Jump to content

Fibonacci without Elliot Wave?


Recommended Posts

I originally thought you could use Fibonacci lines like support/resistance.  But that doesn't seem to be the right approach.  What's the advantage of using Fibonacci without also applying Elliot Wave Principle ideas regarding lengths of waves?

So the simplest rule is you measure from bottom to top and if price comes back 23.6 - 50% before going back up again then you buy?  Is that really effective?  It doesn't seem like it is.  🤔

Link to comment
3 hours ago, dmedin said:

PRT can draw S/R for you ... why not just leave it to the machine?

Because I believe I can do better than a bot when it comes to drawing trendlines and S/R... Just looking at your chart I can tell I would have drawn the lines at different levels.

See the support at 12876.9 for example. That is NOT a good support in my opinion, the system just drew a line at the latest lower low. A good support would be at 13000, because the price bounced 5 times (once as a resistance then 4 times as a suppport), and it is a psychological level (round number). Same with the line connecting the highs, it just connected the first high to the latest high, ignoring all the action in the middle.

Finally, I don't trade the daily. The system is even worse on lower timeframes.

  • Like 2
Link to comment

you are both right because support and resistance supply and demand should really be thought of as zones rather than rigid lines. These zones are areas where you suspect many orders will be waiting and it's unlikely everyone will pick the exact same price level, some will want execution a bit earlier, some a bit later, that's if there are any at all.

  • Like 2
Link to comment

I'd rather use lines, but think of my lines like the center of your zones, because it doesn't matter for me if the price doesn't bounce exactly on it. I think zones are great but I want my daily levels on the chart when I trade small timeframes and zones would just paint the M5 screen black when trading within it. For example for the 13000 level we discussed, if I was trading it I would wait to see a reversal signal on H1/M15/M5 timeframes to enter the trade, doesn't matter if the price goes a little lower.

Edited by oxygen4life
  • Like 1
Link to comment
5 hours ago, Caseynotes said:

These zones are areas where you suspect many orders will be waiting

Surely the big money interests know that there will be many traders looking to buy retracements and will use that knowledge to give fake signals ... that's what I can see when I use Fibonacci to trade.

Fibonacci is only ever useful when used in hindsight and you deliberately manipulate it to line up with certain historical price points.  😞

 

Edited by dmedin
  • Like 1
Link to comment
9 minutes ago, dmedin said:

Fibonacci is only ever useful when used in hindsight and you deliberately manipulate it to line up with certain historical price points.  😞

 

If Fibonacci wasn't profitable it wouldn't be used so widely. It is a great tool in trends on ANY timeframe, I've seen people be profitable using it on the 100-ticks chart. You were talking about Eliott waves on the first post, its principles are 100% based on Fibonacci and traders with 30 years of experience use it daily.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
9 minutes ago, oxygen4life said:

You were talking about Eliott waves on the first post, its principles are 100% based on Fibonacci and traders with 30 years of experience use it daily.

Yes, my question is, can you really just draw up Fibs or do you have to use them in the context of an EWP pattern system(which is pretty much inaccessible for most people).

  • Like 1
Link to comment

In this example I just went long because it stopped making a pattern of lower lows and lower highs, and the MAs aligned (in fact they were aligned at the morning star/bullish Doji that bounced off the 50 SMA).

 What is the use for Fibonacci, unless you are thinking this is a retrace rally in which case you would use the Fibonacci extension?  How is that better than straightforward 'Dow Theory' and using trailing stops to lock in profits?

275160956_Oil-BrentCrude_20200216_17_30.thumb.png.b71c73ab520bab6f98768a09d6a4f3c7.png

 

Edited by dmedin
Link to comment

FIb is used to get the information where the price will pullback before continuation of the trend, not for trend reversals. Fib retracements can be used with basic trendlines, Fib extensions is a bit more advanced as its target vary depending on which Elliott wave you're currently on. I wouldn't use extensions without Elliott.

In your first example as you broke the trendline you need to look at the bigger picture. If the higher timeframe is in a downtrend too, look for an ABC pattern on this timeframe, and a Fib retracement on the higher timeframe from HH to LL to know where it could pullback.

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Here are two Fibs drawn up.  The first one does not look right at all.  You could say that's five waves up with an extended fifth followed by 'one heck of a complex correction'.  If so, the first one has the Fib drawn from the start of wave 1 to the top of wave five.  So there's another a second chart with the Fib drawn from the bottom of wave four and it looks better.  Right?  So you'd look for it go retrace down to 7526?

