Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

My Buy in Price becomes the Pivot Point 100% of the time

Recommended Posts

Hi, maybe I've got a bit of cabin fever staring at charts for the last month while I'm learning, but I swear....I swear, 80-100% of the time, my Buy In Price becomes the point of change, either Reversal, Horizontal or acts as the future Resistance going either Long or Short.

Is it my head?  I've been trading Spot Gold for the past week.  Lost around £200 on a £1400 account.  Went back to the Demo and proved 8 straight wins for £300.  Went back to Live, lost £200.
 

Even today, I've been stuck in Spot Gold since 10.41am UK time.  it's now 16.30! and it's gone back up bounced of my Buy in Price at 1295 ish, and gone back down to previous 1290 support.    £5per point!!!  It turned after a clear upward trend had started and gone down to 1290 support and back up and back down.  Almost every trade i have tried has done this.

What am I missing?  Volume?  Computers? The only daft lad trading Spot Gold??  

Share this post


Link to post

@nit2wynit,

To try and assist you and get to the bottom of your problem one needs to understand how you are trading Gold.

What indicators are you using to determine entering a trade?

Are you a swing trader, trend follower, momentum trader, etc?

What timeframe do you use?

There are many questions I could ask but we can start here and see where this discussion leads. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Hi guys.

I watch the Daily for the trend.  Then each time segment going down to see what the colour of the candle is, then adjust based upon the most recent 5 minute and then back to the weekly to see if there's a larger pattern and a trend reversal due.  I also check the news.  When I've decided I use the 1 minute to buy in. then sit back to the 5min to keep an eye on it.  I think with the Gold I was dealing at times with too little volume.  Often below 100 per minute.  I'd bet on it, it changes every single time I get involved.!  I'd make more money betting against' myself lol.

I've made mistakes starting out with a £1400 account to use around 90% of my buying power.  However i wasn't allowing for volatility or movement so was getting stopped out often.  I adjusted this to allow for a 3pt deviation (£15pp on Spot Gold=£45) but this clearly wasn't enough room, and now decided I'd need at least 5pt.  My timing was well off.  At first I was watching the 1min chart too closely and as soon as I saw a spike, I'd jump in, only for it to drop down and quite often reverse, or go sideways.  To keep this short I basically made all the obvious mistakes!  I've written several A4 pages of notes on my dealings and learned a lot about what I am doing wrong.  But it is uncanny.  Really uncanny, how many times my Buy in becomes the Resistance.  However, on my most recent it was £1295, so I've put this one down to the Dead Man zone of Spot Gold and what has happened over the last month.

Don't get me wrong.  I have made gains of £25, £50, £80 or so, here and there but lost it again.

I've 1k left.    My new strategy, is to bid smaller, and longer.  I will be Trend Following for the Day, and not trying to make larger amounts quicker.  I just want my account back to £1400.

As for Indicators etc.  I only really use Volume first (Patterns being a Pre-Requisite) observe Break Out potential, plot my Support and Resistance, then wait for the chance to get in.


The most recent Learn I have is that the charts are looking at the past!  I've no Idea how far in the past; assuming only seconds, but probably far enough that it makes it too difficult to make large gain in short time, that I must go long when Spread Betting.

Share this post


Link to post

@nit2wynit,  it's a learning curve, we all know. Using my process this is how I would have described gold on that Friday morning.;

Daily; Look at chart structure then look at yesterday's candle.

The higher high, higher low pattern has broken down so the market is no longer trending, stick to trending charts, look at yesterday's candle, major bear strength, don't try to fight it.

The overall look of the chart and yesterday's candle are shouting out that the bears are gearing up for a major try on that support level, trying longs - definitely not here, maybe on a bounce up off 1280 but not here.

image.thumb.png.f2258242d5a40a67b365701735be4b47.png

The H1; and I would see most likely scenario after that strong impulse move down is a pullback and another push down to challenge support, not looking for longs. 

image.thumb.png.9971327ab0ff492a40581118ca1d0476.png

I wouldn't even bother looking at the 5 min because I know major support is just below so the chart structure has ruled out longs (bear strength) and shorts (reward not big enough for the risk), look for another market.

The candles are stamped in the now, indicators compare now to the past, volume is a difficult one to use because it often smolders before igniting. Chart structure is more important anyway and shows what the big players are planing.

If you are constantly trying to catch breakouts you will usually get caught out buying the high or selling the low, that's just how they work, the rewards can be big but the strike rate of timing them right is only 2 out of ten, unless you are playing on a large time frame chart with a massive stop.

Settle on one setup (btfd in a trend) and practice it over and over until you are good at it, then maybe look at adding another type of setup.

(Buy the Failed Dip in uptrend, or sell the failed rally in downtrend).

Decide your basic plan for the session before hand using the higher time frames to to give a sense of bull and bear strength, go with the flow rather than looking for reversals.

