Jump to content
  • 0

non-professional account went sub-zero; then bank transfer request was cancelled to cover sub-zero losses. is that OK? what about negative balance protections


rilski

Question

Hey guys,

I have been doing some spread betting over the last few years but don't have a professional investors account. Ups and downs however made some good profits over the last 12 months. I've made one risky investment recently and it went wrong. I had some guarantees (about £6k) on the account which were not enough to cover the losses on that day (about £7k) and I had no stop loss in place.  I've requested the available funds to be withdrawn before market opened to limit exposure and potentially trigger the margin calls a bit earlier on the day when I lost the money. I was also hoping that as a non-professional account I would get negative balance protection. However that wasn't the case. IG  cancelled the withdrawal request and used the money to offset the losses and had no explanation fo what happened on that day. My spread betting account is now having 0 balance as of today.

I am not moaning about the losses or decisions made. I like making risks every now and then. Just want to make sure if what IG did was legitimate. Never had a call or an email from them to explain what happened on that day. And also no explanations on the negative balance protections.

Please advise if anyone had a similar experience. 

Thanks!

Link to comment

7 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0
On 15/02/2021 at 15:27, rilski said:

Hey guys,

I have been doing some spread betting over the last few years but don't have a professional investors account. Ups and downs however made some good profits over the last 12 months. I've made one risky investment recently and it went wrong. I had some guarantees (about £6k) on the account which were not enough to cover the losses on that day (about £7k) and I had no stop loss in place.  I've requested the available funds to be withdrawn before market opened to limit exposure and potentially trigger the margin calls a bit earlier on the day when I lost the money. I was also hoping that as a non-professional account I would get negative balance protection. However that wasn't the case. IG  cancelled the withdrawal request and used the money to offset the losses and had no explanation fo what happened on that day. My spread betting account is now having 0 balance as of today.

I am not moaning about the losses or decisions made. I like making risks every now and then. Just want to make sure if what IG did was legitimate. Never had a call or an email from them to explain what happened on that day. And also no explanations on the negative balance protections.

Please advise if anyone had a similar experience. 

Thanks!

you need to hold them accountable. They scam clients then frustrate clients with their responses when client is trying to follow up. They want you to let go. Don't let it go, sue them.

Link to comment
  • 0

I would suspect you'll find that IG stopping you trying to withdraw funds already in your account to protect them from being used to cover your losses is entirely legitimate. Apart from what was already held in your account (i.e. the 6K), have you been asked to pay anything over and above that figure to cover the difference of what was lost (i.e the 7K losses minus the 6K already in your account)? If so, then you might have a case as you then are being actively asked to pay the negative balance from other sources. Saying that, I'm no legal expert, so probably best to seek professional advice if you feel you have been treated unfairly.

Edited by Fletch
correction
Link to comment
  • 0

i can imagine what you are going through as i myself had a 25K loss couple of months back due to bad management. its very easy for the mind to be clouded. 

we do know that the withdrawal process is not instant and could take 1-2 business days. also you could have moved part of your the funds to your shares dealing account (or even CFD) from the SB account to keep it safe temporarily from exposure from existing positions. 

Link to comment
  • 0
4 hours ago, Joo said:

If you went negative it's normal that your withdrawal was cancelled ! You can't withdraw money that you don't have.

Seems likely - there has to be a line somewhere - otherwise they would specifically have an overdrafts team - which would be a time/cost ie loss maker for IG and as 70+% non pro trades are non profitable would rack up losses for IG -  which ultimately would be the end of IG!!!  - OK a bit far fetched but a fail safe so IG DON'T GO DOWN THE PAIN  is what everyone  NEEDS.

 

Edited by David30b
not finished
Link to comment
  • 0
On 15/02/2021 at 13:27, rilski said:

Hey guys,

I have been doing some spread betting over the last few years but don't have a professional investors account. Ups and downs however made some good profits over the last 12 months. I've made one risky investment recently and it went wrong. I had some guarantees (about £6k) on the account which were not enough to cover the losses on that day (about £7k) and I had no stop loss in place.  I've requested the available funds to be withdrawn before market opened to limit exposure and potentially trigger the margin calls a bit earlier on the day when I lost the money. I was also hoping that as a non-professional account I would get negative balance protection. However that wasn't the case. IG  cancelled the withdrawal request and used the money to offset the losses and had no explanation fo what happened on that day. My spread betting account is now having 0 balance as of today.

I am not moaning about the losses or decisions made. I like making risks every now and then. Just want to make sure if what IG did was legitimate. Never had a call or an email from them to explain what happened on that day. And also no explanations on the negative balance protections.