EUR_GBP_20200217_00_24.thumb.png.771a604dba0418224eae35a77cb86b1f.png

EUR_GBP_20200217_00.24(1).thumb.png.b1dbb7f14c29c1b7c387f569749f0a64.png

Link to comment
1 hour ago, oxygen4life said:

Fibonacci only works in trending markets. Fibonacci correctly predicted the 2017 pullback as it was trending upwards, however the market started ranging afterwards with no clear direction. Bollinger bands are better suited for ranging markets.

Like this?

316770737_Germany30_20200217_03_21.thumb.png.25f7311d798707157d4e383b6dc3f5a7.png

 

Edited by dmedin
Link to comment
  • 2 months later...

Hi - Late to the thread!

I use Fib and 8ths in my analysis - not for predictive ability but just to see if the market is making moves that are near key natural mathematical  laws/ratios

I've never found acceptable predictability in Fib retracements or Extensions for my style

I've spoken personally to many of the worlds top Fibonacci traders and asked them outright which is the next key level exactly that will be hit and stops the market dead - none of them can say with certainty - that was enough for me to stop investigating further way back in 2010.

Thomas Bulowski has tested hundreds of methods out there on his site he lists the probability of those methods, here's the links to Fib retracements:

http://thepatternsite.com/fib.html

http://thepatternsite.com/FibonacciTargets.html

  • Like 1
Link to comment
10 minutes ago, THT said:

I've never found acceptable predictability in Fib retracements or Extensions for my style

Elliot Wave is attractive because it offers a way to describe and view wave structure, the Fibs on their own don't really help

Link to comment

Same response for EW - I studied it for a long time - I think and this is from memory it'**** rate was 50% ish - a coin toss has a 50% hit rate.

the main EW firm have been calling wave 5 of 5 since 1986, which means that for 34 years their assessment of the overall S&P500 has been wrong, I remember in 2003 them calling for massive lows and again in 2009 - If it worked perfectly it would be really useful - once you start labelling swing highs and lows you mentally submit to being right on them

 Best Information I've ever come across is from WD GANN from 100 years ago

  • Like 1
Link to comment
  • 5 months later...
6 hours ago, dmedin said:

Once again my mind cycles round to this idea of understanding wave structure and how Fibonacci ratios aren't useful on their own.

But then I open up that book by Precther and Frost, and then I remember why I didn't go any further with EWP.

EWP does NOT work  - They've been calling for a top and decline to near 0 since 1986!!!!!

Certain things in EWP do work though and can be used to profit from the markets

Again there's a massive myth about Fib Rets and Ext's - sometimes they work, often they don't, that in itself tells you something is amiss - but again they can be used to profit from the markets

I would look at the 50% ret level which is not a fib level, its a gann level - Hence why the market came to a smack bang stop around that level in the 1960's, 70's, 2003 and 2009

If all you ever did was trade Elliott Wave 2's which are in fact Gann's Secondary reactions (gann wrote about them 1st) you do rather well

  • Like 1
  • Great! 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • image.png