 

 

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Excellent advice @Caseynotes  Thanks for taking the time.  I'll certainly take another look at it.

Do you have any advice on what I should be going for with a small account?  I don't mean specific stock, just the price range etc.?  Any constant Trenders etc.

I'm looking to start the week slowly.  I'm being realistic and hoping to slowly climb with £25 per day wins.  Maybe even this is over reaching?

Share this post


Link to post

@nit2wynit,  as you see, not getting trapped on entry is crucial, so you need to get good fast and that's why you should concentrate on just one setup first, that means using one setup on multiple charts rather than trying to play multiple setups on one chart. 

So get all the daily fx majors charts up plus some major indices, quick scan them all once a day and note which are trending, now you have a few charts and you know the direction so use support and resistance to plot likely targets.

Of those trending, on the H1 - M5 look throughout the day for weakening pullbacks, you are looking for the pullback bars to get smaller (weaker) and trend bars to start making an appearance, the point is you know what you are looking for and roughly where it should occur. Before entry find your stop loss level first. On the smaller charts there will be a level that the pullback simply cannot pass and then the trend bars start getting stronger, the actual bar of your entry is not as important as the identification of that stop loss level.

It's a bit like picking breakouts in reverse, price can't go beyond that level no matter how many times it trys and now the trend bars are getting too strong.

When only looking at small time frame charts you so easy get lost but by having a basic plan such as above you know what you are looking for, if you don't see it stay out, no harm done.

The more time you have the closer you can drill down and observe and so the tighter (and cheaper) your stops can be. Everyone is going to be different.

Share this post


Link to post

@nit2wynit,

You may be interested in reading my 'Potential Long Gold Trade' thread. There may be snippets in there which could possibly be of interest to you.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Is it safe to assume that the price feed in live and demo accounts is identical?

Share this post


Link to post
5 minutes ago, dmedin said:

Is it safe to assume that the price feed in live and demo accounts is identical?

yes, it's just that occasional glitches occur on demo that may affect the feed, all brokers who have developed a platform have an identical demo platform primarily for testing, sometimes the tests fail, they also allow clients to use it to practice on.

Share this post


Link to post

Ive found no discernible difference using the Demo from the Live account, except the irrational buy and sell impulses that go with an almost unlimited account.  I now try to use the Demo not to practice the charts and placing the bet, but practice my own patience and to treat it as if it is real money.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

@nit2wynit,

I think Caseynotes mentioned this in either this thread or another but I agree with him. For new and inexperienced traders it may be a good idea to bet the smallest amount you can in a live account and build those positions up by adding to them should the trade move in your favour (direction). This will help to build your confidence and allow you to really monitor the price action and try and understand why it is moving the way it is. 

However, I would like to add that before you do this make sure you select your asset to trade wisely. Make sure you entry point is thought through carefully. If certain indicators are not met then you should seriously consider waiting patiently until they before entering any trade. 

Sometimes the wisest thing to do is nothing. Do not feel obliged to place a trade. Make sure the conditions and set up are in your favour based on your trading strategy and system. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, please sign in.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      6,938
    • Total Posts
      33,027
    • Total Members
      42,825
    Newest Member
    mziadawood
    Joined 26/06/19 12:22
  • Posts

