Jump to content

Trade Planning and Testing


Recommended Posts

3 hours ago, Caseynotes said:

worked out the stats that predicts the success of that game plan over x number of plays, they play a numbers game

ūü§Ē

Reminds me of the 'probabilities' attached to Signal Centre trades, they say things like '70% certainty' and then the price goes in the totally opposite direction at least nine times out of ten.  :D

Edited by dmedin
Link to post
  • Replies 226
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

To make your trading plan and trade strategy just answer these questions then move on to the testing section below. 1/ TRADING PLAN a) System What type of trader will I be? Swing, trend trade

A few comments on the importance of execution.

see the importance of stats, without the full data picture you would have noticed that the win rate was low and just moved on to something else, forever going round in circles.

Posted Images

1 hour ago, dmedin said:

ūü§Ē

Reminds me of the 'probabilities' attached to Signal Centre trades, they say things like '70% certainty' and then the price goes in the totally opposite direction at least nine times out of ten.  :D

as explained earlier in the thread the cumulative risk reward ratio (auto calc'd on a spread sheet) plotted on the chart with the win rate is absolutely fool proof in revealing if a strategy is profitable of not. Also if you make any changes to the strategy the result will show up quickly in the stats so revealing whether the change was advantageous or not.

Without hard statistics people have a habit of misleading themselves as to how well they and their strategy are really doing.

  • Great! 1
Link to post
  • 3 weeks later...

Link to ebook library with 40 different trade execution strategies that may be worth trying out to see if are compatible with your trade plan if you are struggling to come up with ideas. 

Most will just take a simple eyeball backtest to judge if might suit your preferred markets and time frames.  

https://www.earnforex.com/forex-e-books/trading-strategy/

image.thumb.png.be814599f7b749419e4eff61eace0f1d.png

Link to post

This is what you look like when you jump into live trading without a tried and tested plan.

Are you really feeling that lucky?

atpandt1.thumb.png.0920538bf3c1f83c8a849dfa8e46ed1b.png

Perhaps better off by first looking at the start of this thread for a guide to defining your preferences, devising an appropriate plan and then the 3 key stages of testing that plan to give you the statistically backed edge you will need to survive and win.  

  • Great! 1
Link to post

Short video on the importance of recognised market levels and how to employ them in providing a rationale for a trade entry plus stops and targets.

The key to everything is to have risk defined in a process driven by a systematic approach before you even get in.

 

  • Thought provoking 1
Link to post
2 minutes ago, dmedin said:

Maybe this is something that's best left to the professionals.  I just feel worthless and inadequate.

I think I might have just spotted your problem, it's an 11 minute video and you've just responded to it less than 7 minutes after I posted it. 

Link to post
1 minute ago, Caseynotes said:

I think I might have just spotted your problem, it's an 11 minute video and you've just responded to it less than 7 minutes after I posted it. 

I just needed to look at the title and the introduction, it's the same thing as what's being said in 'Trading in the zone' - 'you need a winning attitude' - well in that case I'm f*ked :D  And I have no idea how you build a statistically valid system without doing proper statistical analysis, and if so then I will need to spend 6 - 12 months re-learning that stuff.  But I will watch it later when I have no 'work' to do (by work I mean filling out a spreadsheet and replying to emails)

Edited by dmedin
Link to post
5 minutes ago, dmedin said:

I just needed to look at the title and the introduction, it's the same thing as what's being said in 'Trading in the zone' - 'you need a winning attitude' - well in that case I'm f*ked :D  And I have no idea how you build a statistically valid system without doing proper statistical analysis, and if so then I will need to spend 6 - 12 months re-learning that stuff.  But I will watch it later when I have no 'work' to do (by work I mean filling out a spreadsheet and replying to emails)

no it's about using recognisable market levels to define risk so you don't keep watching trades reverse into big losses, something you repeatedly complain about.

Again I'm still not sure why you don't just read the OP of the thread, doing the stats is easy.

Link to post
3 hours ago, Caseynotes said:

I think I might have just spotted your problem, it's an 11 minute video and you've just responded to it less than 7 minutes after I posted it. 

The guy cherry picks (as does everyone when they post charts) an example where price bounced off an upper trend channel line and fell drastically, this does not happen very often and more often is simply moves sideways for a protected period of time after bouncing off a trend line.  Hence you lose money trying to go long or trying to go short.

Edited by dmedin
Link to post
1 minute ago, dmedin said:

The guy cherry picks (as does everyone when they post charts) an example where price bounced off an upper trend channel line and fell drastically, this does not happen very often and more often is simply moves sideways for a protected period of time after bouncing off a trend line.  Hence you lose money trying to go long or trying to go short.

err, when giving an example people tend to¬†show one that demonstrates the points they¬†are making rather than an example that doesn't, I don't know why they do that, it's just a thing they do¬†ūüôĄ

as usual you missed the gist of it, that shows sheer determination on your part so well done there.