Please advise if anyone had a similar experience. 

Thanks!

 

On 18/02/2021 at 17:37, nkwe said:

you need to hold them accountable. They scam clients then frustrate clients with their responses when client is trying to follow up. They want you to let go. Don't let it go, sue them.

Thanks for your post. 

You can't withdraw most of your funds before market open and when the market opens and moves against you ask IG to cover all of the losses incurred by those positions. That's taking advantage of the debt coverage brokers take on for retail clients. 

Reversing your withdrawal is legitimate and allowed in this situation. 

Any losses that weren't covered by your reversed withdrawal we will cover (to bring your account out of a negative balance and back to £0). You will be able to see how much IG covered/lost by checking your history. It will be called 'account adjustment'. 

All the best 

  • Like 1
Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      20,765
    • Total Posts
      89,756
    • Total Members
      40,665
    • Most Online
      7,522
      10/06/21 10:53

    Newest Member
    Trader11
    Joined 06/12/22 23:50
  • Posts

    • Elliott Wave Analysis TradingLounge Daily Chart, 7 December 2022, Bitcoin / U.S.Dollar (BTCUSD) BTCUSDElliott Wave Technical Analysis Function:Follow trend Mode:Motive Structure:Impulse Position: Wave ((3)) Direction Next higher Degrees: wave I of Motive Details: Rise an uptrend in wave 3, Wave 3 is usually 1.618 or 2.618 x the length of wave 1 Wave Cancel invalid level:15479 Bitcoin / U.S.Dollar (BTCUSD) Trading Strategy: Bitcoin price remains under heavy sellpressure below the MA200 MA50 indicating a strong downtrend. The wave oscillator isbelow the zero line with decreasing momentum. but still The price tends to bottom as thestructure of the 5th wave. has already ended at the level of 15479, therefore it is likely toreverse again. And the price is expected to trade above 21437, but not below 15479.Overall, we still need to trade cautiously as there is still periodic selling pressure. Bitcoin / U.S.Dollar (BTCUSD) Technical Indicators: The price is below the MA200 MA50,indicating a clear downtrend. The Wave oscillator is below the Zero-Line is a bearishmomentum TradingLounge Analyst: Kittiampon Somboonsod Source : Tradinglounge.com get trial here!     Elliott Wave Analysis TradingLounge 4H Chart, 7 December 2022, Bitcoin / U.S.Dollar (BTCUSD) BTCUSDElliott Wave Technical Analysis Function:Follow trend Mode:Motive Structure:Impulse Position: Wave 1 Direction Next higher Degrees: Wave 1 of Motive Details: Sub-wave 1 of wave 3 and Once complete, the price will drop again in wave 2. Wave Cancel invalid level:16017 Bitcoin / U.S.Dollar (BTCUSD) Trading Strategy: Bitcoin price remains under heavy sellpressure below the MA200 indicating a strong downtrend. The wave oscillator is below thezero line with decreasing momentum. but still The price tends to bottom as the structure ofthe 5th wave. has already ended at the level of 15479, therefore it is likely to reverse again.And the price is expected to trade above 21437, but not below 15479. Overall, we still needto trade cautiously as there is still periodic selling pressure. Bitcoin / U.S.Dollar (BTCUSD) Technical Indicators: The price is below the MA200,indicating a downtrend. The Wave oscillator has a Bearish divergence Price reversal.
    • 06 December 2022 Spot Gold The price of gold did extend its move higher reaching our 1805 resistance target before finding resistance and once again starting to retrace. The moving averages suggest keeping a long bias to trades on the commodity. We are waiting for the current pullback to end with a bullish candle stick pattern before looking to find long entry once again. This is provided that the pullback does not extend past (close below) the 1735 support level. In this scenario, 1805 provides the initial upside resistance target, a break of which would further target the 1875 level.   Brent Crude Oil The price of brent crude oil could not break resistance at 8770 and has instead retraced back to support between levels 8220 and 8080. It appears time now for the commodity price to either break or bounce off the 8080-support level. A close below this level would consider a downside breakout and target a move to 7630. A bullish candle stick reversal (before a downside break occurs) would instead target a move back to 8770, while a close below the reversal low could be used as a stop loss indication in this scenario.         Our weekly technical report is compiled by in-house senior market analyst, Shaun Murison.
    • There was some exceptional volatility last week and the hints of tentative trend developments – most notably a breakdown of the Dollar and attempted rally for US indices. Yet, those moves have abated to start the new week with data and technical levels playing a bigger role in market conviction.        
×
×
  • Create New...