DXY on Tradingview   Written by James Stanley, Senior Strategist for DailyFX.com
×
×
  • Create New...