Jump to content

Do higher minimum stops prevent trading

Recommended Posts

Hi all, I used very tight stop losses which means for example like today the min stop requirement moved from the standard 4 to 12 points. This basically prevents me trading while this is in place. It's a frustration but is it a bad thing? Perhaps I should take the view that the market is too volatile and just wait it out. Some would think though that this is the right time to be trading. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
41 minutes ago, u0362565 said:

Some would think though that this is the right time to be trading. 

just need to look at the long wicks top and bottom during high vol to see small players being squeezed out, better to wait for calm.

  • Great! 1

Share this post


Link to post
58 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

just need to look at the long wicks top and bottom during high vol to see small players being squeezed out, better to wait for calm.

Thanks, I'd like to use a wider stop to be honest but just can't make the numbers add up. Just not got the capital to play with.

Share this post


Link to post

They would stop me from trading - the market HAS to conform to my parameters not the other way around as I need the edge, altering parameters and stops removes part of your edge

On many of my trades it takes 2 attempts to enter a position, due to having a tight stop - but I have a R profit value return that caters for that

 

Share this post


Link to post
41 minutes ago, THT said:

They would stop me from trading - the market HAS to conform to my parameters not the other way around as I need the edge, altering parameters and stops removes part of your edge

On many of my trades it takes 2 attempts to enter a position, due to having a tight stop - but I have a R profit value return that caters for that

 

That sounds like a good mentality to have I'll remember that. Of course it also possible to look at other markets but I'm concentrating on one right now, perhaps results would be similar on others but would want to test first to have some stats.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

hi all I have found tight stops prevent a potentially profitable trade , for example / I decide to enter a long trade at £5/point,  I enter the trade on the one hour time frame ,  place a stop loss on the 4 hour time frame then place a take profit sell stop on the daily time frame once I have done my analysis and figured out where price may top out that day , I do not take more than a £500 loss on any trade , if I have stop loss too tight lets say £150 general market volitivity and noise may stop me out before the trade goes in my direction , views and opinions on this would ne most welcome

Share this post


Link to post

For me your stop is large, I use close to the minimum for the market. But I think same applies. I think basically I like tight stops because you can't lose too much but when you win hopefully you win big relative to that. I've been using a 4:1 reward/risk ratio for example.  When I started out I thought the likelihood of pulling this off given how close the stop was to entry was unlikely but actually it does happen fairly often. The issue I have is that I average a win every 4 trades so essentially make nothing in the end but that's just my mean, I have a massive standard deviation that I need to get way down i.e. increase win rate if possible before this is useful. So for me I think I need better timing signals to enter and I enter too readily without really using indicators to help me.

To be honest though what I've found which might be obvious to most is that if the market trends for a period of time it's much easier to make money. When it isn't it's very difficult, the problem is you often don't know when it's not trending to a large enough degree until you're in it and then you need to know to take some time and return later. Like sailing with a strong wind and then all of a sudden it's doldrums.

Share this post


Link to post

I would have thought the main thing preventing trading is the fact that the vast majority of retail traders lose money.

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Topics
      12,742
    • Total Posts
      65,414
    • Total Members
      86,176
    Newest Member
    rpd2
    Joined 20/10/20 20:14
  • Posts

    • this probably should have been ignored, but IMHO it was a new low.  obviously jlz tried to help someone here, and referred to others to add emphasis to a point.  I'm writing this because I actually asked for support in my earlier response, and I'm very pleased I'm not the only one who reacted to this post thoughtfully, so I think it would be pretty weak if I didn't speak up here. That may make me look ridiculous, and like my tongue is now travelling through a bunch of cracks, but I don't give a **** (like I think you would not either).    I'm actually surprised that you @dmedin  left it to this statement - usually you're significantly more effective in warning people of the hazards we face as retail punters IMHO - I think you definitely had stronger moments. you know what I would find useful:  having a separate, focused thread for insults  - I'm sure by now the respective targets wouldn't mind (to not again say not give a ****), and other discussions could become - let's say "leaner". I genuinely think I got a lot of valuable insights from many of your posts here, and I highly appreciate the honest feedback, and I also believe you have good intentions. I don't know about any history between you, jlz, THT, and Caseynotes.  I further think you play an important role here in this forum and I look forward to more productive discussions with you. But the post quoted above was a new low.     
    • Wall Street holding up still 🤔  
    • I'd given up on Dax but here it comes!  
×
×