Jump to content
  • 0

Why does the API return different data to shown in the web app, with low prices not being lowest? [Solved... user error]

Question

I was trying to write some algorithms using the API, but I keep finding instances where the data doesn't seem to add up (and is different to what's shown in the web app).

 

Here's one example where the lowPrice has a higher bid than the closePrice according to the API - however the low bid price shown in the web app is lower. The result is that I have candles where the wicks go inside the body (this happens if I draw using bid, or using mid points).

 

I can't figure out why the web app and the API would show different data (this isn't the only place, I've found several instances of this and I've barely done any checking!)..

Untitled.png

Edited by DanT

Share this post


Link to post

5 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
On 29/08/2019 at 22:48, DanT said:

Ha, this is embarassing... It was my bug - there was a typo in the script I used to save the data from the API to disk to reuse 😁

No problem, glad it's all working for you now :)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Ha, this is embarassing... It was my bug - there was a typo in the script I used to save the data from the API to disk to reuse 😁

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
Guest Alan Oliver

IG have responded to a request regarding the unsatisfactory operations of their web trader platforms.

The web platform has known issues, i.e. it does not show the correct prices of the underlying market as the market prices change. If you are a trader who places a trade based on the ticket price, or the bar/candle chart, or the horizontal fill lines, be aware!! I have sent graphic shots of three different entry prices on the same chart at the same time depending on whether you are looking at the ticket, the bar or the entry order lines.

The response from IG is copied below:

Thanks for your email. There is already an investigation for the problem where sometimes the bid/ask price will fall outside of what is displayed on the charts, the reference number for it is INC0337629. It is a display problem which does not affect the execution of the trade, it also only seems to happen on the web platform so if you are unsure of the chart price then you can compare it to the chart price on the mobile app. 

Regards,
Anton Liebenberg
Trading Services

What is so surprising is that someone in a support role is so ignorant of trading. Any trader who manually enters a position or manages stops manually is at a distinct disadvantage with IG...of course your trade is affected if the price on the chart/bar is 6708 and you get filled at 6710 (when the spread is 1 point)..but of course you should know to have your phone app running at the same time to make sure your web price is at the real price !! Really, seriously?

My suggestion: Dont trade with IG. They have shown here they know they have an issue but are happy not to oblige their clients with refunds when their platform fills at wrong prices. 

You have been warned....

Alan Oliver.

Account now permanently closed. Close yours asap.....

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I never traded with real money here - I was disappointed enough with the demo system that I decided I just didn't trust it. I frequently ended up with trades that were open but not listed in the web app, or listed in the web app but actually closed (clearing cookies, app data, logging out/in did not help). Every time I contacted them they said this only happened on demo because it was "a simulated environment" and if it did ever happen on live (wait, I thought it couldn't?) I would be compensated. I wouldn't like to have that fight since it would be very difficult prove from screenshots what had occurred. With the stakes involved, it's critical customers can trust the platform, and I just didn't.

 

There were also other small annoying things, like having hugely different minimum bets between live/demo, which makes moving to live harder because you might find you can't do some of the things you were doing on demo on live (I did report this a few times, but it was never fixed before I gave up).

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
5 hours ago, DanT said:

I wouldn't like to have that fight since it would be very difficult prove from screenshots what had occurred

This is a good point

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      11,962
    • Total Posts
      60,588
    • Total Members
      80,588
    Newest Member
    AGR1173
    Joined 12/08/20 18:20
  • Posts

    • Thanks for the feedback.  I currently use TV for my technical analysis, as the features available on IG platform are not quite on par. The fundamental data functionality is good if you are looking / using at a micro level, but not quite what I'm after.  Providers I had in mind were the likes of Stockopedia, MorningStar premium etc. - something that can a consolidated view in an easily digestable / usable manner.   
    • If in the UK you can buy physical silver (coins or bars) from the royal mint or royal mint authorised dealers. Just search the internet. You probably want to buy whatever is captial gains tax exempt (I think silver britannias are). Shop around for the best price and also be careful about VAT as I think you may have to pay that on some purchases and not on others . Of course when you buy physical silver in UK as an investment you also have to consider what GBP/ USD is up to as any change in  exchange rate in future will affect your return (as silver is priced in USD). If you don't want physical then you could buy shares in a silver ETF (eg. SSLN) which is  backed by physical metal or if you want to spread bet it you could buy spot silver. It all depends why you want to buy it. If just as an investment then you get a better return buying etf or spread betting (easier to cash in when you want to and potentially less hassles with tax). If you are worried the banking system will freeze up and you can't get money out at some point in the future ( possibly not likely but you can never rule it out) then it's physical - stored outside the banking system either with a company or stored somewhere by yourself. I'm not an expert on this but have just read a bit about it lately as lots of articles suggesting silver will go higher over the next months / year.  
    • I don't know. But there is good profit taking.
×
×