  • Posts

    • The year has seen record highs for US, Japanese, European and UK stock markets, among others. How should investors and traders react? Source: Getty Images   Shares Stock market Stock United States Investor Investment Written by: Chris Beauchamp | Chief Market Analyst, London   Publication date: Monday 20 May 2024 13:36 While many investors may feel nervous about the potential for a fall, historical analysis shows that investing when the stock market is at an all-time high can actually be a profitable strategy in the medium to long-term. The US stock market hits new all-time highs more frequently than one might expect, with new records being set in 30% of months since 1926. On average, 12-month returns following an all-time high have been 10.3% above inflation, better than the 8.6% for periods not at new highs. No need to fear new highs The impact of avoiding the market after new highs can be severely detrimental to long-term wealth creation. Data from Schroders shows that a $100 investment in the US stock market in January 1926 would be worth $85,008 by the end of 2023 in inflation-adjusted terms, representing a 7.1% annualised return. However, a strategy that switched to cash whenever the market hit a new high would have resulted in a much lower terminal value of just $8,790 – 90% less. Short-term picture more mixed No investing strategy works 100% of the time. New highs are often followed up by other record highs, but pullbacks are a feature, not a bug, of even the strongest market rallies. Some are short-lived, such as the recent April pullback in US indices, but others can go on for much longer. If a trader’s horizon is more short-term, then it is prudent to make sure they are following the price trend in their chosen timeline, but also the longer-term trend. All-time highs not a reason to turn bearish While feelings of nervousness are normal when stock markets reach unprecedented levels, historical data clearly demonstrates that there is no rational reason to fear investing during periods of all-time highs. The market setting new record levels should not, in itself, deter investors from participating in equity markets. Other valid considerations may exist, but the all-time high level alone is not a justifiable reason to dislike stocks.     This information has been prepared by IG, a trading name of IG Markets Limited. In addition to the disclaimer below, the material on this page does not contain a record of our trading prices, or an offer of, or solicitation for, a transaction in any financial instrument. IG accepts no responsibility for any use that may be made of these comments and for any consequences that result. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information. Consequently any person acting on it does so entirely at their own risk. Any research provided does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and needs of any specific person who may receive it. It has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is considered to be a marketing communication. Although we are not specifically constrained from dealing ahead of our recommendations we do not seek to take advantage of them before they are provided to our clients. See full non-independent research disclaimer and quarterly summary.
    • FTSE 100, DAX 40 and S&P 500 head back towards record highs Outlook on FTSE 100, DAX 40 and S&P 500 amid BoE and Fed talk. Source: Getty Images Written by: Axel Rudolph FSTA | Senior Financial Analyst, London   Publication date: Monday 20 May 2024 13:38 FTSE 100 tries to reach last week’s record highs The FTSE 100 is gunning for last week’s record high at 8,479 with the psychological 8,500 mark remaining in sight as several Bank of England (BoE) members will be speaking in the course of this week. Upside pressure will be maintained while last week’s low at 8,393 underpins on a daily chart closing basis. Source: ProRealTime DAX 40 consolidates below record high Last week the DAX 40 hit a record high close to the minor psychological 19,000 mark before slipping and forming a bearish engulfing pattern on the daily candlestick chart which was followed by a drop to Friday’s low at 18,627. This increased the likelihood of at least a short-term bearish reversal being seen over the coming days, even though on Monday a minor recovery rally is currently taking place. Since last week’s high hasn’t been accompanied by a higher reading of the daily Relative Strength Index (RSI), negative divergence can be seen. It may lead to a several hundred points sell-off taking the index back to its April-to-May uptrend line at 18,464. For this scenario to become more probable a fall through last week’s low at 18,623 would need to be seen, though. Source: ProRealTime S&P 500 eyes last week’s record high The S&P 500’s rally from its early May low has taken it to last week’s record high at 5,326 before pausing amid Fed comments making it clear that the battle against inflation hasn’t been won yet. Further Fed commentary by several voting members is in the pipeline for Monday. The previous record high made in April at 5,274 acted as support on Friday when the S&P 500 dipped to 5,284 before heading back up again. As long as the accelerated uptrend line at 5,286 holds, upside pressure should remain in play. Were a new all-time high to be made, the 5,350 region would be in focus. Source: ProRealTime
    • Gold price reaches new record high, WTI crude price and natural gas price also rally Gold has surged to a new high, and both oil and natural gas prices are rising once again. Source: Getty Images Written by: Chris Beauchamp | Chief Market Analyst, London   Publication date: Monday 20 May 2024 13:26 Gold hits new record The price surged to a new record high on Monday, pushing towards $2450. Further strong buying by Asian governments and consumers continues to support the price, which formed a higher low in late April and early May. Additional upside momentum could drive the price on towards the $2500 level, the next big psychological mark. In the short-term, a close back below $2400 might indicate some consolidation is at hand. Source: ProRealTime WTI pushes above 200-day moving average Oil continues to recover, and WTI has pushed back above the 200-day simple moving average (SMA). A close above the 200-day SMA then leads the price to target trendline resistance from the April highs, and the $81.15 lows from late April. A reversal back below $79 might suggest that the price will move back to retest the recent lows. Source: ProRealTime Natural Gas surges Natural gas prices continue to make huge strides and are now rapidly closing in on the highs from mid-January. There seems to be little sign of any possible near-term reversal at present, though some consolidation after such big gains would not be surprising. Additional upside targets the 2900 and the 3000 levels, followed up by the January high at 3121. Source: ProRealTime
×
×
  • Create New...
us