If price breaks or reverses at a significant level the level can then become a reference for a stop loss point. With the stop loss defined you can then consider entry and realistic target points, ideally looking for a risk reward of a min of 1:2 (amount stop loss v amount gained).

Many traders have a win rate of only around 50%, that's fine so long as you are using the method above of first defining an approp stop then checking the distance to an approp target (>1:2) then looking for an entry point.

A consistent win rate of just 50% and a running RR of 1:2 is all you need. That's it, that's the goal. That's what you are supposed to be working towards.

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Great! 1
Link to post
  • 2 weeks later...

Excellent 15 min video testing a simple PSAR with moving average filters strategy. Also links to other strategy tests from the Youtube channel.

Reiterates the theme of this thread which is the importance of having statistical backup to your strategy which is what differentiates Trading from Gambling.

Uses the same methods as in this thread of taking the cumulative win/loss ratio to plot against the cumulative risk reward ratio to ascertain whether the strategy is valid or not.

 

Edited by Caseynotes
  • Great! 1
Link to post

I do like this guy's videos, there are only a few and they are all new (this year). This video looks at a simple intraday strategy using VWAP with an EMA filter.

All the videos are delivered in the computer generated modal voice that highlights the few but essential components that makes for successful trading, they are repeated over and over, you can't miss it, there is no confusion.

One of the vids looks at his process for trade selection but haven't found it again to post yet.

The link below is to the Youtube channel containing the vid collection.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgY_eHY4NCTcRnU6CCZXWng

 

Edited by Caseynotes
Link to post

Another great video from Trading Rush;

'How to Grow a Small Account'.

Concentrates on the core issues, the make or break. A simple viable repeatable system tested on demo that uses win rate and risk/reward management  as the key features to determine the validity of your system before trying it out on a live account.

But don't be like Bill, Bill is retarded.

 

Link to post

Here is the download link for the Trading Rush excel spreadsheet (will open in Open Office).

Though all the platforms now have their own format for auto trade record keeping some like to keep their own. This one is very simple and easy to fill in though unlike the one linked at the start of the thread doesn't calc running risk/reward, this one only does win rate, profit and equity graph.

https://hihacker.net/download-forex-trading-excel-sheet-and-stock-trading-excel-sheet/

image.thumb.png.794a0b7f66405fd4614fd9ec4daae978.png

Link to post
  • 2 weeks later...
On 05/05/2020 at 20:18, Caseynotes said:

Here is the download link for the Trading Rush excel spreadsheet (will open in Open Office).

Though all the platforms now have their own format for auto trade record keeping some like to keep their own. This one is very simple and easy to fill in though unlike the one linked at the start of the thread doesn't calc running risk/reward, this one only does win rate, profit and equity graph.

https://hihacker.net/download-forex-trading-excel-sheet-and-stock-trading-excel-sheet/

image.thumb.png.794a0b7f66405fd4614fd9ec4daae978.png

 

 

My trading performance has improved pretty drastically :D Hope it's not just a passing phase of good luck ūüėģ

  • Great! 1
Link to post

I can't believe that was 12 years ago.  Might as well have been a lifetime.  Reminds me of how Britain has always been grey and depressing.  Wish I could move to California.

Link to post

So if you are testing with a backtester or a simulator it becomes more of a game than work and of course is so much faster than manual testing.

In the pic below is a $100 simulator (one off payment and life long program and data updates) that runs on the MT4 platform as an EX4 expert.

It will run most custom indicators and there is the choice of a few different data providers (not IG), this is using Dukascopy data which covers decades right up to the previous week. This is a Dax chart from 18/07/2018. There is data available for a large number of FX pairs, indices, gold and oil.

On this chart I have Renko overlaid with Heikin Ashi and a simple MA crossover indicator (lines not drawn, crosses shown by dots).

On the control panel is the usual trade buttons (note this data has 3 decimal point so the pips number is pushed along 2 places so 1 pip becomes 100). You can slow it down or speed up, stop, go back bar by bar. Put orders in and trailing stops etc and it will make up reports for your test runs. 

Not just for test runs of course, can be used for general trading practice and can be set to any time frame so you could do a months worth of trading on a daily chart in just an hour or 2.

All in all a very useful time saving tool, not essential but worth the money for the ability to test strategies quickly alone.

image.thumb.png.97ad05a45ad45ef72fef4d5b06364309.png

  • Thought provoking 1
Link to post

Very good educational video on swing trading basics. Seems a little disjointed to begin with but ties up well into a complete package and shows how you should be planning each individual trade from start to finish before you even enter.

By Rayner Teo, those not used to his style might initially be put off but stick with it as he is a very good educator with over a hundred thousand views of this video which was published just over 3 weeks ago.

(30 min)

 

Link to post
  • 2 weeks later...

Good explanation of a simple intraday  trend following scalping strategy in this 15  min video which covers the 'must have' basics of trade entry and exits planned out before the trade entry. I haven't tested this exact strategy but it's very close to my own and looks very good.