    • On another thread which @cryptotraderstarted @wjw22 commented that Bitcoin is not money. Money is something that can be transferred or used in exchange for goods and services. Bitcoin (though not widely accepted - in fact miniscule acceptance at this stage compared to FIAT) can be exchanged for goods and services in certain places across the globe.  They then go on to state that Bitcoin is not a store of value. These are just words. Since Bitcoin's inception in 2009 if you invested £1000 of your hard money into both Bitcoin and Gold then Bitcoin would have proved to be the better store of value than Gold. This is even after numerous 70% to 80% corrections! Bitcoin is not only the best performing asset in the whole world in 2019 but it is the better store of value since its inception. If @wjw22 has any evidence to support otherwise then please do provide.  They then state Bitcoin is a Ponzi and a pyramid scheme. Again these are just words. The European Commission, UK Government and many large Government and corporations are looking at Cryptocurrencies and how it can be applied in certain jurisdictions across the globe. We are at a very early stage. These things take a lot of time. Evidence from a credible source needs to be provided to support such statements as otherwise they are just words which originate from bias, ego, stubbornness, etc.  @cryptotrader, in case why you are wondering why I am not responding to your thread, it is because I want to avoid any aggressive discussions and arguments. We all have different levels of understanding and experience in this area. We all read different literature and research papers on this area. We all have different levels of knowledge in this area. Another reason is because I have done what you have a year or two ago in either this thread or the Blockchain Trilogy thread, cannot remember and it is pointless unless there are balanced arguments presented with credible evidence from credible sources.  People first compared Bitcoin to the Tulip Mania. Now that it has blasted through that people are now comparing it to the Internet boom and bust. Why must we compare it to anything? The Bitcoin boom and bust and boom again could be new future being created without any copying of past historical incidents. Future performance does not have to be based on past historical performance. From time to time new history is created that is different from the past. Bitcoin is a new asset and a new revolution which will create a new history and a new future.  Now @cryptotrader your thread was about Bitcoin specifically based on your title. Not about Cryptocurrencies in general. Yes a lot of Cryptocurrencies are junk. If Bitcoin's store of value is laughable then its store of value performance in terms of protecting capital and increase the value of the capital is astonishing when compared to Gold in the same period of time since Bitcoin's inception. Someone is buying Bitcoin hence the price is going up. A normal person does not need buy one Bitcoin at $13000. They can buy a fraction of it using FIAT money. That is the beauty. Countries like China and Russia want to end the US Dollar being the Reserve Currency. It is unlikely that the world will go back to the Gold standard. In this coming 'Digital Revolution' Bitcoin is one of the favourite to be groomed as the worlds first digital reserve currency which is not linked to any one specific country like the US. During US-North Korea, Bitcoin went up more than Gold. During US-Iran tensions, Bitcoin went up more than Gold. Therefore times are changing. People and countries do not want to store their money in something which can be manipulated by central governments and priced in US Dollars. Times are changing and power is shifting from the west to the east and countries like Japan have embraced Cryptocurrencies. I respect the views of others but what tends to happen is that if someone is negative towards Bitcoin then they highlight the negative and do not offer a balanced argument. Likewise if someone is positive towards Bitcoin then they do not highlight the negatives. Even I am guilty of that. I accept there are negatives and flaws in Bitcoin and other Crypto's.  
    • @cryptotrader wrote (in Silver Bullet thread): "I've always thought that cryptos are completely unrelated to other asset types which is why they're so difficult to price. Everything else has the inter-connectivity between themselves (Fed IR effect USD 'value', which knocks on to USD denominated assets, which leads into equities, re-positioning etc) but always thought crypto is a world unto its own. Linked to cost of production - electricity, CPU costs etc." I think the notion that crypto is something apart from the rest of the financial world is a concept that pervaded the first internet boom; the idea that the internet was going to change the nature of business and society by providing free access to everything and there for traditional business models would fail.  Instead the first internet boom failed, well hardly surprising as all those budding entrepreneurs forgot that you have to make money by charging for goods or services to become a millionaire (although a few clearly did purely off the back of selling out early enough - which is a watch out now on crypto for anyone invested for the long term).  Out of the ashes rose the second internet (or tech) boom but interestingly the winners were those that effectively adopted traditional business models (i.e. the need to make profits and generate positive cashflows - duh!).  The share prices are now massively over inflated of course but that is just financial market forces (the markets can remain irrational longer than we can remain solvent, kind of thing) rather than anything intrinsically wrong with their business models.  Now that these businesses are profitable and hold masses of cash (masses!!!) they can withstand a major downturn, perhaps better than some other more traditional sectors, and be positioned well for the eventual recovery.  It is this recover where I think we will see the really discontinuous tech disruption, the next leap forward.  This is what happened after the first internet bubble burst.  It is after the crash and clear out that we will see Crypto, or rather the blockchain type technology, become mainstream in terms of replacing physical cash, this is the end game, not some nirvana of a non FIAT collective new age hippie dippy free of politics currency (or set of currencies) that everyone will use free of government control - you might as well just howl at the moon as think that is ever going to happen. As regards you comment about Crypto being apart, well how do you buy or invest in Crypto?  With cash of course.  And how it is currently "valued" in the markets?  In USD, hmm... The real problems at present for Crypto, and the reasons it will all end in tears until the next iteration are (for me): There are too many Cryptos, until it is mainstream (i.e. the tech backing electronic FIAT currency, which is the root of the concept of currency right back to the earliest days of non precious metal currency (i.e. the right to exchange a paper bill for gold) it is the wild west. Ordinary people are not using Crypto as a currency, it does not have wide adoption It will not get wide adoption until it is better understood and backed by something normal people recognise as sound (i.e. governments) There isn't sufficient liquidity for wide adoption and consequently the price of a bitcoin is too high for a normal person to use it (similar problem with Gold BTW, which is why I prefer Silver for true disaster insurance and consequently hold physical silver coins) The price is too high and too volatile, it is in the hands of speculators - hence it is a mania The idea that Crypto is a store of value is laughable.  When the $£!& hits the fan people will buy Gold and Silver and USD and Yen, things they understand and can cling to in an uncertain world.  They will not buy bitcoin.  Even if they wanted to how can any normal person buy bitcoin at $50,000 per coin?  Barking mad the whole thing - but this is what I expect at the end of the cycle so carry..!    
    • Unfortunately i am no longer able to continue giving these updates. Alas our fun journey ends here, my fingernails are intact @Caseynotes, lol I will be here still in the forums. Thanks all for your input. DJ  
×
×