 

  • Great! 1
Link to post
51 minutes ago, Caseynotes said:

Good explanation of a simple intraday  trend following scalping strategy in this 15  min video which covers the 'must have' basics of trade entry and exits planned out before the trade entry. I haven't tested this exact strategy but it's very close to my own and looks very good.

 

This is basically John Carters Propulsion trade set-up that he published in his book "Master the Trade" in the 2000's - Although the original method enters at the 8EMA with a 4% stop and 8% target for stocks and 1% stop and 2% target  for Index/forex

The money management is a little skewed in the video - It would make just as much sense getting out in full at T1, rather than selling 50% at T1 and the rest @ T2 as it's much easier to hit T1 than it is T2 for the same return

If it was me (and I DO trade this Propulsion set-up) I would trade in 2 units - sell 1 unit @ T1 and then trailing the remaining unit at a 2 or 3 trailing bar low as mentioned as it doesn't make sense selling at the 2 target levels he mentions as T2 is not always hit

  • Like 2
Link to post
1 minute ago, THT said:

This is basically John Carters Propulsion trade set-up that he published in his book "Master the Trade" in the 2000's - Although the original method enters at the 8EMA with a 4% stop and 8% target for stocks and 1% stop and 2% target  for Index/forex

The money management is a little skewed in the video - It would make just as much sense getting out in full at T1, rather than selling 50% at T1 and the rest @ T2 as it's much easier to hit T1 than it is T2 for the same return

If it was me (and I DO trade this Propulsion set-up) I would trade in 2 units - sell 1 unit @ T1 and then trailing the remaining unit at a 2 or 3 trailing bar low as mentioned as it doesn't make sense selling at the 2 target levels he mentions as T2 is not always hit

Thanks for the reference, I don't think I've heard of John Carter before, will have to look him up.

  • Like 1
Link to post

5 min charts and three pips stop loss is crazy, he must be a real trader with a huge balance to make that worthwhile.  But the strategy is okay :D

Edited by dmedin
Link to post
Just now, dmedin said:

5 min charts and three pips stop loss is crazy, he must be a real trader with a huge balance to make that worthwhile.

no, you weren't listening¬†ūüĎÄ, it was 3 pips beyond the marker, not 3 pips in total.

  • Great! 1
Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • General Statistics

    • Total Topics
      13,656
    • Total Posts
      68,264
    • Total Members
      57,144
    • Most Online
      5,137
      14/01/21 09:51

    Newest Member
    JamHar
    Joined 18/01/21 02:11
  • Posts

    • I'll try to be concise: Dent was in 2010 calling for the mother of all stock market crashes - so were Elliott Wave International in fact EWI have been call for a massive collapse since 1986!¬† Some of what he says is accurate - deflation for example - the reason QE has not caused inflation is because it was issued in a deflationary cycle The crash he talks about won't happen - I listened to dent and EWI back in 2010 and I choose to do my own research as other things i was investigating suggested the opposite to what they were both spouting Read my Time Cycles page, it explains the deflationary/inflationary cycles - proven with 220+ years of stock market history behind the reasoning The deflationary cycle he refers to ended late 2016, its now inflationary according to my calcs and research and my prediction is stock market is going upwards until the mid 2030's when it will crash and top out - yet Dent still thinks its in play Up until then we might get a 1987 style crash event but overall the corrections will be modest not massive and they will all be quickly surpassed I don't listen to anyone out there - I trade independently according to my methods so I don't need to be buying and holding and if I'm wrong so be it - it won't affect my trading as the market dictates my positions, not my expectations - since 2010 this has work exceptionally well, where if I'd of followed EWI and Dents forecasts I'd of lost everything in 2010! I've no thoughts on Gold other than it is inflationary hedge - as mentioned on another thread when the stock market is inflationary (which I think started 2017) then price correlation backwards to last time it was inflationary (1982-2000) gold was subdued ¬† ¬†
    • Thanks @Caseynotes. Do you think the time of the daily close bears any significance. When viewing the hourly charts, the volume and movements seem to be higher in GMT "working hours" and then slow down overnight. Therefore, are other countries trading on GMT I wonder?
    • Saw a snippet on Sky news complaining that¬†the Lateral Flow test must be¬†faulty because it wasn't picking up as many positives as the PCR. Quite an unbelievable misinterpretation of the data on the number of false positives made by the PCR. Not surprising really as the fake positive numbers generated by the PCR are¬†the only thing driving project fear and lockdowns. Meanwhile, in order to stem the flow of staff needing to self isolate¬†following a PCR false positive the NHS are switching to ...¬† er, the lateral flow test. ¬† ¬† ¬† ¬† Dr Clare Craig¬†¬†@ClareCraigPath Deaths are not climbing commensurate with cases. Either COVID got less deadly (despite inc hospital admissions) or we have two measure a) a community positive rate off the charts with false positives b) a hospital rate (likely to inc some real COVID) which is at a steady state ¬† ¬† .
×
×
  • Create New...